·º»ö¾ÚµòË¡
2022ǯ02·î22Æü
¡¡Æ£ÅÄÀ¯Çî´ØÀ¾Âç³Ø¶µ¼ø¡¢Â綶·¯Ê¿ÊÛ¸î»Î¡¢ÏÂÅÄ·ÃÊÛ¸î»Î¤È¶¦Ìõ¤Ç¡¢¥Þ¥¤¥±¥ë¡¦¥µ¥Ã¥¯¥¹¤È¥Ð¡¼¥Ð¥é¡¦¥¹¥Ú¥ë¥Þ¥ó¤Î¡Ø¾ÚµòË¡¤Î¿´Íý³ØŪ´ðÁá٤ò½ÐÈǤ·¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£
¡¡ÂÓ¤è¤ê¡§
¡¡¾ÚµòË¡¤Ï±þÍÑ¿´Íý³Ø¤À¡ª
¡¡¿´Íý³Ø¤¬²Ê³Ø¤È¤·¤ÆÀ®Î©¤¹¤ëÍÚ¤«°ÊÁ°¤«¤é¡¢²¤ÊƤÎË¡Áâ¤Ï¿´Íý³Ø¤ò¼ÂÁ©¤·¤Æ¤¤¿¡£Ëܽñ¤ÏºÇ¿·¤Î¿´Íý³ØŪÃ諤«¤é¡¢¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¾ÚµòË¡¤òÁǺà¤Ë¤¢¤ë¤Ù¤ºÛȽ¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ò¸¡¾Ú¤¹¤ë¡£¤µ¤é¤ËËܽñ¤Ï¡¢ÆüËܤο´Íý³Ø¤Ë¿·¤·¤¤¸¦µæʬÌî¤òÄ󶡤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¡¡ÆüËܤκÛȽ¤ËÀµ¤·¤¤¾ÚµòË¡¤ò¹½ÃÛ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤ËɬÆɤνñ¡£
Ë¡Áâ¤ä¿´Íý³Ø¸¦µæ¼Ô¤Ï¤â¤Á¤í¤ó¡¢ºÛȽ¤È¿´Íý³Ø¤Ë¶½Ì£¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Ù¤Æ¤Î¿Í¤Ë¤ª¤¹¤¹¤á¤·¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡¡ÂÓ¤è¤ê¡§
¡¡¾ÚµòË¡¤Ï±þÍÑ¿´Íý³Ø¤À¡ª
¡¡¿´Íý³Ø¤¬²Ê³Ø¤È¤·¤ÆÀ®Î©¤¹¤ëÍÚ¤«°ÊÁ°¤«¤é¡¢²¤ÊƤÎË¡Áâ¤Ï¿´Íý³Ø¤ò¼ÂÁ©¤·¤Æ¤¤¿¡£Ëܽñ¤ÏºÇ¿·¤Î¿´Íý³ØŪÃ諤«¤é¡¢¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¾ÚµòË¡¤òÁǺà¤Ë¤¢¤ë¤Ù¤ºÛȽ¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ò¸¡¾Ú¤¹¤ë¡£¤µ¤é¤ËËܽñ¤Ï¡¢ÆüËܤο´Íý³Ø¤Ë¿·¤·¤¤¸¦µæʬÌî¤òÄ󶡤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¡¡ÆüËܤκÛȽ¤ËÀµ¤·¤¤¾ÚµòË¡¤ò¹½ÃÛ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤ËɬÆɤνñ¡£
Ë¡Áâ¤ä¿´Íý³Ø¸¦µæ¼Ô¤Ï¤â¤Á¤í¤ó¡¢ºÛȽ¤È¿´Íý³Ø¤Ë¶½Ì£¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Ù¤Æ¤Î¿Í¤Ë¤ª¤¹¤¹¤á¤·¤Þ¤¹¡£
2012ǯ09·î09Æü
¡Ú¤³¤ì¤ÏºÇ¹âºÛȽ½êÂ裲¾®Ë¡ÄîÊ¿À®24ǯ9·î7ÆüȽ·è¤ÎÊ۸ýƬÊÛÏÀ¤ÎµÏ¿¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡Û
¶áÂå¾ÚµòË¡¤ÎÉ㥸¥ç¥ó¡¦¥Ø¥ó¥ê¡¼¡¦¥¦¥£¥°¥â¥¢¤Ï¤³¤¦¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡Ö¡ÎÁ°²Ê¡Ï¤¬ÇÓÀͤµ¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ´¶¼õ¤µ¤ì¤ë¤Ù¤¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤Ê¤¤¤«¤é¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤½¤ì¤¬²áÂç¤Ë¼õ¤±¼è¤é¤ì¤ë¤«¤é¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ºÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ìÇ濳¤Ç¤¢¤ì¡¢ºÛȽµ¡´Ø¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¼«Á³¤«¤ÄÉÔ²ÄÈòŪ¤Ê·¹¸þ¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Ä輨¤µ¤ì¤¿°íå¤ÊÈȺá¤ÎµÏ¿¤ò²áÂç¤Ëɾ²Á¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ì¤¬¸½ºß¤Îµ¯ÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¸ú²Ì¤òɬÍװʾå¤Ë¶¯¤¯Ç§¤á¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¤«¡¢¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï¸½ºß¤Îµ¯ÁÊ»ö¼Â¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æͺᤫ¤É¤¦¤«¤Ë¤«¤«¤ï¤é¤º½èȳ¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òÀµÅö²½¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¼õ¤±¼è¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×[1]¡£
20À¤µª¤Î¤Ï¤¸¤á¤ËÍ̾¤Ê¸íȽ¤Î¸¦µæ¤òȯɽ¤·¤¿¥¨¥É¥¦¥£¥ó¡¦¥Ü¡¼¥Á¥ã¡¼¥É¶µ¼ø¤Ï¡¢Â¿¤¯¤Î¸íȽ»öÎã¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤¬ºÛȽ¤ÇµöÍƤµ¤ìÇ濳¤Ë¼¨¤µ¤ì¤¿¤³¤È¤¬¡ÖÃ×̿Ū¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡×¤È»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹[2]¡£¥Ù¥ó¥¸¥ã¥ß¥ó¡¦¥«¡¼¥É¡¼¥¾È½»ö¤âÁ°²Ê¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤Ï¡Ö̵¼Â¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤È¤Ã¤Æ¤ÎºÒÌñ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹[3]¡£
¸½Âå¤Î¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤ÇºÇ¤âÉÑÈˤˤ½¤ÎÃøºî¤¬°úÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¾ÚµòË¡¸¦µæ¼Ô¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¡ØÁÊÄÉÂоݳ°Èó¹Ô¤Î¾Úµò¡Ù(Uncharged Misconduct Evidence)¤È¤¤¤¦¥¿¥¤¥È¥ë¤ÎÂçÃø[4]¤ò½ÐÈǤ·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¥¨¥É¥ï¡¼¥É¡¦¥¤¥à¥¦¥£¥ó¥±¥ë¥ê¡¼¥É¶µ¼ø¤Ï¡¢Ç濳ºÛȽ¤ÎË¡¼Ò²ñ³ØŪ¸¦µæÀ®²Ì¤ò¿¶¤êÊ֤äơ¢¤³¤¦½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡Ö¸½ºß¤Þ¤Ç¤Î¤¹¤Ù¤Æ¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ï¡¢·º»öÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁÊÄÉÂоݳ°¤ÎÈȺá¤Î¾Úµò¤¬¸¡»¡´±¤Îʼ´ï¸Ë¤Î¤Ê¤«¤ÇºÇ¤âÇ˲õÎϤΤ¢¤ëÉð´ï¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£ÁÊÄÉÂоݤȤʤäƤ¤¤Ê¤¤Èó¹Ô¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¶Ë°¿Í¤È¤·¤ÆÉÁ¤«¤ì¡¢Ç濳¤Ïͺáɾ·è¤ËƳ¤«¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×[5]¡£
¤³¤³¤Ç¸¦µæ¼Ô¤äºÛȽ´±¤¬»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë´í¸±À¤Ï¡¢ÁÊÄɤÎÂоݤȤʤäƤ¤¤Ê¤¤ÈȺá¤äÈó¹Ô¤¬¡¢¸í¤Ã¤Æ°ãË¡¤Ë¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤Ã¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Î¤ß¤ò»Ø¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤à¤·¤í¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤¬ÅÁÅýŪ¤Ëǧ¤á¤ëÎã³°¤Ë³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤äÁ°Îò¤¬Å¬Ë¡¤ËºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Î¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤äÁ°Îò¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤Ï¡¢Ç¡²¿¤Ê¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Î¤Ê¤«¤ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ëŨ°Õ¤äÈ¿´¶¡¢Í½ÃÇ¡¢Ê諤òÀ¸¤ß½Ð¤¹¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Èà¤é¤ò¤·¤Æ»ö·ï¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤ä¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¸í¤Ã¤¿ÍºáȽ·è¤ò²¼¤µ¤»¤ë´í¸±À¤ò¾ï¤Ë»ý¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤äÁ°Îò¤¬Î㳰Ū¤ËÁÊ°ø¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¾ì¹ç¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¡¦Á°Îò¤È¤¤¤¦À³Ê¾Úµò¤Î»ý¤Ä¶²¤í¤·¤¤´í¸±À¡½¡½Ñͺá¤Î´í¸±À¡½¡½¤ò̵»ë¤Ç¤¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¹âÅ٤ʾì¹ç¤Ë¸Â¤é¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
ËÜ·ï¤Ç¡¢»ä¤Î°ÍÍê¿ÍOK»á¤Ï¡¢ÌÚ¤¥¢¥Ñ¡¼¥È¤Î1¼¼¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤³¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÀÐÌý¥¹¥È¡¼¥Ö¤ÎÅôÌý¤ò¼¼Æâ¤Ë»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤ÆÊü²Ð¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¸½½»·ú¤ʪÅùÊü²Ð¤Îºá¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£Èà¤Ï¤³¤Îºá¤ò°ì´Ó¤·¤ÆÈÝÄꤷ¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èà¤Ë¤Ï¤ª¤è¤½20ǯÁ°¤Ë11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦Á°²Ê¤¬¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Î10·ï¤Ï¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¤½¤Î10·ï¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Î7·ï¤Ç¤Ï¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÅôÌý¤òÍøÍѤ·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤¬Ä¾Ì̤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¤³¤ÎO»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¡¢Èà¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¸½ºß¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤Ç¤¢¤ëÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Îͺá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ·¤ÆÎɤ¤¤«¤È¤¤¤¦ÌäÂê¤Ç¤¹¡£
¡Ö11·ï¤â¤ÎÊü²Ð¤òÈȤ·¤¿Èï¹ð¿Í¡¢¤·¤«¤âµ¯Áʾõ¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ë¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÅôÌý¤òÉô²°¤Ë»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤¿»ö·ï¤ò7²ó¤â¤ä¤Ã¤¿Èï¹ð¿Í¤À¤«¤é¡¢º£²ó¤â¤ä¤Ã¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¡½¡½¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ï¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤ÇO»á¤òͺá¤È¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤½¤ì¤³¤½¡¢¤Þ¤µ¤Ëµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡ÖÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎÍøÍѤˤۤ«¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤«¤é¤Ç¤¹¡£¤·¤«¤·¤Þ¤¿¡¢¤³¤Î11·ï¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ¹¤ì¤Ð¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤äºÛȽ°÷¤Ï¡½¡½°Õ¼±¤¹¤ë¤È¤·¤Ê¤¤¤È¤Ë¤«¤«¤ï¤é¤º¡½¡½¤³¤Î¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤Ë¤È¤é¤ï¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤Ë¤µ¤é¤µ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£O»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î´í¸±À¤ò¾è¤ê±Û¤¨¤Æ;¤ê¤¢¤ë¤Û¤É¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤½¤³¤Ë¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢O»á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Ï¡ÖÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ´ØÏ¢À¤¬¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Èà¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÏËÜ·ï¤ÎÈȿͤò¼±Ê̤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤Î´í¸±À¤ò¾è¤ê±Û¤¨¤ë¤Û¤É¤Î¹â¤¤¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£ËÜÅö¤Ë¤½¤¦¸À¤¨¤ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£¸¶È½·è¤ÎÀâÌÀ¤ò¸«¤Æ¤¤¤¯¤³¤È¤Ë¤·¤Þ¤·¤ç¤¦¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢¤Þ¤º¡¢O»á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÈËÜ·ï¤È¤Î´Ö¤Ë¤ÏÊü²Ð¤Î¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÎÂçȾ¡Ê10·ï¡Ë¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Ï¡¢¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¡¢¤½¤ÎÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤ËÎà»÷À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î°ìÉôʬ¤Ë¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¾å¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤¬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¡¢¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤¬¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤ÎÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡Ê¸¶È½·è5~6ÊÇ¡Ë¡£
¤Þ¤º¡¢µï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¥¿¥¤¥×¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Ï·è¤·¤ÆÄÁ¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ½ñ¤ÎÃæ¤Ë´ö¤Ä¤«¤Î¼Â¾ÚŪ¸¦µæ¤ò°úÍѤ·¤Þ¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Î°ì¤Ä¾åÌî¸ü»á¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡¢ÌýÎà¤ò»ÈÍѤ·¤¿Êü²Ð¤Ï15¡ó¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î64¡ó¤Ï¡Ö¸½¾ìËô¤Ï¸½¾ìÉÕ¶á¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡×ÌýÎबÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹[6]¡£Ä¹Ç¯¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ·º»öºÛȽ¤Ë·È¤ï¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¿¸µÅìµþ¹âºÛÉôÁí³çȽ»ö¤Ç¤¢¤ëÌçÌîÇ¼ø¤Ï¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Îɾ¼á¤ò¤·¤¿ÏÀʸ¤ÎÃæ¤Ç¡Ö¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÂÖÍͤÎÊü²Ð¤Ï¤Û¤«¤Ë¤â¸«¼õ¤±¤é¤ì¤ë¤à¤·¤í¤¢¤ê¤Õ¤ì¤¿ÂÖÍͤȤ¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤À¤í¤¦¤«¡×¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤ª¤é¤ì¤Þ¤¹[7]¡£
¸¶È½·è¤¬¸À¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¡Öµï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¯¡×¤È¤¤¤¦ÈȹԷÁÂ֤ϳΤ«¤Ë¡Ö½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î°ìÉôʬ¤Ë¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èȿͤò¼±Ê̤Ǥ¤ë¤è¤¦¤ÊºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿ÆÃħ¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¤È¤¦¤Æ¤¤ÉÔ²Äǽ¤Ç¤¹¡£
¤È¤³¤í¤Ç¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡Öµï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¯¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¤À¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤½¤Î¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤³¤È¤¬¤½¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦ÀâÌÀ¤òÉÕ¤±²Ã¤¨¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤³¤ì¤Ï¤É¤¦¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£
¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢¸À¤¤´¹¤¨¤ì¤Ð¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¹Ô°Ù¤¬¾ï½¬²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤Ä¤Þ¤ê¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ïµï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¾ï½¬Åª¤Ë¹Ô¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢º£²ó¤âµï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤òÊü¤Ã¤¿²ÄǽÀ¤¬¹â¤¤¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤³¤ì¤Ï¤Þ¤µ¤Ë¡¢¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤¬¶Ø»ß¤·¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ÎÂ翳±¡°ÊÍè¤ÎȽÎ㤬¶Ø»ß¤·¤¿¡ÖÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤ÎÏÀÍý¤½¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤Ä¤Þ¤ê¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎÎã³°¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡ÖÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¡×¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÁ°²Ê¤òÍøÍѤ·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¸À¤¤¤Ê¤¬¤é¡¢¼ÂºÝ¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤òÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¼¡¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡ÖÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡×¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¤âÎà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤Î¤¤¤º¤ì¤â¤¬¡¢ÀàÅð¤ò»î¤ß¤ÆÍߤ¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¶âÉʤ¬ÆÀ¤é¤ì¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ËÂФ¹¤ëʢΩ¤Á¤ò²ò¾Ã¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¼ç¤ÊÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¾¿Í¤Î½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£Â¾Êý¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÈÀÜÃ夷¤¿»þ´ÖÂӤˡ¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤ÎÈȹԾì½ê¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤ÆÀàÅð¤ò¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÏÁ褤¤¬¤Ê¤¯¡¢Æ±ÀàÅð¤ÎÈï³²ÉʤÏ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤È¥«¥Ã¥×ÌÍ1¸Ä¤Ë¤È¤É¤Þ¤Ã¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤òËþ¤µ¤»¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¤Ï»Ç¤ï¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤«¤é¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ÎÊ¢¤¤¤»¤ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ËµÚ¤ó¤À²ÄǽÀ¤¬¹Í¤¨¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Ï¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢Îà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¡¢¤½¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡ÊƱÁ°6ÊÇ¡Ë¡£
¤³¤Î¸¶È½·è¤ÎÀ⼨¤Ï¡¢Àè¤Ë»ØŦ¤·¤¿¡Ö¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÎÎà»÷À¡×¤è¤ê¤â¤µ¤é¤ËÂ礤ÊÌäÂê¤ò¤Ï¤é¤ó¤Ç¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤ò½¼Ê¬¤Ê¶âÉʤ¬ÆÀ¤é¤ì¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¡Ö¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡×¤È·è¤á¤Ä¤±¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤Ç¤¹¡£Éô²°¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤Æ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤òÅð¤Ã¤Æ¥«¥Ã¥×Ìͤò¿©¤Ù¤¿¤³¤È¤òO¤µ¤ó¤Ïǧ¤á¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èà¤Ï²Ð¤òÅÀ¤±¤¿¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£ÀàÅð¤ÈÊü²Ð¤¬Æ±°ì¿Íʪ¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤Ï²¿¤âȯ¸«¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤É¤¦¤·¤ÆËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤¬¡Ö¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡×¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£
ÌçÌîÇ¼ø¤Ï¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤ò¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÈãȽ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡Öº£²ó¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Ï¾¤ÎµÒ´ÑŪ»ö¼Â¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȹԤǤ¢¤ë¤È³ÎÄêŪ¤Ë¾ÚÌÀ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢º£²ó¤ÎÈȹԤ¬Èȿͤˤè¤Ã¤Æ¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÆ°µ¡¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê·Àµ¡¤Ç¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¤Î¤«¤â²òÌÀ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Á°·º¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤äÈȹԤˤ¤¤¿¤ë·Àµ¡¤¬Î©¾Ú¤µ¤ì¤¿¤«¤é¤È¤¤¤Ã¤Æ¡¢º£²ó¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÆ°µ¡¡¢·Àµ¡¤ÈÈæ³ÓÂоȤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȹԤǤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤¬Î©¾Ú¤µ¤ì¤Æ¡¢¤Ï¤¸¤á¤Æ¡¢¶¦¤Ë¡ØÀàÅð¤ÎÀ®²Ì¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÉÔËþ¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡Ù¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¤È¿äǧ¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬²Äǽ¤È¤Ê¤ë¡ÊËÜȽ·è¤Ï¡¢·ëÏÀ¤òÀè¼è¤ê¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤ï¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤â¤·¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȹԤǤʤ¤¤È¤·¤¿¤é¡¢¤½¤Î¼Ô¤¬ÀàÅðÌÜŪ¤Ç¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿¤È¤«¡¢¡ØÀàÅð¤ÎÀ®²Ì¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡Ù¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÊü²Ð¤·¤¿¤È¤Ï¡¢¤¿¤ä¤¹¤¯¿äǧ¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¤Ï¤º¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡Ë¤³¤³¤Ç¤Ï¡¢²áµî¤ÎÈȹԤˤĤ¤¤Æǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë³ÆÈȹԤηÀµ¡¤ÎÁí¹ç¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¿äǧ¤Ç¤¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¡Ê·¹¸þ¡Ë¤ò´ð¤Ë¤·¤Æ¡¢º£²ó¤ÎÈȹԤ⤽¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀ³Ê¡Ê·¹¸þ¡Ë¤òͤ¹¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤«¤È¿äǧ¤Ç¤¤ë¤Ë²á¤®¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ï¤Þ¤µ¤Ë¡Ø°À³Ê¤ÎΩ¾Ú¡Ù¤½¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¸«¤¨¤ë¡×[8]¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¤³¤³¤Ç¤âO»á¤Î¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç²¿ÅÙ¤âÀàÅð¤ÎÀ®²Ì¤¬¤¢¤¬¤é¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÊü²Ð¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢º£Å٤⤽¤¦¤·¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÁ°²Ê¤ò»È¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¸¶¿³ºÛȽ´±¤Ï¡¢°À³ÊΩ¾Ú¤ò¼õ¤±Æþ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤Ê¤ÉÁ´¤¯¤Ê¤¯¡¢¡ÖÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¡×¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÁ°²Ê¤ò»È¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È»×¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¼ÂºÝ¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ë°À³ÊΩ¾Ú¤Î¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤ËÖȤäƤ¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Î¤â¤¿¤é¤¹Í½ÃÇ¡¦Êи«¤Î¤È¤ê¤³¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¤È¤³¤í¤Ç¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢»ä¤¬¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ½ñ¤Ç°úÍѤ·¤¿Êü²Ð¤Î¼Â¾ÚŪ¸¦µæ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÏÀʸ¤òÍøÍѤ·¤Æ¡¢¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÏÀÍý¤òŸ³«¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
²°ÆâÊü²Ð¤ÏÁ´ÂΤÎ56.9¡ó¡¢ÌýÎà¤Î»ÈÍѤ¬15.8¡ó¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤È̵´Ø·¸¤Ê¼Ô¤ÎÈȹԤ¬44.5¡ó¡£¤³¤ì¤é¤ò³Ý¤±¹ç¤ï¤»¤ë¤È³ÎΨÏÀŪ¤Ë¤Ï4.0¡ó¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡¢¤È¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢ÀàÅð¤È´ØÏ¢¤¢¤ë¤â¤Î¤Î³ä¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë2.1¡ó¤ò³Ý¤±¹ç¤ï¤»¤ë¤È0.84¡ó¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢¤³¤ì¤Ï¶Ë¤á¤Æµ©¤Ê¥±¡¼¥¹¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡¢¤È¡£
¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤ÎÏÀÍý¤¬ÄÌÍѤ·¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤ÏÅý·×³Ø¤Î½éÊâ¤ò³Ø¤ó¤À¿Í¤Ë¤ÏÌÀÇò¤Ê¤³¤È¤Ç¤¹¡£Åý·×¾å¤Î³Æ¾ò·ï¤¬´°Á´¤ÊÆÈΩÊÑ¿ô¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¡¢¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á³Æ¾ò·ï¤Î´Ö¤ÎÁê´Ø·¸¿ô¤¬£°¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¾ÚÌÀ¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¸Â¤ê¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬Å¸³«¤¹¤ë³Ý¤±»»¤Ë¤è¤ë³ÎΨÏÀ¤Ï̵°ÕÌ£¤Ç¤¹¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï¼ÂÂ֤Ȥ«¤±Î¥¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤È¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤ï¤«¤ê¤ä¤¹¤¤¤è¤¦¤ËÎã¤ò¾å¤²¤ÆÀâÌÀ¤·¤Þ¤¹¡£
ÌÜ·â¾Ú¿Í¤¬¡ÖÈȿͤÏ50ºÐÂå¤ÎÃËÀ¤Ç¡¢¿ÈŤÏ170¥»¥ó¥Á¡¢ÂνŤÏ80¥¥í¤¯¤é¤¤¡¢¸ý¤Ò¤²¤È¤¢¤´¤Ò¤²¤òÀ¸¤ä¤·¡¢ÇòȱƬ¤À¤Ã¤¿¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤¿¤È¤·¤Þ¤¹¡£
50ºÐÂå¤ÏÁ´¿Í¸ý¤Î10ʬ¤Î1
¿ÈĹ170¥»¥ó¥Á¤Î¿Í¤Ï150¿Í¤Ë1¿Í
ÃËÀ¤ÏÁ´¿Í¸ý¤Î2ʬ¤Î1
ÂνÅ80¥¥í¤Î¿Í¤Ï300¿Í¤Ë1¿Í
¸ý¤Ò¤²¤È¤¢¤´¤Ò¤²¤òÀ¸¤ä¤·¤¿¿Í¤Ï15,000¿Í¤Ë1¿Í
Çòȱ¤Ï3500¿Í¤Ë1¿Í
¤À¤È¤·¤Þ¤¹¡£
¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢¤³¤ÎÆÃħ¤ò»ý¤Ã¤¿¿Í¤Ï1575²¯¿Í¤Ë1¿Í¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤³¤ÎÌÜ·â¾Ú¸À¤ÏDNA·¿´ÕÄê°Ê¾å¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤò»ý¤Ä¼±Ê̾ڵò¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤ó¤ÊÇϼ¯¤Ê¤³¤È¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
Ïäò¤â¤È¤ËÌᤷ¤Þ¤·¤ç¤¦¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢ÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤¿¤á¤ËÁ°²Ê¤òµöÍƤ¹¤ë¾ò·ï¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤ËÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡¢ÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ì¤Ð¤ê¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡Ê¸¶È½·è8ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤Î¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦´ð½à¤Ï´Ë¤ä¤«¤Ë¤¹¤®¤Þ¤¹¡£¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦ÄøÅ٤Ǥϡ¢¸¶È½·è¼«¿È¤¬¸í¤ê¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¡½¡½¡Ö¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç·«¤êÊÖ¤·¤ä¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¿¤Î¤À¤«¤é¡¢¤Þ¤¿¤ä¤Ã¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¤¤¤¦À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦´í¸±À¤¬Í¾¤ê¤Ë¤âÂ礤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤·¤«¤â¡¢Ëܿͤ¿¤Á¤Ï¤½¤Î´í¸±¤ò²óÈò¤Ç¤¤¿¤È»×¤¤¹þ¤ó¤Ç¤¤¤ë¤À¤±¤Ë;·×¤Ë´í¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤¨¤Þ¤¹¡£
³Î¤«¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤¬¸À¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î¤¦¤Á¡¢¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¹Ô¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¡Ö¤¢¤ëÄøÅÙ¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¡ÊƱÁ°7ÊǡˤǤ·¤ç¤¦¡£µï¼¼Æâ¤ÇÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤ÆÊü²Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡Ö¤è¤ê°ìÁظÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¡ÊƱÁ°¡Ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊü²ÐÈȤϡ½¡½¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡½¡½¾¯¤Ê¤«¤é¤ºÂ¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¸¶È½·è¤¬¸À¤¦¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¹Í¤¨Êý¤ÏÎ㤨¤Ð·ì±Õ·¿¤Ë»÷¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡££Â·¿¤Î·ì±Õ·¿¤Î¿Íʪ¤Ï¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢·ì±Õ·¿´ÕÄê¤Ë¤ÏÈȿͼ±Ê̤Τ¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï·è¤·¤Æ·ì±Õ·¿¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ë¤Ï°·¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£·ì±Õ·¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤ÏµÒ´ÑŪ¤Ê°À¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤ÎµÒ´ÑŪ¤Ê²ÁÃͰʾå¤Ë²áÂçɾ²Á¤µ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏB·¿¤À¤«¤éºá¤òÈȤ·¤ä¤¹¤¤¤Ê¤É¤È¹Í¤¨¤ë¿Í¤Ï¤¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÏµÒ´ÑŪ¤Ç¹çÍýŪ¤Êɾ²Á¤ò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬Èó¾ï¤Ëº¤Æñ¤Ê¾Úµò¤Ç¤¹¡£¥¦¥£¥°¥â¥¢¤¬»ØŦ¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ìÇ濳¤Ç¤¢¤ì¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Ï°íå¤ÊÈȺá¤ÎµÏ¿¤Ë¶¯¤¯°õ¾Ý¤Å¤±¤é¤ì¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¤¡¢ÃΤ餺ÃΤ餺¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Ë²áÂç¤Êɾ²Á¤ò¤·¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£µö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡Ö°À³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤Î櫤ËÍî¤Á¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤Ïº£²ó¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤ÈÎà»÷¤·¤¿ÆÃħŪ¤ÊÁ°²Ê¤¬¤¢¤ë¡£¤À¤«¤é¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢º£ÅÙ¤â¤ä¤Ã¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¡£¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿´¾Ú·ÁÀ®¡½¡½Í½ÃÇ¡¢Êи«¡½¡½¤Î´í¸±¤¬¤½¤³¤Ëʬ¤«¤Á¤¬¤¿¤¯È¼¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
Á°²Ê¤òÈȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤ¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î´í¸±¤«¤é¼«Í³¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Á°²Ê¤ò¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤ¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤ò¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ëο²ï¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¿Âç¤ÊÈȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¸¶È½·è¤¬ºÎÍѤ·¤¿µöÍÆÀ¤Î´ð½à¤Ï´Ë¤ä¤«¤¹¤®¤Þ¤¹¡£
¤½¤ì¤Ç¤Ï¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ï¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê´ð½à¤Ë¤è¤ë¤Ù¤¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤òο²ï¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¡¢¹âÅÙ¤ÎÈȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ï¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£¸½ºßÀ¤³¦¤ÇºÇ¤âÎɤ¯Æɤޤì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¾ÚµòË¡¤Î¶µ²Ê½ñ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤Î¶µ²Ê½ñ¤Ë¤Ï¤³¤¦½ñ¤«¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡Ö¤½¤ì¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ÎÊýË¡¤¬¤Û¤È¤ó¤ÉƱ°ì(nearly identical)¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤áÀµ¤Ë¤½¤ì¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¼ê»Å»ö(handiwork)¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¼±Ê̤Ǥ¤ë(earmark)¤è¤¦¤Ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȤ·¤¿Ê̤κá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»¦¿Í¡¢¶¯Åð¤ä¥ì¥¤¥×¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤ÊƱ¼ï¤ÎÈȺ᤬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤ÏÁ´¤¯Â¤ê¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤ÎÈȺá¤Î¥Ñ¥¿¡¼¥ó¤äÆÃħ¤¬¡¢¤È¤Æ¤â°Û¾ï¤ÇºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¡¢½ð̾(signature)¤Ë¤âÅù¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡×[9]¡£
ÆüËܤκÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ë°ËÆ£²í¿ÍȽ»ö¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤ÈƱÍͤιͤ¨¤òÊ̤Îɽ¸½¤Ç½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡ÖÃí°Õ¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ï¡¢Ã±¤ËÈȺá¤ÎÆâÍƤä¼ê¸ý¤¬Îà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤ÇÎà»÷»ö¼Â¤Ë¤è¤ëΩ¾Ú¤òµö¤·¤Æ¤è¤¤¤ï¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¥á¥ë¥¯¥Þ¡¼¥ë¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬²áµî¤ËÎà»÷¤ÎÈȺá¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¼«ÂΤ«¤é¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬º£²óµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿ÈȺá¤ÎÈȿͤǤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¡¢Ä¾Àܡʤ¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á°À³Ê¤È¤¤¤¦Ãæ´Ö¹à¤ò²ðºß¤µ¤»¤ë¤³¤È¤Ê¤¯¡Ë¿äǧ¤Ç¤¤ë¤«¤É¤¦¤«¡¢¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ÈȺá¤ÎÆâÍƤä¼ê¸ý¤¬Îà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤ꤺ¡¢¤½¤ÎÆâÍƤä¼ê¸ý¤¬ÈȿͤËÆÃͤΤâ¤Î¤È¤¤¤¨¤ëÄøÅÙ¤ËÆüì¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òÍפ¹¤ë¤Ç¤¢¤í¤¦¡×[10]¡£
¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤Îɽ¸½¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡ÖÈȿͤνð̾¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤°¤é¤¤¤Ë°Û¾ï¤ÇºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿ÆÃħ¤¬¤¢¤ë¾ì¹ç¡×¡¢°ËƣȽ»ö¤Îɽ¸½¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡Ö°À³Ê¤È¤¤¤¦Ãæ´Ö¹à¤ò²ðºß¤µ¤»¤ë¤³¤È¤Ê¤¯Ä¾ÀÜÈȿͤȿäǧ¤Ç¤¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¡¢¤½¤ÎÆâÍƤä¼ê¸ý¤¬Æüì¤Ê¾ì¹ç¡×¤Ë¤Ï¤¸¤á¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï¡½¡½À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡½¡½Èȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤¦¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£ËÜ·ï¤ÇÌäÂê¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤¿O»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿ÆÃħ¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Éô²°¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤Æ¤½¤Î¾ì¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤ë¿Í¤Ï¤Û¤«¤Ë¤â¤¿¤¯¤µ¤ó¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤³¤Î¼ê¸ý¤ÏÈà¤Î½ð̾¤È¤Ï¸À¤¨¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤½¤ÎÈȹԤ«¤éÈȿͤÏÈà¤À¤ÈľÀÜǧÄꤹ¤ë¤³¤È¤Ê¤É¤Ç¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£O»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¡¢º£²óµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿»ö·ï¤ÎÈȿͤ¬Èà¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¸¶È½·è¤ÏÇË´þ¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
Ĺ´±Ê¤Ӥ˺ǹâºÛȽ»ö¤Î³§¤µ¤ó¡¢
ÂçÀµ7ǯ¡¢1918ǯ¡¢¤¤¤Þ¤«¤é94ǯ¤Þ¤¨¤Ë¡¢Â翳±¡¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¸¶Â§¤òÀë¸À¤·¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤Ï¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎË¡Íý¤òºÎÍѤ·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¼¤Íè¡¢¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ÎºÇ½ª¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÏÀޤˤդì¤Æ¤³¤Î¸¶Â§¤ò³Îǧ¤·¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢Î㳰Ū¤ËÁ°²Ê¤¬¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤ê¤¦¤ë´ö¤Ä¤«¤Î¾ì¹ç¤ò¼¨¤·¤Æ¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£Â翳±¡¤äºÇ¹âºÛ¤ÏÎã³°¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤â¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ë±è¤¦È½ÃǤò¤·¤Æ¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£
¤¤¤Þ¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤¬Ä¾Ì̤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎÎã³°¤Î°ì¤Ä¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡ÖÈȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤È¤¤¤¦ÌäÂê¤Ç¤¹¡£¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ï¡¢¤³¤³¤Ç¤â¿ÍÎඦÄ̤λñ»º¤È¤â¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤Îˡ§¤ò½¼Ê¬¤Ë»²¾È¤·¤Æ¸·³Ê¤ÇÌÀ³Î¤Ê¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òÄ輨¤¹¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¹¡£·è¤·¤Æ¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎË¡Íý¤ËÉ÷·ê¤ò¤¢¤±¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¤³¤È¤ò¤·¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ë¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ò¼é¤ê¤«¤Ä¤½¤ì¤ò¶¯²½¤¹¤Ù¤Íýͳ¤¬¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤ì¤ÏºÛȽ°÷À©Å٤Ǥ¹¡£ºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Ï¡¢·º»öºÛȽ¤Î»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Ë»Ô̱¤Î·òÁ´¤Ê¼Ò²ñ¾ï¼±¤òÈ¿±Ç¤µ¤»¤ë¤³¤È¤òÌÜŪ¤È¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤·¤Æ»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Ï¾Úµò¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£·è¤·¤Æ¡¢Í½ÃǤäÊ諤ä»×¤¤¹þ¤ß¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æͺá¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¤³¤È¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£»Ô̱¤Ë¤è¤ëȽÃǤ¬Å¬Àµ¤Ë¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤¢¤ë¤Î¤¬¾ÚµòË¡¤Ç¤¹¡£ºÛȽ´±¤¬Ë¡Î§¤ÎÀìÌç²È¤È¤·¤Æ¾Úµò¤ÎÁªÊ̤òŬÀµ¤Ë¹Ô¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¡¢»Ô̱¤Î¾ï¼±¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯¾Úµò¤Îɾ²Á¤ä»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤ÎÁ°Äó¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
¥¦¥£¥°¥â¥¢¤¬»ØŦ¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢»Ô̱¤Ç¤¢¤ìºÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ì¡¢¿Í´Ö¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤò²áÂç¤Ëɾ²Á¤·¡¢°íå¤ÊÈȺá¤ÎµÏ¿¤ËÏǤ蘆¤ì¤¬¤Á¤Ç¤¹¡£¤Ç¤¹¤«¤é¡¢¤½¤Î´í¸±¤òÃΤäƤ¤¤ëºÛȽ´±¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾Úµò¤ò¸·³Ê¤Ëµ¬À©¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ï»ºÀ¼¤ò¾å¤²¤¿¿·¤¿¤Ê»Ô̱»²²Ã¤Î»ÊË¡À©ÅÙ¤ò¡¢Á´À¤³¦¤Î¿Í¡¹¤«¤é¿®Íꤵ¤ì¤ëΩÇɤʤâ¤Î¤Ë°é¤Æ¤Æ¹Ô¤«¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Á°²Ê¤Î¤¢¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¤¿¤È¤¨¾Úµò¤¬Çö¤¯¤Æ¤â¡¢»÷¤¿¤è¤¦¤ÊÁ°²Ê¤¬¤¢¤ì¤ÐÍưפËͺá¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¡£¤½¤¦¤·¤¿Ñͺá¤òÀ¸¤ß½Ð¤¹¤è¤¦¤Ê´í¤Ê¤¤À©Å٤ˤ·¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
¤¢¤ê¤¬¤È¤¦¤´¤¶¤¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£
Ãí
[1] £±Wigmore on Evidence (3d ed 1940),¡ø194.
[2] Edwin M. Borchard, Convicting the Innocence (1932), at 369-370.
[3] People v. Zackowitz, 254 N.Y. 192 (1930), at 198.
[4] Edward J. Imwinkelreid, Uncharged Misconduct Evidence, 2 vols (West, 2009).
[5] Edward J. Imwinkelreid, ¡ÈUncharged Misconduct¡É, 12 Litigation 25 (1985-1986), at 25.
[6]¾åÌî¸ü¡ØÅÔ»Ô·¿Êü²ÐÈȺ᡽¡½Êü²ÐÈȺῴÍýʬÀÏÆþÌç¡Ù¡ÊΩ²Ö½ñ˼1998¡Ë¡¢24¡¢29-30ÊÇ¡£
[7] ÌçÌîÇî¡ÖƱ¼ïÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤òµö¤µ¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¸¶¿³¤ÎÁ¼ÃÖ¤¬°ãË¡¤È¤µ¤ì¤¿»öÎã¡×·º»öË¡¥¸¥ã¡¼¥Ê¥ë31¡Ý83¡Ê2011¡Ë¡¢88~89ÊÇ¡£
[8] ÌçÌÁ°Ãí¡¢88~89ÊÇ¡£
[9] McCormick, On Evidence, 6th ed (Thomson/West, 2006), 315.
[10] °ËÆ£²í¿Í¡ÖÎà»÷»ö¼Â¤Ë¤è¤ëΩ¾Ú¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡×¡Ø¿¢Â¼Î©ÏºÈ½»öÂà´±µÇ°ÏÀʸ½¸¡ÊÂ裱´¬¡Ë¡Ù¡ÊΩ²Ö½ñ˼2011¡Ë¡¢372ÊÇ¡£
¶áÂå¾ÚµòË¡¤ÎÉ㥸¥ç¥ó¡¦¥Ø¥ó¥ê¡¼¡¦¥¦¥£¥°¥â¥¢¤Ï¤³¤¦¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡Ö¡ÎÁ°²Ê¡Ï¤¬ÇÓÀͤµ¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ´¶¼õ¤µ¤ì¤ë¤Ù¤¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤Ê¤¤¤«¤é¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤½¤ì¤¬²áÂç¤Ë¼õ¤±¼è¤é¤ì¤ë¤«¤é¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ºÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ìÇ濳¤Ç¤¢¤ì¡¢ºÛȽµ¡´Ø¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¼«Á³¤«¤ÄÉÔ²ÄÈòŪ¤Ê·¹¸þ¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Ä輨¤µ¤ì¤¿°íå¤ÊÈȺá¤ÎµÏ¿¤ò²áÂç¤Ëɾ²Á¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ì¤¬¸½ºß¤Îµ¯ÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¸ú²Ì¤òɬÍװʾå¤Ë¶¯¤¯Ç§¤á¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¤«¡¢¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï¸½ºß¤Îµ¯ÁÊ»ö¼Â¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æͺᤫ¤É¤¦¤«¤Ë¤«¤«¤ï¤é¤º½èȳ¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òÀµÅö²½¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¼õ¤±¼è¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×[1]¡£
20À¤µª¤Î¤Ï¤¸¤á¤ËÍ̾¤Ê¸íȽ¤Î¸¦µæ¤òȯɽ¤·¤¿¥¨¥É¥¦¥£¥ó¡¦¥Ü¡¼¥Á¥ã¡¼¥É¶µ¼ø¤Ï¡¢Â¿¤¯¤Î¸íȽ»öÎã¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤¬ºÛȽ¤ÇµöÍƤµ¤ìÇ濳¤Ë¼¨¤µ¤ì¤¿¤³¤È¤¬¡ÖÃ×̿Ū¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡×¤È»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹[2]¡£¥Ù¥ó¥¸¥ã¥ß¥ó¡¦¥«¡¼¥É¡¼¥¾È½»ö¤âÁ°²Ê¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤Ï¡Ö̵¼Â¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤È¤Ã¤Æ¤ÎºÒÌñ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹[3]¡£
¸½Âå¤Î¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤ÇºÇ¤âÉÑÈˤˤ½¤ÎÃøºî¤¬°úÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¾ÚµòË¡¸¦µæ¼Ô¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¡ØÁÊÄÉÂоݳ°Èó¹Ô¤Î¾Úµò¡Ù(Uncharged Misconduct Evidence)¤È¤¤¤¦¥¿¥¤¥È¥ë¤ÎÂçÃø[4]¤ò½ÐÈǤ·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¥¨¥É¥ï¡¼¥É¡¦¥¤¥à¥¦¥£¥ó¥±¥ë¥ê¡¼¥É¶µ¼ø¤Ï¡¢Ç濳ºÛȽ¤ÎË¡¼Ò²ñ³ØŪ¸¦µæÀ®²Ì¤ò¿¶¤êÊ֤äơ¢¤³¤¦½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡Ö¸½ºß¤Þ¤Ç¤Î¤¹¤Ù¤Æ¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ï¡¢·º»öÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁÊÄÉÂоݳ°¤ÎÈȺá¤Î¾Úµò¤¬¸¡»¡´±¤Îʼ´ï¸Ë¤Î¤Ê¤«¤ÇºÇ¤âÇ˲õÎϤΤ¢¤ëÉð´ï¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£ÁÊÄÉÂоݤȤʤäƤ¤¤Ê¤¤Èó¹Ô¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¶Ë°¿Í¤È¤·¤ÆÉÁ¤«¤ì¡¢Ç濳¤Ïͺáɾ·è¤ËƳ¤«¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×[5]¡£
¤³¤³¤Ç¸¦µæ¼Ô¤äºÛȽ´±¤¬»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë´í¸±À¤Ï¡¢ÁÊÄɤÎÂоݤȤʤäƤ¤¤Ê¤¤ÈȺá¤äÈó¹Ô¤¬¡¢¸í¤Ã¤Æ°ãË¡¤Ë¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤Ã¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Î¤ß¤ò»Ø¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤à¤·¤í¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤¬ÅÁÅýŪ¤Ëǧ¤á¤ëÎã³°¤Ë³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤äÁ°Îò¤¬Å¬Ë¡¤ËºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Î¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤äÁ°Îò¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤Ï¡¢Ç¡²¿¤Ê¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Î¤Ê¤«¤ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ëŨ°Õ¤äÈ¿´¶¡¢Í½ÃÇ¡¢Ê諤òÀ¸¤ß½Ð¤¹¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Èà¤é¤ò¤·¤Æ»ö·ï¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤ä¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¸í¤Ã¤¿ÍºáȽ·è¤ò²¼¤µ¤»¤ë´í¸±À¤ò¾ï¤Ë»ý¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤äÁ°Îò¤¬Î㳰Ū¤ËÁÊ°ø¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¾ì¹ç¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¡¦Á°Îò¤È¤¤¤¦À³Ê¾Úµò¤Î»ý¤Ä¶²¤í¤·¤¤´í¸±À¡½¡½Ñͺá¤Î´í¸±À¡½¡½¤ò̵»ë¤Ç¤¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¹âÅ٤ʾì¹ç¤Ë¸Â¤é¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
ËÜ·ï¤Ç¡¢»ä¤Î°ÍÍê¿ÍOK»á¤Ï¡¢ÌÚ¤¥¢¥Ñ¡¼¥È¤Î1¼¼¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤³¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÀÐÌý¥¹¥È¡¼¥Ö¤ÎÅôÌý¤ò¼¼Æâ¤Ë»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤ÆÊü²Ð¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¸½½»·ú¤ʪÅùÊü²Ð¤Îºá¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£Èà¤Ï¤³¤Îºá¤ò°ì´Ó¤·¤ÆÈÝÄꤷ¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èà¤Ë¤Ï¤ª¤è¤½20ǯÁ°¤Ë11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦Á°²Ê¤¬¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Î10·ï¤Ï¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¤½¤Î10·ï¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Î7·ï¤Ç¤Ï¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÅôÌý¤òÍøÍѤ·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤¬Ä¾Ì̤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¤³¤ÎO»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¡¢Èà¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¸½ºß¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤Ç¤¢¤ëÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Îͺá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ·¤ÆÎɤ¤¤«¤È¤¤¤¦ÌäÂê¤Ç¤¹¡£
¡Ö11·ï¤â¤ÎÊü²Ð¤òÈȤ·¤¿Èï¹ð¿Í¡¢¤·¤«¤âµ¯Áʾõ¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ë¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÅôÌý¤òÉô²°¤Ë»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤¿»ö·ï¤ò7²ó¤â¤ä¤Ã¤¿Èï¹ð¿Í¤À¤«¤é¡¢º£²ó¤â¤ä¤Ã¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¡½¡½¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ï¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤ÇO»á¤òͺá¤È¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤½¤ì¤³¤½¡¢¤Þ¤µ¤Ëµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡ÖÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎÍøÍѤˤۤ«¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤«¤é¤Ç¤¹¡£¤·¤«¤·¤Þ¤¿¡¢¤³¤Î11·ï¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ¹¤ì¤Ð¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤äºÛȽ°÷¤Ï¡½¡½°Õ¼±¤¹¤ë¤È¤·¤Ê¤¤¤È¤Ë¤«¤«¤ï¤é¤º¡½¡½¤³¤Î¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤Ë¤È¤é¤ï¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤Ë¤µ¤é¤µ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£O»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î´í¸±À¤ò¾è¤ê±Û¤¨¤Æ;¤ê¤¢¤ë¤Û¤É¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤½¤³¤Ë¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢O»á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Ï¡ÖÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ´ØÏ¢À¤¬¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Èà¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÏËÜ·ï¤ÎÈȿͤò¼±Ê̤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤Î´í¸±À¤ò¾è¤ê±Û¤¨¤ë¤Û¤É¤Î¹â¤¤¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£ËÜÅö¤Ë¤½¤¦¸À¤¨¤ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£¸¶È½·è¤ÎÀâÌÀ¤ò¸«¤Æ¤¤¤¯¤³¤È¤Ë¤·¤Þ¤·¤ç¤¦¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢¤Þ¤º¡¢O»á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÈËÜ·ï¤È¤Î´Ö¤Ë¤ÏÊü²Ð¤Î¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÎÂçȾ¡Ê10·ï¡Ë¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Ï¡¢¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¡¢¤½¤ÎÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤ËÎà»÷À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î°ìÉôʬ¤Ë¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¾å¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤¬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¡¢¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤¬¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤ÎÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡Ê¸¶È½·è5~6ÊÇ¡Ë¡£
¤Þ¤º¡¢µï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¥¿¥¤¥×¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Ï·è¤·¤ÆÄÁ¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ½ñ¤ÎÃæ¤Ë´ö¤Ä¤«¤Î¼Â¾ÚŪ¸¦µæ¤ò°úÍѤ·¤Þ¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Î°ì¤Ä¾åÌî¸ü»á¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡¢ÌýÎà¤ò»ÈÍѤ·¤¿Êü²Ð¤Ï15¡ó¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î64¡ó¤Ï¡Ö¸½¾ìËô¤Ï¸½¾ìÉÕ¶á¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡×ÌýÎबÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹[6]¡£Ä¹Ç¯¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ·º»öºÛȽ¤Ë·È¤ï¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¿¸µÅìµþ¹âºÛÉôÁí³çȽ»ö¤Ç¤¢¤ëÌçÌîÇ¼ø¤Ï¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Îɾ¼á¤ò¤·¤¿ÏÀʸ¤ÎÃæ¤Ç¡Ö¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÂÖÍͤÎÊü²Ð¤Ï¤Û¤«¤Ë¤â¸«¼õ¤±¤é¤ì¤ë¤à¤·¤í¤¢¤ê¤Õ¤ì¤¿ÂÖÍͤȤ¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤À¤í¤¦¤«¡×¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤ª¤é¤ì¤Þ¤¹[7]¡£
¸¶È½·è¤¬¸À¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¡Öµï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¯¡×¤È¤¤¤¦ÈȹԷÁÂ֤ϳΤ«¤Ë¡Ö½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î°ìÉôʬ¤Ë¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èȿͤò¼±Ê̤Ǥ¤ë¤è¤¦¤ÊºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿ÆÃħ¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¤È¤¦¤Æ¤¤ÉÔ²Äǽ¤Ç¤¹¡£
¤È¤³¤í¤Ç¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡Öµï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¯¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¤À¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤½¤Î¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤³¤È¤¬¤½¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦ÀâÌÀ¤òÉÕ¤±²Ã¤¨¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤³¤ì¤Ï¤É¤¦¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£
¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢¸À¤¤´¹¤¨¤ì¤Ð¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¹Ô°Ù¤¬¾ï½¬²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤Ä¤Þ¤ê¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ïµï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¾ï½¬Åª¤Ë¹Ô¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢º£²ó¤âµï¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤òÊü¤Ã¤¿²ÄǽÀ¤¬¹â¤¤¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤³¤ì¤Ï¤Þ¤µ¤Ë¡¢¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤¬¶Ø»ß¤·¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ÎÂ翳±¡°ÊÍè¤ÎȽÎ㤬¶Ø»ß¤·¤¿¡ÖÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤ÎÏÀÍý¤½¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤Ä¤Þ¤ê¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎÎã³°¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡ÖÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¡×¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÁ°²Ê¤òÍøÍѤ·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¸À¤¤¤Ê¤¬¤é¡¢¼ÂºÝ¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤òÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¼¡¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡ÖÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡×¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¤âÎà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤Î¤¤¤º¤ì¤â¤¬¡¢ÀàÅð¤ò»î¤ß¤ÆÍߤ¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¶âÉʤ¬ÆÀ¤é¤ì¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ËÂФ¹¤ëʢΩ¤Á¤ò²ò¾Ã¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¼ç¤ÊÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¾¿Í¤Î½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£Â¾Êý¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÈÀÜÃ夷¤¿»þ´ÖÂӤˡ¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤ÎÈȹԾì½ê¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤ÆÀàÅð¤ò¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÏÁ褤¤¬¤Ê¤¯¡¢Æ±ÀàÅð¤ÎÈï³²ÉʤÏ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤È¥«¥Ã¥×ÌÍ1¸Ä¤Ë¤È¤É¤Þ¤Ã¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤òËþ¤µ¤»¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¤Ï»Ç¤ï¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤«¤é¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ÎÊ¢¤¤¤»¤ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ËµÚ¤ó¤À²ÄǽÀ¤¬¹Í¤¨¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Ï¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢Îà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¡¢¤½¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡ÊƱÁ°6ÊÇ¡Ë¡£
¤³¤Î¸¶È½·è¤ÎÀ⼨¤Ï¡¢Àè¤Ë»ØŦ¤·¤¿¡Ö¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÎÎà»÷À¡×¤è¤ê¤â¤µ¤é¤ËÂ礤ÊÌäÂê¤ò¤Ï¤é¤ó¤Ç¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤ò½¼Ê¬¤Ê¶âÉʤ¬ÆÀ¤é¤ì¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¡Ö¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡×¤È·è¤á¤Ä¤±¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤Ç¤¹¡£Éô²°¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤Æ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤òÅð¤Ã¤Æ¥«¥Ã¥×Ìͤò¿©¤Ù¤¿¤³¤È¤òO¤µ¤ó¤Ïǧ¤á¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èà¤Ï²Ð¤òÅÀ¤±¤¿¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£ÀàÅð¤ÈÊü²Ð¤¬Æ±°ì¿Íʪ¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤Ï²¿¤âȯ¸«¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤É¤¦¤·¤ÆËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤¬¡Ö¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡×¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£
ÌçÌîÇ¼ø¤Ï¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤ò¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÈãȽ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡Öº£²ó¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Ï¾¤ÎµÒ´ÑŪ»ö¼Â¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȹԤǤ¢¤ë¤È³ÎÄêŪ¤Ë¾ÚÌÀ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢º£²ó¤ÎÈȹԤ¬Èȿͤˤè¤Ã¤Æ¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÆ°µ¡¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê·Àµ¡¤Ç¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¤Î¤«¤â²òÌÀ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Á°·º¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤äÈȹԤˤ¤¤¿¤ë·Àµ¡¤¬Î©¾Ú¤µ¤ì¤¿¤«¤é¤È¤¤¤Ã¤Æ¡¢º£²ó¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÆ°µ¡¡¢·Àµ¡¤ÈÈæ³ÓÂоȤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȹԤǤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤¬Î©¾Ú¤µ¤ì¤Æ¡¢¤Ï¤¸¤á¤Æ¡¢¶¦¤Ë¡ØÀàÅð¤ÎÀ®²Ì¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÉÔËþ¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡Ù¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¤È¿äǧ¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬²Äǽ¤È¤Ê¤ë¡ÊËÜȽ·è¤Ï¡¢·ëÏÀ¤òÀè¼è¤ê¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤ï¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤â¤·¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȹԤǤʤ¤¤È¤·¤¿¤é¡¢¤½¤Î¼Ô¤¬ÀàÅðÌÜŪ¤Ç¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿¤È¤«¡¢¡ØÀàÅð¤ÎÀ®²Ì¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡Ù¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÊü²Ð¤·¤¿¤È¤Ï¡¢¤¿¤ä¤¹¤¯¿äǧ¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¤Ï¤º¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡Ë¤³¤³¤Ç¤Ï¡¢²áµî¤ÎÈȹԤˤĤ¤¤Æǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë³ÆÈȹԤηÀµ¡¤ÎÁí¹ç¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¿äǧ¤Ç¤¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¡Ê·¹¸þ¡Ë¤ò´ð¤Ë¤·¤Æ¡¢º£²ó¤ÎÈȹԤ⤽¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀ³Ê¡Ê·¹¸þ¡Ë¤òͤ¹¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤«¤È¿äǧ¤Ç¤¤ë¤Ë²á¤®¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ï¤Þ¤µ¤Ë¡Ø°À³Ê¤ÎΩ¾Ú¡Ù¤½¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¸«¤¨¤ë¡×[8]¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¤³¤³¤Ç¤âO»á¤Î¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç²¿ÅÙ¤âÀàÅð¤ÎÀ®²Ì¤¬¤¢¤¬¤é¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÊü²Ð¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢º£Å٤⤽¤¦¤·¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÁ°²Ê¤ò»È¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¸¶¿³ºÛȽ´±¤Ï¡¢°À³ÊΩ¾Ú¤ò¼õ¤±Æþ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤Ê¤ÉÁ´¤¯¤Ê¤¯¡¢¡ÖÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¡×¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÁ°²Ê¤ò»È¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È»×¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¼ÂºÝ¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ë°À³ÊΩ¾Ú¤Î¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤ËÖȤäƤ¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Î¤â¤¿¤é¤¹Í½ÃÇ¡¦Êи«¤Î¤È¤ê¤³¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¤È¤³¤í¤Ç¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢»ä¤¬¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ½ñ¤Ç°úÍѤ·¤¿Êü²Ð¤Î¼Â¾ÚŪ¸¦µæ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÏÀʸ¤òÍøÍѤ·¤Æ¡¢¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÏÀÍý¤òŸ³«¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
²°ÆâÊü²Ð¤ÏÁ´ÂΤÎ56.9¡ó¡¢ÌýÎà¤Î»ÈÍѤ¬15.8¡ó¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤È̵´Ø·¸¤Ê¼Ô¤ÎÈȹԤ¬44.5¡ó¡£¤³¤ì¤é¤ò³Ý¤±¹ç¤ï¤»¤ë¤È³ÎΨÏÀŪ¤Ë¤Ï4.0¡ó¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡¢¤È¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢ÀàÅð¤È´ØÏ¢¤¢¤ë¤â¤Î¤Î³ä¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë2.1¡ó¤ò³Ý¤±¹ç¤ï¤»¤ë¤È0.84¡ó¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢¤³¤ì¤Ï¶Ë¤á¤Æµ©¤Ê¥±¡¼¥¹¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡¢¤È¡£
¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤ÎÏÀÍý¤¬ÄÌÍѤ·¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤ÏÅý·×³Ø¤Î½éÊâ¤ò³Ø¤ó¤À¿Í¤Ë¤ÏÌÀÇò¤Ê¤³¤È¤Ç¤¹¡£Åý·×¾å¤Î³Æ¾ò·ï¤¬´°Á´¤ÊÆÈΩÊÑ¿ô¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¡¢¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á³Æ¾ò·ï¤Î´Ö¤ÎÁê´Ø·¸¿ô¤¬£°¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¾ÚÌÀ¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¸Â¤ê¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬Å¸³«¤¹¤ë³Ý¤±»»¤Ë¤è¤ë³ÎΨÏÀ¤Ï̵°ÕÌ£¤Ç¤¹¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï¼ÂÂ֤Ȥ«¤±Î¥¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤È¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤ï¤«¤ê¤ä¤¹¤¤¤è¤¦¤ËÎã¤ò¾å¤²¤ÆÀâÌÀ¤·¤Þ¤¹¡£
ÌÜ·â¾Ú¿Í¤¬¡ÖÈȿͤÏ50ºÐÂå¤ÎÃËÀ¤Ç¡¢¿ÈŤÏ170¥»¥ó¥Á¡¢ÂνŤÏ80¥¥í¤¯¤é¤¤¡¢¸ý¤Ò¤²¤È¤¢¤´¤Ò¤²¤òÀ¸¤ä¤·¡¢ÇòȱƬ¤À¤Ã¤¿¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤¿¤È¤·¤Þ¤¹¡£
50ºÐÂå¤ÏÁ´¿Í¸ý¤Î10ʬ¤Î1
¿ÈĹ170¥»¥ó¥Á¤Î¿Í¤Ï150¿Í¤Ë1¿Í
ÃËÀ¤ÏÁ´¿Í¸ý¤Î2ʬ¤Î1
ÂνÅ80¥¥í¤Î¿Í¤Ï300¿Í¤Ë1¿Í
¸ý¤Ò¤²¤È¤¢¤´¤Ò¤²¤òÀ¸¤ä¤·¤¿¿Í¤Ï15,000¿Í¤Ë1¿Í
Çòȱ¤Ï3500¿Í¤Ë1¿Í
¤À¤È¤·¤Þ¤¹¡£
¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢¤³¤ÎÆÃħ¤ò»ý¤Ã¤¿¿Í¤Ï1575²¯¿Í¤Ë1¿Í¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤³¤ÎÌÜ·â¾Ú¸À¤ÏDNA·¿´ÕÄê°Ê¾å¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤò»ý¤Ä¼±Ê̾ڵò¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤ó¤ÊÇϼ¯¤Ê¤³¤È¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
Ïäò¤â¤È¤ËÌᤷ¤Þ¤·¤ç¤¦¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢ÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤¿¤á¤ËÁ°²Ê¤òµöÍƤ¹¤ë¾ò·ï¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤ËÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡¢ÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ì¤Ð¤ê¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡Ê¸¶È½·è8ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤Î¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦´ð½à¤Ï´Ë¤ä¤«¤Ë¤¹¤®¤Þ¤¹¡£¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦ÄøÅ٤Ǥϡ¢¸¶È½·è¼«¿È¤¬¸í¤ê¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¡½¡½¡Ö¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç·«¤êÊÖ¤·¤ä¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¿¤Î¤À¤«¤é¡¢¤Þ¤¿¤ä¤Ã¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¤¤¤¦À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦´í¸±À¤¬Í¾¤ê¤Ë¤âÂ礤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤·¤«¤â¡¢Ëܿͤ¿¤Á¤Ï¤½¤Î´í¸±¤ò²óÈò¤Ç¤¤¿¤È»×¤¤¹þ¤ó¤Ç¤¤¤ë¤À¤±¤Ë;·×¤Ë´í¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤¨¤Þ¤¹¡£
³Î¤«¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤¬¸À¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î¤¦¤Á¡¢¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¹Ô¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¡Ö¤¢¤ëÄøÅÙ¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¡ÊƱÁ°7ÊǡˤǤ·¤ç¤¦¡£µï¼¼Æâ¤ÇÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤ÆÊü²Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡Ö¤è¤ê°ìÁظÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¡ÊƱÁ°¡Ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊü²ÐÈȤϡ½¡½¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡½¡½¾¯¤Ê¤«¤é¤ºÂ¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¸¶È½·è¤¬¸À¤¦¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¹Í¤¨Êý¤ÏÎ㤨¤Ð·ì±Õ·¿¤Ë»÷¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡££Â·¿¤Î·ì±Õ·¿¤Î¿Íʪ¤Ï¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢·ì±Õ·¿´ÕÄê¤Ë¤ÏÈȿͼ±Ê̤Τ¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï·è¤·¤Æ·ì±Õ·¿¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ë¤Ï°·¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£·ì±Õ·¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤ÏµÒ´ÑŪ¤Ê°À¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤ÎµÒ´ÑŪ¤Ê²ÁÃͰʾå¤Ë²áÂçɾ²Á¤µ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏB·¿¤À¤«¤éºá¤òÈȤ·¤ä¤¹¤¤¤Ê¤É¤È¹Í¤¨¤ë¿Í¤Ï¤¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÏµÒ´ÑŪ¤Ç¹çÍýŪ¤Êɾ²Á¤ò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬Èó¾ï¤Ëº¤Æñ¤Ê¾Úµò¤Ç¤¹¡£¥¦¥£¥°¥â¥¢¤¬»ØŦ¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ìÇ濳¤Ç¤¢¤ì¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Ï°íå¤ÊÈȺá¤ÎµÏ¿¤Ë¶¯¤¯°õ¾Ý¤Å¤±¤é¤ì¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¤¡¢ÃΤ餺ÃΤ餺¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Ë²áÂç¤Êɾ²Á¤ò¤·¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£µö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡Ö°À³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤Î櫤ËÍî¤Á¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤Ïº£²ó¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤ÈÎà»÷¤·¤¿ÆÃħŪ¤ÊÁ°²Ê¤¬¤¢¤ë¡£¤À¤«¤é¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢º£ÅÙ¤â¤ä¤Ã¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¡£¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿´¾Ú·ÁÀ®¡½¡½Í½ÃÇ¡¢Êи«¡½¡½¤Î´í¸±¤¬¤½¤³¤Ëʬ¤«¤Á¤¬¤¿¤¯È¼¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
Á°²Ê¤òÈȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤ¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î´í¸±¤«¤é¼«Í³¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Á°²Ê¤ò¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤ¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤ò¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ëο²ï¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¿Âç¤ÊÈȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¸¶È½·è¤¬ºÎÍѤ·¤¿µöÍÆÀ¤Î´ð½à¤Ï´Ë¤ä¤«¤¹¤®¤Þ¤¹¡£
¤½¤ì¤Ç¤Ï¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ï¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê´ð½à¤Ë¤è¤ë¤Ù¤¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤òο²ï¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¡¢¹âÅÙ¤ÎÈȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ï¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Ç¤·¤ç¤¦¤«¡£¸½ºßÀ¤³¦¤ÇºÇ¤âÎɤ¯Æɤޤì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¾ÚµòË¡¤Î¶µ²Ê½ñ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤Î¶µ²Ê½ñ¤Ë¤Ï¤³¤¦½ñ¤«¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡Ö¤½¤ì¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ÎÊýË¡¤¬¤Û¤È¤ó¤ÉƱ°ì(nearly identical)¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤áÀµ¤Ë¤½¤ì¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¼ê»Å»ö(handiwork)¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¼±Ê̤Ǥ¤ë(earmark)¤è¤¦¤Ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȤ·¤¿Ê̤κá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»¦¿Í¡¢¶¯Åð¤ä¥ì¥¤¥×¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤ÊƱ¼ï¤ÎÈȺ᤬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤ÏÁ´¤¯Â¤ê¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤ÎÈȺá¤Î¥Ñ¥¿¡¼¥ó¤äÆÃħ¤¬¡¢¤È¤Æ¤â°Û¾ï¤ÇºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¡¢½ð̾(signature)¤Ë¤âÅù¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡×[9]¡£
ÆüËܤκÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ë°ËÆ£²í¿ÍȽ»ö¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤ÈƱÍͤιͤ¨¤òÊ̤Îɽ¸½¤Ç½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
¡ÖÃí°Õ¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ï¡¢Ã±¤ËÈȺá¤ÎÆâÍƤä¼ê¸ý¤¬Îà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤ÇÎà»÷»ö¼Â¤Ë¤è¤ëΩ¾Ú¤òµö¤·¤Æ¤è¤¤¤ï¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¥á¥ë¥¯¥Þ¡¼¥ë¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬²áµî¤ËÎà»÷¤ÎÈȺá¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¼«ÂΤ«¤é¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬º£²óµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿ÈȺá¤ÎÈȿͤǤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¡¢Ä¾Àܡʤ¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á°À³Ê¤È¤¤¤¦Ãæ´Ö¹à¤ò²ðºß¤µ¤»¤ë¤³¤È¤Ê¤¯¡Ë¿äǧ¤Ç¤¤ë¤«¤É¤¦¤«¡¢¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ÈȺá¤ÎÆâÍƤä¼ê¸ý¤¬Îà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤ꤺ¡¢¤½¤ÎÆâÍƤä¼ê¸ý¤¬ÈȿͤËÆÃͤΤâ¤Î¤È¤¤¤¨¤ëÄøÅÙ¤ËÆüì¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òÍפ¹¤ë¤Ç¤¢¤í¤¦¡×[10]¡£
¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤Îɽ¸½¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡ÖÈȿͤνð̾¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤°¤é¤¤¤Ë°Û¾ï¤ÇºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿ÆÃħ¤¬¤¢¤ë¾ì¹ç¡×¡¢°ËƣȽ»ö¤Îɽ¸½¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡Ö°À³Ê¤È¤¤¤¦Ãæ´Ö¹à¤ò²ðºß¤µ¤»¤ë¤³¤È¤Ê¤¯Ä¾ÀÜÈȿͤȿäǧ¤Ç¤¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¡¢¤½¤ÎÆâÍƤä¼ê¸ý¤¬Æüì¤Ê¾ì¹ç¡×¤Ë¤Ï¤¸¤á¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï¡½¡½À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡½¡½Èȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤¦¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£ËÜ·ï¤ÇÌäÂê¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤¿O»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿ÆÃħ¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Éô²°¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤Æ¤½¤Î¾ì¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤Æ²Ð¤ò¤Ä¤±¤ë¿Í¤Ï¤Û¤«¤Ë¤â¤¿¤¯¤µ¤ó¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤³¤Î¼ê¸ý¤ÏÈà¤Î½ð̾¤È¤Ï¸À¤¨¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£¤½¤ÎÈȹԤ«¤éÈȿͤÏÈà¤À¤ÈľÀÜǧÄꤹ¤ë¤³¤È¤Ê¤É¤Ç¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£O»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¡¢º£²óµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿»ö·ï¤ÎÈȿͤ¬Èà¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£
¸¶È½·è¤ÏÇË´þ¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
Ĺ´±Ê¤Ӥ˺ǹâºÛȽ»ö¤Î³§¤µ¤ó¡¢
ÂçÀµ7ǯ¡¢1918ǯ¡¢¤¤¤Þ¤«¤é94ǯ¤Þ¤¨¤Ë¡¢Â翳±¡¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¸¶Â§¤òÀë¸À¤·¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤Ï¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎË¡Íý¤òºÎÍѤ·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¼¤Íè¡¢¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ÎºÇ½ª¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÏÀޤˤդì¤Æ¤³¤Î¸¶Â§¤ò³Îǧ¤·¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢Î㳰Ū¤ËÁ°²Ê¤¬¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤ê¤¦¤ë´ö¤Ä¤«¤Î¾ì¹ç¤ò¼¨¤·¤Æ¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£Â翳±¡¤äºÇ¹âºÛ¤ÏÎã³°¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤â¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ë±è¤¦È½ÃǤò¤·¤Æ¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£
¤¤¤Þ¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤¬Ä¾Ì̤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎÎã³°¤Î°ì¤Ä¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡ÖÈȿͼ±Ê̾ڵò¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤È¤¤¤¦ÌäÂê¤Ç¤¹¡£¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ï¡¢¤³¤³¤Ç¤â¿ÍÎඦÄ̤λñ»º¤È¤â¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤Îˡ§¤ò½¼Ê¬¤Ë»²¾È¤·¤Æ¸·³Ê¤ÇÌÀ³Î¤Ê¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òÄ輨¤¹¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¹¡£·è¤·¤Æ¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎË¡Íý¤ËÉ÷·ê¤ò¤¢¤±¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¤³¤È¤ò¤·¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ë¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ò¼é¤ê¤«¤Ä¤½¤ì¤ò¶¯²½¤¹¤Ù¤Íýͳ¤¬¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤ì¤ÏºÛȽ°÷À©Å٤Ǥ¹¡£ºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Ï¡¢·º»öºÛȽ¤Î»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Ë»Ô̱¤Î·òÁ´¤Ê¼Ò²ñ¾ï¼±¤òÈ¿±Ç¤µ¤»¤ë¤³¤È¤òÌÜŪ¤È¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤½¤·¤Æ»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Ï¾Úµò¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£·è¤·¤Æ¡¢Í½ÃǤäÊ諤ä»×¤¤¹þ¤ß¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æͺá¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¤³¤È¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£»Ô̱¤Ë¤è¤ëȽÃǤ¬Å¬Àµ¤Ë¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤¢¤ë¤Î¤¬¾ÚµòË¡¤Ç¤¹¡£ºÛȽ´±¤¬Ë¡Î§¤ÎÀìÌç²È¤È¤·¤Æ¾Úµò¤ÎÁªÊ̤òŬÀµ¤Ë¹Ô¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¡¢»Ô̱¤Î¾ï¼±¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯¾Úµò¤Îɾ²Á¤ä»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤ÎÁ°Äó¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
¥¦¥£¥°¥â¥¢¤¬»ØŦ¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢»Ô̱¤Ç¤¢¤ìºÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ì¡¢¿Í´Ö¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤò²áÂç¤Ëɾ²Á¤·¡¢°íå¤ÊÈȺá¤ÎµÏ¿¤ËÏǤ蘆¤ì¤¬¤Á¤Ç¤¹¡£¤Ç¤¹¤«¤é¡¢¤½¤Î´í¸±¤òÃΤäƤ¤¤ëºÛȽ´±¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾Úµò¤ò¸·³Ê¤Ëµ¬À©¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡£¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ï»ºÀ¼¤ò¾å¤²¤¿¿·¤¿¤Ê»Ô̱»²²Ã¤Î»ÊË¡À©ÅÙ¤ò¡¢Á´À¤³¦¤Î¿Í¡¹¤«¤é¿®Íꤵ¤ì¤ëΩÇɤʤâ¤Î¤Ë°é¤Æ¤Æ¹Ô¤«¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Á°²Ê¤Î¤¢¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¤¿¤È¤¨¾Úµò¤¬Çö¤¯¤Æ¤â¡¢»÷¤¿¤è¤¦¤ÊÁ°²Ê¤¬¤¢¤ì¤ÐÍưפËͺá¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦¡£¤½¤¦¤·¤¿Ñͺá¤òÀ¸¤ß½Ð¤¹¤è¤¦¤Ê´í¤Ê¤¤À©Å٤ˤ·¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤ê¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£
¤¢¤ê¤¬¤È¤¦¤´¤¶¤¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£
Ãí
[1] £±Wigmore on Evidence (3d ed 1940),¡ø194.
[2] Edwin M. Borchard, Convicting the Innocence (1932), at 369-370.
[3] People v. Zackowitz, 254 N.Y. 192 (1930), at 198.
[4] Edward J. Imwinkelreid, Uncharged Misconduct Evidence, 2 vols (West, 2009).
[5] Edward J. Imwinkelreid, ¡ÈUncharged Misconduct¡É, 12 Litigation 25 (1985-1986), at 25.
[6]¾åÌî¸ü¡ØÅÔ»Ô·¿Êü²ÐÈȺ᡽¡½Êü²ÐÈȺῴÍýʬÀÏÆþÌç¡Ù¡ÊΩ²Ö½ñ˼1998¡Ë¡¢24¡¢29-30ÊÇ¡£
[7] ÌçÌîÇî¡ÖƱ¼ïÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤òµö¤µ¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¸¶¿³¤ÎÁ¼ÃÖ¤¬°ãË¡¤È¤µ¤ì¤¿»öÎã¡×·º»öË¡¥¸¥ã¡¼¥Ê¥ë31¡Ý83¡Ê2011¡Ë¡¢88~89ÊÇ¡£
[8] ÌçÌÁ°Ãí¡¢88~89ÊÇ¡£
[9] McCormick, On Evidence, 6th ed (Thomson/West, 2006), 315.
[10] °ËÆ£²í¿Í¡ÖÎà»÷»ö¼Â¤Ë¤è¤ëΩ¾Ú¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡×¡Ø¿¢Â¼Î©ÏºÈ½»öÂà´±µÇ°ÏÀʸ½¸¡ÊÂ裱´¬¡Ë¡Ù¡ÊΩ²Ö½ñ˼2011¡Ë¡¢372ÊÇ¡£
¡Ú¤³¤ì¤ÏºÇ¹âºÛȽ½êÂ裲¾®Ë¡ÄîÊ¿À®24ǯ9·î7ÆüȽ·è¤Î¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ½ñ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡Û
£³¡¡ÈÈ¿ÍÀǧÄê¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¾ºá¾Úµò¤¬µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¾ò·ï
¤µ¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ì¤Ç¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Î²ÝÂ꡽¡½Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤ëÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤ÎǧÄ꡽¡½¤òÏÀ¤¸¤ë½àÈ÷¤¬¤Ç¤¤¿¡£ËÜÂê¤ËÆþ¤í¤¦¡£¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤½¤·¤ÆϢˮ¾Úµòµ¬Â§¤Ï¡¢¡ÖƱ°ìÀ¡×(identity)¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤ÁÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬µ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿ÈȺá¤ÎÈȿͤǤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¡ÊÈÈ¿ÍÀ¡Ë¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¾ºá¾Úµò¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë(FRE404(b))¡£¤³¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤ò»Ù¤¨¤ë¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¡Ê¿äǧ²áÄø¡Ë¤Ï²¿¤À¤í¤¦¤«¡£Â¾ºá¤¬µ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿ÈȺá¤È¡ÖÎà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎÊÀ³²¤Ï²¿°ì¤Ä²ò¾Ã¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¤à¤·¤í¤½¤ì¤ÏÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤Î¿äǧ²áÄø¤òŵ·¿Åª¤Ë¼¨¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£Àè¤Ë¿Þ¼¨¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¡Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Aºá¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¤Ï¡¢¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Aºá¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÈȺá¤òÈȤ¹À³Ê·¹¸þ¤ò¤â¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤ò΢ÉÕ¤±¤ë¡¢¤·¤¬¤¿¤Ã¤Æ¡¢£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏAºá¤Ë»÷¤¿¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤òÈȤ·¤¿²ÄǽÀ¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¿äǧ²áÄø¤Ï¡¢Aºá¤È¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤¬Îà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ½é¤á¤ÆÀ®¤êΩ¤Ä¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Îà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ì¤Ð¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Û¤É¶¯¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Î㤨¤Ð¡¢»¦¿Í¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎºÛȽ¤Ç¡¢Èà¤Îƻϩ¸òÄÌË¡°ãÈ¿¤äÀàÅð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤¬Äó½Ð¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆºÛȽ°÷¤¬Èï¹ð¿Í¤ËÉÔ¸øÀµ¤ÊͽÃÇÊ諤ò»ý¤Ä¿´ÇۤϤ¢¤Þ¤ê¤Ê¤¤¡£Îà»÷¤ÎÈȺá¤Ç¤¢¤ë»¦¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎÊý¤¬¤Ï¤ë¤«¤Ë¶¯¤¤Í½ÃÇÊ諤òºÛȽ°÷¤ËÍ¿¤¨¡¢¸øÀµ¤Ê¾Úµòɾ²Á¤òº¤Æñ¤Ë¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤ÎŨ°Õ¤òÊú¤«¤»¤ë´í¸±À¤ò»ý¤Ä¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢ÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤¿¤á¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤ò»Ù¤¨¤ë¿äǧ²áÄø¤Ï¡¢Â¾ºá¤È¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤È¤Î´Ö¤Î¡ÖÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤ÏÊ̤ΤȤ³¤í¤Ëµá¤á¤é¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤Ï¾ºá¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤ëÈÈ¿ÍÀǧÄê¤Î¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤ò¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÀâÌÀ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
¡Ö¤½¤ÎÊýË¡¤¬¤Û¤È¤ó¤ÉƱ°ì(nearly identical)¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤áÀµ¤Ë¤½¤ì¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¼ê»Å»ö(handiwork)¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¼±Ê̤Ǥ¤ë(earmark)¤è¤¦¤Ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȤ·¤¿Ê̤κá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»¦¿Í¡¢¶¯Åð¤ä¥ì¥¤¥×¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤ÊƱ¼ï¤ÎÈȺ᤬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤ÏÁ´¤¯Â¤ê¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤ÎÈȺá¤Î¥Ñ¥¿¡¼¥ó¤äÆÃħ¤¬¡¢¤È¤Æ¤â°Û¾ï¤ÇºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¡¢½ð̾(signature)¤Ë¤âÅù¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡×[21]¡£
¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤Ï¤½¤ÎÎã¤È¤·¤ÆÁ°½Ð¤Î¡ÖÍáÁå¤Î²Ö²Ç¡×»ö·ï¤òµó¤²¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¥¸¥ç¡¼¥¸¡¦¥¸¥ç¥»¥Õ¡¦¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Ï¡¢¥Ù¥Ã¥·¡¼¡¦¥Þ¥ó¥Ç¥£¤òÈà¤é¤Î¥Þ¥ó¥·¥ç¥ó¤ÎÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤µ¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»¦¿Í¤Îºá¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¡£Ë´¤¯¤Ê¤ëÁ°¤Ë2¿Í¤Ï·ëº§¼°¤òµó¤²¡¢¥Þ¥ó¥Ç¥£¤ÏÁ´ºâ»º¤ò¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Ë°ä£¤¹¤ë»Ý¤Î°ä¸À½ñ¤Ë½ð̾¤·¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£¸øȽ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢¥¹¥ß¥¹¤¬Â¾¤Ë¿ô̾¤Î½÷À¤È·ëº§¼°¤òµó¤²¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤Î½÷À¤¬¤ß¤ÊÁ´ºâ»º¤ò¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Ë°ä¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦°ä¸À½ñ¤Ë½ð̾¤·¤¿¸å¤ËÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤·¤¿¡¢¤È¤¤¤¦¾Úµò¤ò¿½ÀÁ¤·¤¿¡£¸øȽºÛȽ´±¤Ï¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤òµöÍƤ·¤Æ¡¢¥¹¥ß¥¹¤òͺá¤È¤·¤Æ»à·º¤ò¸À¤¤ÅϤ·¤¿¡£·º»ö¾åÁʺÛȽ½ê¤â¤³¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤òǧ¤á¤ÆͺáȽ·è¤ò¾µÇ§¤·¤¿[22]¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢Â¾ºá¤ÎÆâÍƤ¬¶Ë¤á¤ÆÆðۤǰ۾ï¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤Î´í¸±À¤òµ¤¤Ë³Ý¤±¤ëɬÍפ¬¤Ê¤¤¤Û¤É¤Ë¡¢¼±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¹â¤¤¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡¢¤³¤ÎÎã³°¤¬Å¬ÍѤǤ¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£´¡¡ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ
ËÜ·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¤Ï¤É¤¦¤«¡£¸¶È½·è¤ÏO»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤Î¤¦¤Á10·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡Ö¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤¬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢¤·¤«¤â¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¡Ö¸ÇÃå¡×¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ëÅÀ¤¬¡ÖÆÃħŪ¡×¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢²°Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤ÆÃå²Ð¤¹¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦Êü²Ð¤Î¼ê¸ý¤Ï¡¢¹¤¯Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤³¤Î¼ê¸ý¤ÏÊü²ÐÈȤÎƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤Û¤É¤Ë¸ÄÀŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£
²Ê³Ø·Ù»¡¸¦µæ½ê¤Î»³²¬°ì¿®¤¬¾¼ÏÂ50ǯÂå½éƬ¤Î1ǯ´Ö¤ËȯÀ¸¤·¤¿Á´¹ñ¤ÎÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤òÂоݤ˹Ԥ俸¦µæ¤Ë¤è¤ë¤È¡¢Á´1691·ï¤Î¤¦¤Á963·ï¡Ê56.9%¡Ë¤¬²°Æâ¤òÊü²ÐÅÀ¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡£Ã±°ìÈȹԷ²¡Ê861·ï¡Ë¤Ç¤Ï69.8%¡¢Ï¢Â³ÈȹԷ²¡Ê830·ï¡Ë¤Ç¤Ï43.6%¤Î¥±¡¼¥¹¤Ç²°Æâ¤ÇÊü²Ð¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[23]¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢¿ÀÆàÀ·Ù²Ê³ØÁܺº¸¦µæ½ê¿´Íý²ÝĹ¤Î¾åÌî¸ü¤¬¾¼ÏÂ46ǯ¤«¤é55ǯ¤Þ¤Ç¤Î10ǯ´Ö¤Ë¿ÀÆàÀÆâ¤ÇΩ·ï¤µ¤ì¤¿379Îã¤ÎÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¸¦µæ¤Ë¤è¤ë¤È¡¢·úʪÊü²Ð»ö·ï309·ï¡½¡½Ã±°ìÊü²Ð»ö·ï56·ï¡¢Ï¢Â³Êü²Ð»ö·ï253·ï¡ÊÈȿͤÏ51¿Í¡Ë¡½¡½¤Î¤¦¤Á¡¢ÅÀ²Ð¾ì½ê¤¬²°Æâ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤â¤Î¤¬Ã±°ìÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Ç¤Ï43·ï¡Ê76.8%¡Ë¡¢Ï¢Â³Êü²Ð»ö·ï¤Ç¤Ï104·ï¡Ê41.1%¡Ë¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿[24]¡£¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢Åìµþ¾ÃËÉÄ£¤¬¾¼ÏÂ55ǯ¤«¤é57ǯ¤Þ¤Ç¤Î3ǯ´Ö¤ÎÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¹Ô¤Ã¤¿Ä´ºº·ë²Ì¤Ç¤â¡¢Êü²Ð¾ì½ê¤Ï¡Ö·úʪÆâÉô¡×¤¬ºÇ¤â¿¤¤¡£Á´4,802·ï¤ÎÌóȾ¿ô2,044·ï¤¬·úʪÆâÉô¤òÊü²Ð¾ì½ê¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢2°Ì¤Î¡Ö³°ÊÉ¡¢¸®²¼Åù¡×742·ï¤òÂ礤¯°ú¤Î¥¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë[25]¡£
¤Ä¤®¤Ë¡¢ÅôÌý¤Î»ÈÍѤâ·è¤·¤ÆÄÁ¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£»³²¬¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ç¤ÏÌýÎà¤Î»ÈÍѤÏñ°ìÈȹԷ²¤Ç25.0%¡¢Ï¢Â³ÈȹԷ²¤Ç15.8%¤Ç¤¢¤ë[26]¡£¾åÌî¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ç¤ÏÁ´379·ï¤Î¤¦¤ÁÌýÎà¤ò»ÈÍѤ·¤¿Îã¤Ï57·ï¡Ê15%¡Ë¤Ç¤¢¤ë[27]¡£²£ÉͻԾÃËɶɤ¬¹Ô¤Ã¤¿²£ÉÍ»ÔÆâ¤Ç¾¼ÏÂ63ǯ¤«¤éÊ¿À®9ǯ¤Þ¤Ç¤Î10ǯ´Ö¤ËȯÀ¸¤·¤¿Êü²Ð»ö·ï¤ÎÄ´ºº¤Ë¤è¤ë¤È¡¢·úʪÊü²Ð»ö·ï¡Ê1258·ï¡Ë¤Î13.5¡ó¡Ê170·ï¡Ë¤¬¡Ö¥¬¥½¥ê¥ó¡¦ÅôÌý¡×¤òÃå²Ðʪ¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[28]¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢ÌýÎà¤ÎÆþ¼êÊýË¡¤ò¤ß¤ë¤È¡¢¾åÌî¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ç¤Ï34·ï¡Ê64.9%¡Ë¤Ç¡Ö¸½¾ìËô¤Ï¸½¾ìÉÕ¶á¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡×ÌýÎब»ÈÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[29]¡£
Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤¬¡ÖÆÃħŪ¡×¤Èɾ¤¹¤ëO»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤ÎÂÖÍͤϡ¢·è¤·¤ÆÄÁ¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤à¤·¤íÊü²ÐÈȤδ֤Ǥϥݥԥå¥é¡¼¤Ï¼ê¸ý¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£O»á°Ê³°¤ÎÊü²ÐÈȤο¤¯¤¬¤½¤ì¤ÈƱ¤¸ÊýË¡¤ÇÊü²Ð¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Î¡Ö¼êÃÊÊýË¡¡×¤òËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̤λØɸ¤È¤·¤ÆÍѤ¤¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¤Ê¤ª¡¢¸¶È½·è¤ÏƱ¤¸ÊýË¡¤Ë¤è¤ëÊü²Ð¤¬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¤¿¤¿¤á¤Ë¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤Ê¤É¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡Ê6ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¡Ö¸ÇÃå²½¡×¤Î°ÕÌ£¤ÏÎɤ¯¤ï¤«¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£O»á¤¬Êü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¤¦¤Á¤Ë¾ò·ïÈ¿¼Í¤È¤·¤Æ¥Ñ¥Ö¥í¥Õ¤Î¸¤¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÊü²Ð¤ò¹Ô¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¾Úµò¤Ï¤É¤³¤Ë¤â¤Ê¤¤¡£»³²¬°ì¿®¤ä¾åÌî¸ü¤¬»ØŦ¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Êü²ÐÈȤˤϡÖñ°ìÈȹԷ²¡×¤È¡ÖϢ³ÈȹԷ²¡×¤È¤¬¤¢¤ê¡¢Î¾¼Ô¤ÎÈȹԷÁÂ֤ˤÏÁê°ã¤¬¤¢¤ë¡£¡ÖϢ³ÈȹԷ²¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢Íפ¹¤ë¤Ëû´ü´Ö¤ËƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤è¤ëÊü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¿Í¡¹¤Î¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì°Ê¾å¤Ç¤â¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê²¼¤Ç¤â¤Ê¤¤¡£Ï¢Â³ÈȹԷ²¤ÎÊü²ÐÈȤϤߤÊƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤Ç¤ÎÊü²Ð¤òÊ£¿ô²ó·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢ÈȹԤ´¤È¤Ë¼ê¸ý¤òÊѤ¨¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤³¤ì¤ò¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Î¸ÇÃå²½¡×¤Ê¤É¤È¤¤¤Ã¤Æ²¿¤«ÆÃÊ̤ʰÕÌ£¤¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ëм¤á¤«¤¹¤Î¤ÏÀ¿¼Â¤ÊÂÖÅ٤ǤϤʤ¤¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢Æ±¤¸¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹·ÁÂÖ¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Ï¡¢O»á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤À¤±¤Ë¸Â¤é¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤ì¤òª¤¨¤Æ¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Î¸ÇÃå²½¡×¤Ê¤É¤È¶Ä¡¹¤·¤¤¥é¥Ù¥ë¤òŽ¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤À¤«¤é¤½¤ì¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈȹÔÂÖÍͤ¬¡Ö¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¡×¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢Á´¤¯²Ê³ØŪ¤Êº¬µò¤Î¤Ê¤¤²±Â¬¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¼¡¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢O»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤Ï¡¢¤¤¤º¤ì¤âÀàÅð¤ÎÌÜŪ¤ò㤷¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ÎʢΩ¤Á¤ò²ò¾Ã¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢¤³¤Î¡ÖÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡×¤ÎÅÀ¤ÇÆÃħŪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¿ô¤¢¤ëÆ°µ¡¤Î¤¦¤ÁÀàÅ𤬤¦¤Þ¤¯¤¤¤«¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ÎÉÔËþ¤òȯ»¶¤¹¤ë¡Ê¡Ö¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡×¡Ë¤È¤¤¤¦Æ°µ¡¤Ï¡ÖÆÃħŪ¡×¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢ÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤ÎǧÄê¤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¸¶È½·è¤¬»ØŦ¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¤ÇÊü²Ð¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï·è¤·¤ÆÄÁ¤·¤¤¤³¤È¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¤ÏÊü²Ð¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤ÆºÇ¤â°ìÈÌŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»³²¬°ì¿®¤Ï¡¢Ï¢Â³Êü²ÐÈȤÎÆ°µ¡¤ò¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¡Ö²Ð¤Î´î¤Ó¡×¡Ö±åº¨¡×¡Ö±Ñͺ»Ö¸þ¡×¡Ö¤½¤Î¾¡×¤Î5¤Ä¤ËʬÎष¤¿[30]¡£Ä´ººÂоݤȤʤä¿Á´81·ï¤Î¤¦¤Á60.5%¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤ë49·ï¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤¬¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¤Ç¤¢¤ë[31]¡£ÉÔËþ¤ÎÃæ¤Ë¤Ï¿Æ²¤È¤ÎíÂíà¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿Í´Ö´Ø·¸¤Ë¤è¤ë¤â¤Î¤¬Â¿¤¤¤¬¡¢Â¾¤ÎÈȺá¤ò°Õ¿Þ¤·¤¿¤¬À®¸ù¤·¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤«¤é¡ÖÍ×µáÁ˻ߤξõÂ֡פȤʤêÊü²Ð¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦Îã¤â¤¢¤ë¡£»³²¬¤Ï¡ÖÈæ³ÓŪñ½ã¤ÊÎã¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¡ÖÀàÅð¤òÌÜŪ¤È¤·¤Æ¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿¤¬Ìܻؤ·¤¿¸½¶â¤ò¸«½Ð¤¹¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿ÉÔËþ¤«¤é¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿²È²°Æâ¤ÇÊü²Ð¤·¤¿Î㤬¤¢¤ë¡×¤ÈÊó¹ð¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë[32]¡£¾åÌî¸ü¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ç¤â¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¤ÏºÇ¤â¥Ý¥Ô¥å¥é¡¼¤ÊÆ°µ¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¾åÌî¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡¢Ã±°ìÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Î29.8%¡¢Ï¢Â³Êü²Ð»ö·ï¤Î64.9%¤¬¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¤òÆ°µ¡¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Æ°µ¡¤ÎÂè1°Ì¤Ë¥é¥ó¥¯¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë[33]¡£Êü²ÐÈȤΤʤ«¤Ë¤ÏO»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤ÊÆ°µ¡¡½¡½¸¶È½·è¤Îɽ¸½¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¡½¡½¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¤¹¤ë¿Í¤¬°ìÄê¿ô¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤âÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̤λØɸ¤È¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¤³¤³¤Ç¤â¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Î¸ÇÃå²½¡×¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£Êü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤·¤¿·ë²Ì¡ÖÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¡Ê6ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ë³¤±¤Æ¸¶È½·è¤Ï¸À¤¦¡£
¡Ö¾Êý¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÈÀÜÃ夷¤¿»þ´ÖÂӤˡ¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤ÎÈȹԾì½ê¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤ÆÀàÅð¤ò¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÏÁ褤¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Æ±ÀàÅð¤ÎÈï³²ÉʤÏ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤È¥«¥Ã¥×ÌÍ1¸Ä¤Ë¤È¤É¤Þ¤Ã¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤òËþ¤µ¤»¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¤Ï¤¦¤«¤¬¤ï¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤«¤é¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ÎÊ¢¤¤¤»¤ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ËµÚ¤ó¤À²ÄǽÀ¤¬¹Í¤¨¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Ï¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢Îà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡×¡Ê6ÊÇ¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£
¤³¤ÎÏÀ»Ý¤Î¤Ê¤«¤Ç¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÏÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̤λØɸ¤È¤·¤Æ»È¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤¬ÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤ÏÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤Ø¤È¤¤¤¦¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢º£²ó¤â¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸½¤ì¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤ÈÏÀ¤¸¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤ì¤³¤½¤Þ¤µ¤Ë¡¢Ë¡¤¬¶Ø»ß¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÍøÍѤ˾¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£Æ±°ìÀ¼±Ê̤Τ¿¤á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎÍøÍѤϡ¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤¦¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤¬¶Ë¤á¤ÆÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¡½¡½¡Ö¤È¤Æ¤â°Û¾ï¤ÇºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¡¢½ð̾(signature)¤Ë¤âÅù¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¡×¡Ê¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¡Ë¡½¡½¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¡¢¤½¤ÎÆÃħ¡½¡½Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î½ð̾¡½¡½¤ò·ó¤ÍÈ÷¤¨¤¿ËÜ·ï¤âÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȹԤ˰㤤¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¸¶È½·è¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤òµöÍƤ¹¤ë¾ò·ï¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤ËÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡¢ÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ì¤Ð¤ê¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¸À¤¦¡Ê8ÊÇ¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤Î´ð½à¤Ï´Ë¤ä¤«¤¹¤®¤ë¡£¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦ÄøÅ٤Ǥϡ¢¸¶È½·è¼«¿È¤¬¸í¤ê¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦´í¸±À¤¬Í¾¤ê¤Ë¤âÂ礤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£³Î¤«¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤¬¸À¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î¤¦¤Á¡¢¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¹Ô¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¡Ö¤¢¤ëÄøÅÙ¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¡Ê7ÊǡˤÀ¤í¤¦¤·¡¢¤½¤Îµï¼¼Æâ¤ÇÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤ÆÊü²Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡Ö¤è¤ê°ìÁظÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¡ÊƱÁ°¡Ë¤À¤í¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Àè¤Ë»ØŦ¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊü²ÐÈȤϡ½¡½¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡½¡½¾¯¤Ê¤«¤é¤ºÂ¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï·ì±Õ·¿¤Ë»÷¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡££Â·¿¤Î·ì±Õ·¿¤Î¿Íʪ¤Ï¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢·ì±Õ·¿´ÕÄê¤Ë¤ÏÈȿͼ±Ê̤Τ¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï·è¤·¤Æ·ì±Õ·¿¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ë¤Ï°·¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Á°²Ê¤Ï¡¢·ì±Õ·¿¤È°ã¤Ã¤Æ¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤ò»ý¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤ÏÆÃħŪ¤ÊÁ°²Ê¤¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢º£ÅÙ¤â¤ä¤Ã¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿´¾Ú·ÁÀ®¡½¡½Í½ÃÇ¡¢Êи«¡½¡½¤Î´í¸±¤òȼ¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£·ì±Õ·¿¤Ë¤Ï¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊÀ³²¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤À¤«¤éÁ°²Ê¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤ò¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ëο²ï¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¿Âç¤Ê¼±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤Ê¤¤¸Â¤ê¡¢ºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤¬ºÎÍѤ·¤¿µöÍÆÀ¤Î´ð½à¤Ï´Ë¤ä¤«¤¹¤®¤ë¡£
Á°½Ò¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢ÌäÂê¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤¿Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤¬¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢ÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤ÎǧÄê¡ÊƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̡ˤΤ¿¤á¤Ë»ÈÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤ËÅö¤Æ¤Ï¤Þ¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤â¤¦¤¤¤Á¤ÉˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¿³ºº¡Ê¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¡Ë¤ò¹Ô¤ï¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎȽÃǤˤª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢Áʾ٤θ½¾ì¤ËľÀܿȤò¤ª¤¯»ö¼Â¿³ºÛȽ´±¤ÎȽÃǤ¬Âº½Å¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç¸¡Æ¤¤·¤¿¤È¤³¤í¤«¤é¤âÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ê¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢O»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤òµÑ²¼¤·¤¿1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÃǤϡ¢Â翳±¡°ÊÍè¤ÎºÇ½ª¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÎã¤È¡¢¤½¤Î´ðÁäȤʤ俱ÑÊƾڵòË¡¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤ËÃé¼Â¤Ë½¾¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¶Ë¤á¤ÆÀµ¤·¤¤¡£¤½¤ì¤Ð¤«¤ê¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ÎȽÃǤòƳ¤¯¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤ÈÊÛ¸î¿Í¤ËÊ¿Åù¤Ë°Õ¸«Äó½Ð¤Îµ¡²ñ¤òÍ¿¤¨¡ÊµÏ¿28¡Ë¡¢ÁÐÊý¤«¤é¾ÜºÙ¤Ê½ñÌ̤ˤè¤ë°Õ¸«¤Î³«ÄĤò¼õ¤±¤Æ¤«¤é¡ÊµÏ¿159~168ÊÇ¡Ë¡¢ºÇ½ªÅª¤ÊȽÃǤò¹Ô¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤½¤ÎȽÃǤβáÄø¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ×ó°ÕŪ¤ÊÍ×ÁǤϲ¿¤â¤Ê¤¤¤·¡¢¸í²ò¤ä»×¤¤¹þ¤ß¤È»×¤ï¤ì¤ëÍ×ÁǤâÁ´¤¯¤Ê¤¤¡£1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¿³ºº¤Î²áÄø¤Ë¤âÆâÍƤˤâºÛÎ̸¢¤ÎÍôÍѤȸƤ٤ë¤â¤Î¤Ï²¿¤â¤Ê¤¤¡£¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤³¤Î°ÕÌ£¤Ç¤â°ì¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÃǤÏŬˡ¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤³¤ì¤ò°ãË¡¤ÈÃǤ¸¤¿¸¶È½·è¤Ï¸í¤ê¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£µ¡¡·ëÏÀ
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢100ǯ¶á¤¯¼é¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¿¤ï¤¬¹ñºÇ½ª¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÎã¤Îή¤ì¤«¤é³°¤ì¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Á°²Ê¤ÏÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤Îŵ·¿¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤ò¸íƳ¤¹¤ë´í¸±¤ò»ý¤Ä¤Î¤Ç¡¢¾Úµò¤«¤éÇÓ½ü¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤ÎÎã³°¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÈÈ¿ÍÀǧÄê¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î´í¸±¤òο²ï¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Î¼±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î²ÁÃͤ¬¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï¤½¤ÎÈȿͤμê»Å»ö¤È¤·¤Æʶ¤¦Êý¤Ê¤¹ï°õ¤òÇØÉé¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤¬¿ÍÎà¤ÎÎò»ËŪ·Ð¸³¤Ëº¬º¹¤·¤¿À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤¬µá¤á¤ë¤È¤³¤í¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤¬¤¤¤¦¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦´ð½à¤Ï¡¢¤¢¤Þ¤ê¤Ë¤â´Ë¤ä¤«¤Ë²á¤®¤ë¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤òÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ¹¤ë´í¸±¤òÍÆǧ¤·¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤Î¤¢¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ëº¹Ê̤˾¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£Á°²Ê¤Î¤¢¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¤½¤¦¤Ç¤Ê¤¤Èï¹ð¿Í¤è¤ê¤âÁÊ°ø¤Ë´Ø¤·¤Æ¾¯¤Ê¤¤¾Úµò¤Ç¤âͺá¤È¤Ê¤ë´í¸±À¤òÉ餦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ë¤«¤é¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï¤Þ¤µ¤·¤¯¡¢¸øÊ¿¤ÊºÛȽ½ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÀµ¤Ê¿³Íý¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¸¢Íø¤òÇíÃ¥¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ë¾¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£
¡Ú°Ê²¼¾Êά¡Û
Ãí
[1]¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢1ÅٵѲ¼¤µ¤ì¤¿È½·èÆ¥Ëܤȶ¡½ÒÄ´½ñ¤Î°ìÉô¡Ê²µ38¡¤39¡Ë¤òºÆÅÙƱ¤¸Î©¾Ú¼ñ»Ý¤Ç¾ÚµòÀÁµá¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÏºÆÅٵѲ¼¤·¤¿¡ÊµÏ¿147ÊÇ¡Ë¡£
[2] Î㤨¤Ð¡¢²ò¸Û¤µ¤ì¤¿ÈïÍѼԤˤè¤ë¸ÛÍÑÃæ¤Î»ö¼Â¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Ú¸À¤Î¸úÎϤòÈÝÄꤷ¤¿ÂçȽÌÀ29¡¦4¡¦23·ºÏ¿2¡¾4¡¾66¡¢Èó¸ø³«Ë¡Äî¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¶¡½Ò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤òÈÝÄꤷ¤¿ÂçȽÌÀ39¡¦2¡¦22·ºÏ¿12¡¾2¡¾248¤Ê¤É¡¢Ëçµó¤Ë¤¤¤È¤Þ¤¬¤Ê¤¤¡£
[3] ¡ÖºÛȽĹ¤Ï¡¢Áʾٴط¸¿Í¤Î¤¹¤ë¿ÒÌäËô¤ÏÄĽҤ¬´û¤Ë¤·¤¿¿ÒÌä¼ã¤·¤¯¤ÏÄĽҤȽÅÊ£¤¹¤ë¤È¤¡¢Ëô¤Ï»ö·ï¤Ë´Ø·¸¤Î¤Ê¤¤»ö¹à¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤ë¤È¤¤½¤Î¾ÁêÅö¤Ç¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤Ï¡¢Áʾٴط¸¿Í¤ÎËܼÁŪ¤Ê¸¢Íø¤ò³²¤·¤Ê¤¤¸Â¤ê¡¢¤³¤ì¤òÀ©¸Â¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£Áʾٴط¸¿Í¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¶¡½Ò¤òµá¤á¤ë¹Ô°Ù¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤âƱÍͤǤ¢¤ë¡£¡×
[4] ¹¾²ÈµÁÃË¡Ø·º»ö¾ÚµòË¡¤Î´ðÁÃÍýÏÀ¡Ê²þÄûÈÇ¡Ë¡Ù¡ÊÍÈå³Õ1952¡Ë¡¢238ÊÇ¡¢ÀÄÌڱѸÞϺ¡Ö¾ÚµòǽÎϤÎÀ©¸Â¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤½¤Î¾¤ÎÌäÂê¡×ÃÄÆ£½Å¸÷ÊÔ¡ØˡΧ¼Â̳¹ÖºÂ·º»öÊÔ¡ÊÂè9´¬¡Ë¡Ù¡ÊÍÈå³Õ1956¡Ë¡¢1961¡¢1990ÊÇ¡£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÎã¤â¡ÖÈȹԤξõ¶·Åù¤ò»£±Æ¤·¤¿¤¤¤ï¤æ¤ë¸½¾ì¼Ì¿¿¤Ï¡¢È󶡽Ҿڵò¤Ë°¤·¡¢Åö³º¼Ì¿¿¼«ÂÎËô¤Ï¤½¤Î¾¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤ê»ö·ï¤È¤Î´ØÏ¢À¤òǧ¤á¤¦¤ë¸Â¤ê¾ÚµòǽÎϤò¶ñÈ÷¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¡Î¤ë¡Ï¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¡¢´ØÏ¢À¤ò¾ÚµòǽÎϤÎÍ×·ï¤È¹Í¤¨¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡ÊºÇ2¾®·è¾¼59¡¦12¡¦21·º½¸38-12-3071¡¢3074Êǡο·½ÉÁû¾ñ»ö·ï¡Ï¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£
[5] ºÇ¹âºÛÄ´ºº´±¤Ï¡¢¾¼ÏÂ41ǯ·èÄ꤬±ÑÊƾڵòË¡¤ÎÍýÏÀ¤òǧ¤á¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡ÊË¡Áâ²ñÊԡغǹâºÛȽ½êȽÎã²òÀâ·º»öÊÔ¾¼ÏÂ41ǯÅÙ¡Ù214-215ÊÇ¡ÎÌÊ°ú¿ÂϺ¡Ï¡Ë¡£
[6] McCormick, On Evidence, 6th ed (Thomson/West, 2006), 311.
[7] ˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¹ÍθÍ×ÁǤÏϢˮ¾Úµòµ¬Â§403¤ËÄê¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö¤¿¤È¤¨´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¡¢ÉÔ¸øÀµ¤ÊͽÃÇÊи«¡¢ÁèÅÀ¤Îº®Í𡢤ޤ¿¤ÏÇ濳¤ò¸íƳ¤¹¤ë´í¸±¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¼ã¤·¤¯¤Ï¡¢ÉÔÅö¤ÊÃÙÂÚ¡¢»þ´Ö¤ÎϲÈñ¡¢¤Þ¤¿¤Ï½ÅʣŪ¤Ê¾Úµò¤ÎÉÔɬÍפÊÄó½Ð¤ÎÊÀ³²¤Ø¤Î¹Íθ¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ëο²ï¤µ¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤òÇÓ½ü¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡£¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤âˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ÎȽÃǤ¬ÍѤ¤¤é¤ì¤ë¤Ù¤¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤¿ºÇ¶á¤ÎÏÀʸ¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢º´¡¹ÌÚ°ìÉס־ڵò¤Î¡Ø´ØÏ¢À¡Ù¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï¡ØµöÍÆÀ¡Ù¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡½¡½ºÛȽ°÷À©Å٤β¼¤Ç¤Î¾ÚµòÄ´¤Ù¤òǰƬ¤Ë¡×¡Ø¸¶ÅÄÔ¢ÃËȽ»öÂà´±µÇ°ÏÀʸ½¸¡§¿·¤·¤¤»þÂå¤Î·º»öºÛȽ¡Ù¡ÊȽÎ㥿¥¤¥à¥º¼Ò2010¡Ë¡¢183Êǰʲ¼¤ò»²¾È¡£
[8] McCormick, supra note 6, 313.
[9] Id., 311¡¥
[10] Id., 316.
[11] Id.
[12] Id.
[13] Rex v. Smith, 11 Cr. App. R. 229, 84 L.J.K.B 2153 (1915).¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤ÎµÏ¿¤òÆüËܸì¤ÇÆɤळ¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£¡Ø¼ÂÏ¿ºÛȽ¥·¥ê¡¼¥ºËÅ»¦¡§¥¸¥ç¡¼¥¸¡¦¥¸¥ç¥»¥Õ¡¦¥¹¥ß¥¹»ö·ï¡Ù¡Ê²¢Ê¸¼Ò1981¡Ë¡£
[14] McCormick, supra note 6, 315.
[15] Id., 312-313.
[16] ¡Ö¡Ê1¡ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¡¡Èï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¤Î´ØÏ¢¤¹¤ëÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤Î¾Úµò¤ÇÈï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¤¬¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¡¢Ëô¤Ï¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬¤½¤ì¤ËÈ¿Çý¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¡¢¼ã¤·¤¯¤Ï¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤È¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¼Ô¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤¬Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¿½ÀÁ¤µ¤ì¤«¤Äµ¬Â§404(a)(2)¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ëƱ¼ï¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¡×¡£µ¬Â§404(a)(2)¤Ï¤³¤¦µ¬Äꤹ¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö¡Ê2¡ËÈï³²¼Ô¤È¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¼Ô¤ÎÀ³Ê¡¡ÈȺáÈï³²¼Ô¤È¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¼Ô¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤ÇÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¡¢Ëô¤Ï¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬¤½¤ì¤ËÈ¿Çý¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¡¢¼ã¤·¤¯¤Ï¡¢»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤¬¤Ï¤¸¤á¤Ë¹¶·â¤·¤¿¤È¤Î¾Úµò¤ËÈ¿Çý¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ë¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤È¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¼Ô¤¬²¹Ï¤ÊÀ³Ê¤À¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¡×¡£
[17] McCormick, supra note 6, 318.
[18] Id., 318-319.
[19] Id., 317.
[20] Id., 310.
[21] Id., 315¡Ê¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡË.
[22] Id.
[23] »³²¬°ì¿®¡ÖÊü²ÐÈȺá¤Î·ÁÂ֤˴ؤ¹¤ë½ôÆÃÀ¡§£±Ã±°ìÈȹԷ²¤ÈϢ³ÈȹԷ²¤ÎÈæ³Ó¡×²Ê³Ø·Ù»¡¸¦µæ½êÊó¹ð31-4-95¡Ê1978¡Ë¡¢99ÊÇ¡£
[24] ¾åÌî¸ü¡ØÅÔ»Ô·¿Êü²ÐÈȺ᡽¡½Êü²ÐÈȺῴÍýʬÀÏÆþÌç¡Ù¡ÊΩ²Ö½ñ˼1998¡Ë¡¢29ÊÇ¡£
[25] Åìµþ¾ÃËÉģĴºº²Ý¡Ö¶áǯÅìµþ¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëÊü²Ð²ÐºÒ¤Î¼Â¾ð¡×²ÐºÒ35-5-1¡Ê1985¡Ë¡¢5ÊÇ¡£
[26] »³²¬¡¢Á°Ãí23¡¢100ÊÇ¡£
[27] ¾åÌÁ°Ãí24¡¢30ÊÇ¡£
[28] ²£ÉͻԾÃËɶɡÖÊü²Ð²ÐºÒËÉ»ßÂкö¡½¡½¼ÂÂ֤Ⱥ£¸å¤Î»Üºö¡×²ÐºÒ49-4-49¡Ê1999¡Ë¡¢52ÊÇ¡£
[29] ¾åÌÁ°Ãí24¡¢30ÊÇ¡£
[30] »³²¬°ì¿®¡ÖϢ³Êü²Ð¤ÎÈȺá³Ø¡×·Ù»¡³ØÏÀ½¸33-12-88¡Ê1980¡Ë¡¢94~99ÊÇ¡£
[31] ƱÁ°¡¢94ÊÇ¡£
[32] ƱÁ°¡£
[33] ¾åÌÁ°Ãí24¡¢33ÊÇ¡£
£³¡¡ÈÈ¿ÍÀǧÄê¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¾ºá¾Úµò¤¬µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¾ò·ï
¤µ¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ì¤Ç¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Î²ÝÂ꡽¡½Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤ëÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤ÎǧÄ꡽¡½¤òÏÀ¤¸¤ë½àÈ÷¤¬¤Ç¤¤¿¡£ËÜÂê¤ËÆþ¤í¤¦¡£¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤½¤·¤ÆϢˮ¾Úµòµ¬Â§¤Ï¡¢¡ÖƱ°ìÀ¡×(identity)¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤ÁÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬µ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿ÈȺá¤ÎÈȿͤǤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¡ÊÈÈ¿ÍÀ¡Ë¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¾ºá¾Úµò¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë(FRE404(b))¡£¤³¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤ò»Ù¤¨¤ë¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¡Ê¿äǧ²áÄø¡Ë¤Ï²¿¤À¤í¤¦¤«¡£Â¾ºá¤¬µ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿ÈȺá¤È¡ÖÎà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎÊÀ³²¤Ï²¿°ì¤Ä²ò¾Ã¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¤à¤·¤í¤½¤ì¤ÏÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤Î¿äǧ²áÄø¤òŵ·¿Åª¤Ë¼¨¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£Àè¤Ë¿Þ¼¨¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¡Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Aºá¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¤Ï¡¢¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Aºá¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÈȺá¤òÈȤ¹À³Ê·¹¸þ¤ò¤â¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤ò΢ÉÕ¤±¤ë¡¢¤·¤¬¤¿¤Ã¤Æ¡¢£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏAºá¤Ë»÷¤¿¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤òÈȤ·¤¿²ÄǽÀ¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¿äǧ²áÄø¤Ï¡¢Aºá¤È¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤¬Îà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ½é¤á¤ÆÀ®¤êΩ¤Ä¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Îà»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ì¤Ð¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Û¤É¶¯¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Î㤨¤Ð¡¢»¦¿Í¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎºÛȽ¤Ç¡¢Èà¤Îƻϩ¸òÄÌË¡°ãÈ¿¤äÀàÅð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤¬Äó½Ð¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆºÛȽ°÷¤¬Èï¹ð¿Í¤ËÉÔ¸øÀµ¤ÊͽÃÇÊ諤ò»ý¤Ä¿´ÇۤϤ¢¤Þ¤ê¤Ê¤¤¡£Îà»÷¤ÎÈȺá¤Ç¤¢¤ë»¦¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎÊý¤¬¤Ï¤ë¤«¤Ë¶¯¤¤Í½ÃÇÊ諤òºÛȽ°÷¤ËÍ¿¤¨¡¢¸øÀµ¤Ê¾Úµòɾ²Á¤òº¤Æñ¤Ë¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤ÎŨ°Õ¤òÊú¤«¤»¤ë´í¸±À¤ò»ý¤Ä¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢ÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤¿¤á¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤ò»Ù¤¨¤ë¿äǧ²áÄø¤Ï¡¢Â¾ºá¤È¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤È¤Î´Ö¤Î¡ÖÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤ÏÊ̤ΤȤ³¤í¤Ëµá¤á¤é¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤Ï¾ºá¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤ëÈÈ¿ÍÀǧÄê¤Î¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤ò¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÀâÌÀ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
¡Ö¤½¤ÎÊýË¡¤¬¤Û¤È¤ó¤ÉƱ°ì(nearly identical)¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤áÀµ¤Ë¤½¤ì¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¼ê»Å»ö(handiwork)¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¼±Ê̤Ǥ¤ë(earmark)¤è¤¦¤Ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȤ·¤¿Ê̤κá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»¦¿Í¡¢¶¯Åð¤ä¥ì¥¤¥×¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤ÊƱ¼ï¤ÎÈȺ᤬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤ÏÁ´¤¯Â¤ê¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤ÎÈȺá¤Î¥Ñ¥¿¡¼¥ó¤äÆÃħ¤¬¡¢¤È¤Æ¤â°Û¾ï¤ÇºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¡¢½ð̾(signature)¤Ë¤âÅù¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡×[21]¡£
¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤Ï¤½¤ÎÎã¤È¤·¤ÆÁ°½Ð¤Î¡ÖÍáÁå¤Î²Ö²Ç¡×»ö·ï¤òµó¤²¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¥¸¥ç¡¼¥¸¡¦¥¸¥ç¥»¥Õ¡¦¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Ï¡¢¥Ù¥Ã¥·¡¼¡¦¥Þ¥ó¥Ç¥£¤òÈà¤é¤Î¥Þ¥ó¥·¥ç¥ó¤ÎÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤µ¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»¦¿Í¤Îºá¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¡£Ë´¤¯¤Ê¤ëÁ°¤Ë2¿Í¤Ï·ëº§¼°¤òµó¤²¡¢¥Þ¥ó¥Ç¥£¤ÏÁ´ºâ»º¤ò¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Ë°ä£¤¹¤ë»Ý¤Î°ä¸À½ñ¤Ë½ð̾¤·¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£¸øȽ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢¥¹¥ß¥¹¤¬Â¾¤Ë¿ô̾¤Î½÷À¤È·ëº§¼°¤òµó¤²¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤Î½÷À¤¬¤ß¤ÊÁ´ºâ»º¤ò¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Ë°ä¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦°ä¸À½ñ¤Ë½ð̾¤·¤¿¸å¤ËÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤·¤¿¡¢¤È¤¤¤¦¾Úµò¤ò¿½ÀÁ¤·¤¿¡£¸øȽºÛȽ´±¤Ï¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤òµöÍƤ·¤Æ¡¢¥¹¥ß¥¹¤òͺá¤È¤·¤Æ»à·º¤ò¸À¤¤ÅϤ·¤¿¡£·º»ö¾åÁʺÛȽ½ê¤â¤³¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤òǧ¤á¤ÆͺáȽ·è¤ò¾µÇ§¤·¤¿[22]¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢Â¾ºá¤ÎÆâÍƤ¬¶Ë¤á¤ÆÆðۤǰ۾ï¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤Î´í¸±À¤òµ¤¤Ë³Ý¤±¤ëɬÍפ¬¤Ê¤¤¤Û¤É¤Ë¡¢¼±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¹â¤¤¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡¢¤³¤ÎÎã³°¤¬Å¬ÍѤǤ¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£´¡¡ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ
ËÜ·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¤Ï¤É¤¦¤«¡£¸¶È½·è¤ÏO»á¤Î11·ï¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤Î¤¦¤Á10·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡Ö¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤¬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢¤·¤«¤â¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¡Ö¸ÇÃå¡×¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ëÅÀ¤¬¡ÖÆÃħŪ¡×¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢²°Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤ÆÃå²Ð¤¹¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦Êü²Ð¤Î¼ê¸ý¤Ï¡¢¹¤¯Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤³¤Î¼ê¸ý¤ÏÊü²ÐÈȤÎƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤Û¤É¤Ë¸ÄÀŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£
²Ê³Ø·Ù»¡¸¦µæ½ê¤Î»³²¬°ì¿®¤¬¾¼ÏÂ50ǯÂå½éƬ¤Î1ǯ´Ö¤ËȯÀ¸¤·¤¿Á´¹ñ¤ÎÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤òÂоݤ˹Ԥ俸¦µæ¤Ë¤è¤ë¤È¡¢Á´1691·ï¤Î¤¦¤Á963·ï¡Ê56.9%¡Ë¤¬²°Æâ¤òÊü²ÐÅÀ¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡£Ã±°ìÈȹԷ²¡Ê861·ï¡Ë¤Ç¤Ï69.8%¡¢Ï¢Â³ÈȹԷ²¡Ê830·ï¡Ë¤Ç¤Ï43.6%¤Î¥±¡¼¥¹¤Ç²°Æâ¤ÇÊü²Ð¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[23]¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢¿ÀÆàÀ·Ù²Ê³ØÁܺº¸¦µæ½ê¿´Íý²ÝĹ¤Î¾åÌî¸ü¤¬¾¼ÏÂ46ǯ¤«¤é55ǯ¤Þ¤Ç¤Î10ǯ´Ö¤Ë¿ÀÆàÀÆâ¤ÇΩ·ï¤µ¤ì¤¿379Îã¤ÎÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¸¦µæ¤Ë¤è¤ë¤È¡¢·úʪÊü²Ð»ö·ï309·ï¡½¡½Ã±°ìÊü²Ð»ö·ï56·ï¡¢Ï¢Â³Êü²Ð»ö·ï253·ï¡ÊÈȿͤÏ51¿Í¡Ë¡½¡½¤Î¤¦¤Á¡¢ÅÀ²Ð¾ì½ê¤¬²°Æâ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤â¤Î¤¬Ã±°ìÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Ç¤Ï43·ï¡Ê76.8%¡Ë¡¢Ï¢Â³Êü²Ð»ö·ï¤Ç¤Ï104·ï¡Ê41.1%¡Ë¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿[24]¡£¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢Åìµþ¾ÃËÉÄ£¤¬¾¼ÏÂ55ǯ¤«¤é57ǯ¤Þ¤Ç¤Î3ǯ´Ö¤ÎÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¹Ô¤Ã¤¿Ä´ºº·ë²Ì¤Ç¤â¡¢Êü²Ð¾ì½ê¤Ï¡Ö·úʪÆâÉô¡×¤¬ºÇ¤â¿¤¤¡£Á´4,802·ï¤ÎÌóȾ¿ô2,044·ï¤¬·úʪÆâÉô¤òÊü²Ð¾ì½ê¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢2°Ì¤Î¡Ö³°ÊÉ¡¢¸®²¼Åù¡×742·ï¤òÂ礤¯°ú¤Î¥¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë[25]¡£
¤Ä¤®¤Ë¡¢ÅôÌý¤Î»ÈÍѤâ·è¤·¤ÆÄÁ¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£»³²¬¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ç¤ÏÌýÎà¤Î»ÈÍѤÏñ°ìÈȹԷ²¤Ç25.0%¡¢Ï¢Â³ÈȹԷ²¤Ç15.8%¤Ç¤¢¤ë[26]¡£¾åÌî¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ç¤ÏÁ´379·ï¤Î¤¦¤ÁÌýÎà¤ò»ÈÍѤ·¤¿Îã¤Ï57·ï¡Ê15%¡Ë¤Ç¤¢¤ë[27]¡£²£ÉͻԾÃËɶɤ¬¹Ô¤Ã¤¿²£ÉÍ»ÔÆâ¤Ç¾¼ÏÂ63ǯ¤«¤éÊ¿À®9ǯ¤Þ¤Ç¤Î10ǯ´Ö¤ËȯÀ¸¤·¤¿Êü²Ð»ö·ï¤ÎÄ´ºº¤Ë¤è¤ë¤È¡¢·úʪÊü²Ð»ö·ï¡Ê1258·ï¡Ë¤Î13.5¡ó¡Ê170·ï¡Ë¤¬¡Ö¥¬¥½¥ê¥ó¡¦ÅôÌý¡×¤òÃå²Ðʪ¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[28]¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢ÌýÎà¤ÎÆþ¼êÊýË¡¤ò¤ß¤ë¤È¡¢¾åÌî¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ç¤Ï34·ï¡Ê64.9%¡Ë¤Ç¡Ö¸½¾ìËô¤Ï¸½¾ìÉÕ¶á¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡×ÌýÎब»ÈÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[29]¡£
Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤¬¡ÖÆÃħŪ¡×¤Èɾ¤¹¤ëO»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤ÎÂÖÍͤϡ¢·è¤·¤ÆÄÁ¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤à¤·¤íÊü²ÐÈȤδ֤Ǥϥݥԥå¥é¡¼¤Ï¼ê¸ý¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£O»á°Ê³°¤ÎÊü²ÐÈȤο¤¯¤¬¤½¤ì¤ÈƱ¤¸ÊýË¡¤ÇÊü²Ð¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Î¡Ö¼êÃÊÊýË¡¡×¤òËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̤λØɸ¤È¤·¤ÆÍѤ¤¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¤Ê¤ª¡¢¸¶È½·è¤ÏƱ¤¸ÊýË¡¤Ë¤è¤ëÊü²Ð¤¬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¤¿¤¿¤á¤Ë¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤Ê¤É¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡Ê6ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¡Ö¸ÇÃå²½¡×¤Î°ÕÌ£¤ÏÎɤ¯¤ï¤«¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£O»á¤¬Êü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¤¦¤Á¤Ë¾ò·ïÈ¿¼Í¤È¤·¤Æ¥Ñ¥Ö¥í¥Õ¤Î¸¤¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÊü²Ð¤ò¹Ô¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¾Úµò¤Ï¤É¤³¤Ë¤â¤Ê¤¤¡£»³²¬°ì¿®¤ä¾åÌî¸ü¤¬»ØŦ¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Êü²ÐÈȤˤϡÖñ°ìÈȹԷ²¡×¤È¡ÖϢ³ÈȹԷ²¡×¤È¤¬¤¢¤ê¡¢Î¾¼Ô¤ÎÈȹԷÁÂ֤ˤÏÁê°ã¤¬¤¢¤ë¡£¡ÖϢ³ÈȹԷ²¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢Íפ¹¤ë¤Ëû´ü´Ö¤ËƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤è¤ëÊü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¿Í¡¹¤Î¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì°Ê¾å¤Ç¤â¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê²¼¤Ç¤â¤Ê¤¤¡£Ï¢Â³ÈȹԷ²¤ÎÊü²ÐÈȤϤߤÊƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤Ç¤ÎÊü²Ð¤òÊ£¿ô²ó·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢ÈȹԤ´¤È¤Ë¼ê¸ý¤òÊѤ¨¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤³¤ì¤ò¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Î¸ÇÃå²½¡×¤Ê¤É¤È¤¤¤Ã¤Æ²¿¤«ÆÃÊ̤ʰÕÌ£¤¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ëм¤á¤«¤¹¤Î¤ÏÀ¿¼Â¤ÊÂÖÅ٤ǤϤʤ¤¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢Æ±¤¸¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹·ÁÂÖ¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Ï¡¢O»á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤À¤±¤Ë¸Â¤é¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤ì¤òª¤¨¤Æ¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Î¸ÇÃå²½¡×¤Ê¤É¤È¶Ä¡¹¤·¤¤¥é¥Ù¥ë¤òŽ¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤À¤«¤é¤½¤ì¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈȹÔÂÖÍͤ¬¡Ö¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¡×¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ï¡¢Á´¤¯²Ê³ØŪ¤Êº¬µò¤Î¤Ê¤¤²±Â¬¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¼¡¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢O»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤Ï¡¢¤¤¤º¤ì¤âÀàÅð¤ÎÌÜŪ¤ò㤷¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ÎʢΩ¤Á¤ò²ò¾Ã¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢¤³¤Î¡ÖÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡×¤ÎÅÀ¤ÇÆÃħŪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¿ô¤¢¤ëÆ°µ¡¤Î¤¦¤ÁÀàÅ𤬤¦¤Þ¤¯¤¤¤«¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ÎÉÔËþ¤òȯ»¶¤¹¤ë¡Ê¡Ö¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¡×¡Ë¤È¤¤¤¦Æ°µ¡¤Ï¡ÖÆÃħŪ¡×¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢ÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤ÎǧÄê¤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¸¶È½·è¤¬»ØŦ¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¤ÇÊü²Ð¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï·è¤·¤ÆÄÁ¤·¤¤¤³¤È¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¤ÏÊü²Ð¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤ÆºÇ¤â°ìÈÌŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»³²¬°ì¿®¤Ï¡¢Ï¢Â³Êü²ÐÈȤÎÆ°µ¡¤ò¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¡Ö²Ð¤Î´î¤Ó¡×¡Ö±åº¨¡×¡Ö±Ñͺ»Ö¸þ¡×¡Ö¤½¤Î¾¡×¤Î5¤Ä¤ËʬÎष¤¿[30]¡£Ä´ººÂоݤȤʤä¿Á´81·ï¤Î¤¦¤Á60.5%¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤ë49·ï¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤¬¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¤Ç¤¢¤ë[31]¡£ÉÔËþ¤ÎÃæ¤Ë¤Ï¿Æ²¤È¤ÎíÂíà¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿Í´Ö´Ø·¸¤Ë¤è¤ë¤â¤Î¤¬Â¿¤¤¤¬¡¢Â¾¤ÎÈȺá¤ò°Õ¿Þ¤·¤¿¤¬À®¸ù¤·¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤«¤é¡ÖÍ×µáÁ˻ߤξõÂ֡פȤʤêÊü²Ð¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦Îã¤â¤¢¤ë¡£»³²¬¤Ï¡ÖÈæ³ÓŪñ½ã¤ÊÎã¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¡ÖÀàÅð¤òÌÜŪ¤È¤·¤Æ¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿¤¬Ìܻؤ·¤¿¸½¶â¤ò¸«½Ð¤¹¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿ÉÔËþ¤«¤é¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿²È²°Æâ¤ÇÊü²Ð¤·¤¿Î㤬¤¢¤ë¡×¤ÈÊó¹ð¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë[32]¡£¾åÌî¸ü¤Î¸¦µæ¤Ç¤â¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¤ÏºÇ¤â¥Ý¥Ô¥å¥é¡¼¤ÊÆ°µ¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¾åÌî¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡¢Ã±°ìÊü²Ð»ö·ï¤Î29.8%¡¢Ï¢Â³Êü²Ð»ö·ï¤Î64.9%¤¬¡ÖÉÔËþ¤Îȯ»¶¡×¤òÆ°µ¡¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Æ°µ¡¤ÎÂè1°Ì¤Ë¥é¥ó¥¯¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë[33]¡£Êü²ÐÈȤΤʤ«¤Ë¤ÏO»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤ÊÆ°µ¡¡½¡½¸¶È½·è¤Îɽ¸½¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¡½¡½¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¤¹¤ë¿Í¤¬°ìÄê¿ô¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤âÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̤λØɸ¤È¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¤³¤³¤Ç¤â¡Ö¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Î¸ÇÃå²½¡×¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£Êü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤·¤¿·ë²Ì¡ÖÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¡Ê6ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ë³¤±¤Æ¸¶È½·è¤Ï¸À¤¦¡£
¡Ö¾Êý¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÈÀÜÃ夷¤¿»þ´ÖÂӤˡ¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤ÎÈȹԾì½ê¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤ÆÀàÅð¤ò¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÏÁ褤¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Æ±ÀàÅð¤ÎÈï³²ÉʤÏ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤È¥«¥Ã¥×ÌÍ1¸Ä¤Ë¤È¤É¤Þ¤Ã¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤òËþ¤µ¤»¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¤Ï¤¦¤«¤¬¤ï¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤«¤é¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ÎÊ¢¤¤¤»¤ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ËµÚ¤ó¤À²ÄǽÀ¤¬¹Í¤¨¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Ï¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢Îà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡×¡Ê6ÊÇ¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£
¤³¤ÎÏÀ»Ý¤Î¤Ê¤«¤Ç¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÏÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̤λØɸ¤È¤·¤Æ»È¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤¬ÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤ÏÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤Ø¤È¤¤¤¦¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢º£²ó¤â¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸½¤ì¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤ÈÏÀ¤¸¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤ì¤³¤½¤Þ¤µ¤Ë¡¢Ë¡¤¬¶Ø»ß¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÍøÍѤ˾¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£Æ±°ìÀ¼±Ê̤Τ¿¤á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎÍøÍѤϡ¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤¦¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤¬¶Ë¤á¤ÆÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¡½¡½¡Ö¤È¤Æ¤â°Û¾ï¤ÇºÝΩ¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¡¢½ð̾(signature)¤Ë¤âÅù¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¡×¡Ê¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¡Ë¡½¡½¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¿¤á¡¢¤½¤ÎÆÃħ¡½¡½Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î½ð̾¡½¡½¤ò·ó¤ÍÈ÷¤¨¤¿ËÜ·ï¤âÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȹԤ˰㤤¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¸¶È½·è¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤òµöÍƤ¹¤ë¾ò·ï¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤ËÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡¢ÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ì¤Ð¤ê¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¸À¤¦¡Ê8ÊÇ¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤Î´ð½à¤Ï´Ë¤ä¤«¤¹¤®¤ë¡£¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦ÄøÅ٤Ǥϡ¢¸¶È½·è¼«¿È¤¬¸í¤ê¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦´í¸±À¤¬Í¾¤ê¤Ë¤âÂ礤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£³Î¤«¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤¬¸À¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î¤¦¤Á¡¢¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¹Ô¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¡Ö¤¢¤ëÄøÅÙ¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¡Ê7ÊǡˤÀ¤í¤¦¤·¡¢¤½¤Îµï¼¼Æâ¤ÇÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤ÆÊü²Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡Ö¤è¤ê°ìÁظÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡×¡ÊƱÁ°¡Ë¤À¤í¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Àè¤Ë»ØŦ¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊü²ÐÈȤϡ½¡½¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡½¡½¾¯¤Ê¤«¤é¤ºÂ¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï·ì±Õ·¿¤Ë»÷¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡££Â·¿¤Î·ì±Õ·¿¤Î¿Íʪ¤Ï¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢·ì±Õ·¿´ÕÄê¤Ë¤ÏÈȿͼ±Ê̤Τ¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï·è¤·¤Æ·ì±Õ·¿¤ÈƱ¤¸¤è¤¦¤Ë¤Ï°·¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Á°²Ê¤Ï¡¢·ì±Õ·¿¤È°ã¤Ã¤Æ¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤ò»ý¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤ÏÆÃħŪ¤ÊÁ°²Ê¤¬¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢º£ÅÙ¤â¤ä¤Ã¤¿¤Ë°ã¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿´¾Ú·ÁÀ®¡½¡½Í½ÃÇ¡¢Êи«¡½¡½¤Î´í¸±¤òȼ¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£·ì±Õ·¿¤Ë¤Ï¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊÀ³²¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤À¤«¤éÁ°²Ê¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë´í¸±À¤ò¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ëο²ï¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¿Âç¤Ê¼±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤Ê¤¤¸Â¤ê¡¢ºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤¬ºÎÍѤ·¤¿µöÍÆÀ¤Î´ð½à¤Ï´Ë¤ä¤«¤¹¤®¤ë¡£
Á°½Ò¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢ÌäÂê¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤¿Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤¬¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢ÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤ÎǧÄê¡ÊƱ°ìÀ¼±Ê̡ˤΤ¿¤á¤Ë»ÈÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤ËÅö¤Æ¤Ï¤Þ¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤â¤¦¤¤¤Á¤ÉˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¿³ºº¡Ê¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¡Ë¤ò¹Ô¤ï¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎȽÃǤˤª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢Áʾ٤θ½¾ì¤ËľÀܿȤò¤ª¤¯»ö¼Â¿³ºÛȽ´±¤ÎȽÃǤ¬Âº½Å¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç¸¡Æ¤¤·¤¿¤È¤³¤í¤«¤é¤âÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ê¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢O»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤òµÑ²¼¤·¤¿1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÃǤϡ¢Â翳±¡°ÊÍè¤ÎºÇ½ª¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÎã¤È¡¢¤½¤Î´ðÁäȤʤ俱ÑÊƾڵòË¡¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤ËÃé¼Â¤Ë½¾¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¶Ë¤á¤ÆÀµ¤·¤¤¡£¤½¤ì¤Ð¤«¤ê¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ÎȽÃǤòƳ¤¯¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤ÈÊÛ¸î¿Í¤ËÊ¿Åù¤Ë°Õ¸«Äó½Ð¤Îµ¡²ñ¤òÍ¿¤¨¡ÊµÏ¿28¡Ë¡¢ÁÐÊý¤«¤é¾ÜºÙ¤Ê½ñÌ̤ˤè¤ë°Õ¸«¤Î³«ÄĤò¼õ¤±¤Æ¤«¤é¡ÊµÏ¿159~168ÊÇ¡Ë¡¢ºÇ½ªÅª¤ÊȽÃǤò¹Ô¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤½¤ÎȽÃǤβáÄø¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ×ó°ÕŪ¤ÊÍ×ÁǤϲ¿¤â¤Ê¤¤¤·¡¢¸í²ò¤ä»×¤¤¹þ¤ß¤È»×¤ï¤ì¤ëÍ×ÁǤâÁ´¤¯¤Ê¤¤¡£1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¿³ºº¤Î²áÄø¤Ë¤âÆâÍƤˤâºÛÎ̸¢¤ÎÍôÍѤȸƤ٤ë¤â¤Î¤Ï²¿¤â¤Ê¤¤¡£¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤³¤Î°ÕÌ£¤Ç¤â°ì¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÃǤÏŬˡ¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤³¤ì¤ò°ãË¡¤ÈÃǤ¸¤¿¸¶È½·è¤Ï¸í¤ê¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£µ¡¡·ëÏÀ
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢100ǯ¶á¤¯¼é¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¿¤ï¤¬¹ñºÇ½ª¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÎã¤Îή¤ì¤«¤é³°¤ì¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Á°²Ê¤ÏÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤Îŵ·¿¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤ò¸íƳ¤¹¤ë´í¸±¤ò»ý¤Ä¤Î¤Ç¡¢¾Úµò¤«¤éÇÓ½ü¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤ÎÎã³°¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÈÈ¿ÍÀǧÄê¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î´í¸±¤òο²ï¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Î¼±Ê̾ڵò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î²ÁÃͤ¬¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï¤½¤ÎÈȿͤμê»Å»ö¤È¤·¤Æʶ¤¦Êý¤Ê¤¹ï°õ¤òÇØÉé¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤¬¿ÍÎà¤ÎÎò»ËŪ·Ð¸³¤Ëº¬º¹¤·¤¿À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤¬µá¤á¤ë¤È¤³¤í¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤¬¤¤¤¦¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦´ð½à¤Ï¡¢¤¢¤Þ¤ê¤Ë¤â´Ë¤ä¤«¤Ë²á¤®¤ë¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤òÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ¹¤ë´í¸±¤òÍÆǧ¤·¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤Î¤¢¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ëº¹Ê̤˾¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£Á°²Ê¤Î¤¢¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¤½¤¦¤Ç¤Ê¤¤Èï¹ð¿Í¤è¤ê¤âÁÊ°ø¤Ë´Ø¤·¤Æ¾¯¤Ê¤¤¾Úµò¤Ç¤âͺá¤È¤Ê¤ë´í¸±À¤òÉ餦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ê¤ë¤«¤é¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤Ï¤Þ¤µ¤·¤¯¡¢¸øÊ¿¤ÊºÛȽ½ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÀµ¤Ê¿³Íý¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¸¢Íø¤òÇíÃ¥¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ë¾¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£
¡Ú°Ê²¼¾Êά¡Û
Ãí
[1]¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢1ÅٵѲ¼¤µ¤ì¤¿È½·èÆ¥Ëܤȶ¡½ÒÄ´½ñ¤Î°ìÉô¡Ê²µ38¡¤39¡Ë¤òºÆÅÙƱ¤¸Î©¾Ú¼ñ»Ý¤Ç¾ÚµòÀÁµá¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÏºÆÅٵѲ¼¤·¤¿¡ÊµÏ¿147ÊÇ¡Ë¡£
[2] Î㤨¤Ð¡¢²ò¸Û¤µ¤ì¤¿ÈïÍѼԤˤè¤ë¸ÛÍÑÃæ¤Î»ö¼Â¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Ú¸À¤Î¸úÎϤòÈÝÄꤷ¤¿ÂçȽÌÀ29¡¦4¡¦23·ºÏ¿2¡¾4¡¾66¡¢Èó¸ø³«Ë¡Äî¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¶¡½Ò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤òÈÝÄꤷ¤¿ÂçȽÌÀ39¡¦2¡¦22·ºÏ¿12¡¾2¡¾248¤Ê¤É¡¢Ëçµó¤Ë¤¤¤È¤Þ¤¬¤Ê¤¤¡£
[3] ¡ÖºÛȽĹ¤Ï¡¢Áʾٴط¸¿Í¤Î¤¹¤ë¿ÒÌäËô¤ÏÄĽҤ¬´û¤Ë¤·¤¿¿ÒÌä¼ã¤·¤¯¤ÏÄĽҤȽÅÊ£¤¹¤ë¤È¤¡¢Ëô¤Ï»ö·ï¤Ë´Ø·¸¤Î¤Ê¤¤»ö¹à¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤ë¤È¤¤½¤Î¾ÁêÅö¤Ç¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤Ï¡¢Áʾٴط¸¿Í¤ÎËܼÁŪ¤Ê¸¢Íø¤ò³²¤·¤Ê¤¤¸Â¤ê¡¢¤³¤ì¤òÀ©¸Â¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£Áʾٴط¸¿Í¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¶¡½Ò¤òµá¤á¤ë¹Ô°Ù¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤âƱÍͤǤ¢¤ë¡£¡×
[4] ¹¾²ÈµÁÃË¡Ø·º»ö¾ÚµòË¡¤Î´ðÁÃÍýÏÀ¡Ê²þÄûÈÇ¡Ë¡Ù¡ÊÍÈå³Õ1952¡Ë¡¢238ÊÇ¡¢ÀÄÌڱѸÞϺ¡Ö¾ÚµòǽÎϤÎÀ©¸Â¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤½¤Î¾¤ÎÌäÂê¡×ÃÄÆ£½Å¸÷ÊÔ¡ØˡΧ¼Â̳¹ÖºÂ·º»öÊÔ¡ÊÂè9´¬¡Ë¡Ù¡ÊÍÈå³Õ1956¡Ë¡¢1961¡¢1990ÊÇ¡£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÎã¤â¡ÖÈȹԤξõ¶·Åù¤ò»£±Æ¤·¤¿¤¤¤ï¤æ¤ë¸½¾ì¼Ì¿¿¤Ï¡¢È󶡽Ҿڵò¤Ë°¤·¡¢Åö³º¼Ì¿¿¼«ÂÎËô¤Ï¤½¤Î¾¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤ê»ö·ï¤È¤Î´ØÏ¢À¤òǧ¤á¤¦¤ë¸Â¤ê¾ÚµòǽÎϤò¶ñÈ÷¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¡Î¤ë¡Ï¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¡¢´ØÏ¢À¤ò¾ÚµòǽÎϤÎÍ×·ï¤È¹Í¤¨¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡ÊºÇ2¾®·è¾¼59¡¦12¡¦21·º½¸38-12-3071¡¢3074Êǡο·½ÉÁû¾ñ»ö·ï¡Ï¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£
[5] ºÇ¹âºÛÄ´ºº´±¤Ï¡¢¾¼ÏÂ41ǯ·èÄ꤬±ÑÊƾڵòË¡¤ÎÍýÏÀ¤òǧ¤á¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡ÊË¡Áâ²ñÊԡغǹâºÛȽ½êȽÎã²òÀâ·º»öÊÔ¾¼ÏÂ41ǯÅÙ¡Ù214-215ÊÇ¡ÎÌÊ°ú¿ÂϺ¡Ï¡Ë¡£
[6] McCormick, On Evidence, 6th ed (Thomson/West, 2006), 311.
[7] ˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¹ÍθÍ×ÁǤÏϢˮ¾Úµòµ¬Â§403¤ËÄê¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö¤¿¤È¤¨´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¡¢ÉÔ¸øÀµ¤ÊͽÃÇÊи«¡¢ÁèÅÀ¤Îº®Í𡢤ޤ¿¤ÏÇ濳¤ò¸íƳ¤¹¤ë´í¸±¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¼ã¤·¤¯¤Ï¡¢ÉÔÅö¤ÊÃÙÂÚ¡¢»þ´Ö¤ÎϲÈñ¡¢¤Þ¤¿¤Ï½ÅʣŪ¤Ê¾Úµò¤ÎÉÔɬÍפÊÄó½Ð¤ÎÊÀ³²¤Ø¤Î¹Íθ¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ëο²ï¤µ¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤òÇÓ½ü¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡£¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤âˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ÎȽÃǤ¬ÍѤ¤¤é¤ì¤ë¤Ù¤¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤¿ºÇ¶á¤ÎÏÀʸ¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢º´¡¹ÌÚ°ìÉס־ڵò¤Î¡Ø´ØÏ¢À¡Ù¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï¡ØµöÍÆÀ¡Ù¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡½¡½ºÛȽ°÷À©Å٤β¼¤Ç¤Î¾ÚµòÄ´¤Ù¤òǰƬ¤Ë¡×¡Ø¸¶ÅÄÔ¢ÃËȽ»öÂà´±µÇ°ÏÀʸ½¸¡§¿·¤·¤¤»þÂå¤Î·º»öºÛȽ¡Ù¡ÊȽÎ㥿¥¤¥à¥º¼Ò2010¡Ë¡¢183Êǰʲ¼¤ò»²¾È¡£
[8] McCormick, supra note 6, 313.
[9] Id., 311¡¥
[10] Id., 316.
[11] Id.
[12] Id.
[13] Rex v. Smith, 11 Cr. App. R. 229, 84 L.J.K.B 2153 (1915).¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤ÎµÏ¿¤òÆüËܸì¤ÇÆɤळ¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£¡Ø¼ÂÏ¿ºÛȽ¥·¥ê¡¼¥ºËÅ»¦¡§¥¸¥ç¡¼¥¸¡¦¥¸¥ç¥»¥Õ¡¦¥¹¥ß¥¹»ö·ï¡Ù¡Ê²¢Ê¸¼Ò1981¡Ë¡£
[14] McCormick, supra note 6, 315.
[15] Id., 312-313.
[16] ¡Ö¡Ê1¡ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¡¡Èï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¤Î´ØÏ¢¤¹¤ëÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤Î¾Úµò¤ÇÈï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¤¬¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¡¢Ëô¤Ï¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬¤½¤ì¤ËÈ¿Çý¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¡¢¼ã¤·¤¯¤Ï¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤È¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¼Ô¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤¬Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¿½ÀÁ¤µ¤ì¤«¤Äµ¬Â§404(a)(2)¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ëƱ¼ï¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¡×¡£µ¬Â§404(a)(2)¤Ï¤³¤¦µ¬Äꤹ¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö¡Ê2¡ËÈï³²¼Ô¤È¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¼Ô¤ÎÀ³Ê¡¡ÈȺáÈï³²¼Ô¤È¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¼Ô¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤ÇÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¡¢Ëô¤Ï¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬¤½¤ì¤ËÈ¿Çý¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¡¢¼ã¤·¤¯¤Ï¡¢»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤¬¤Ï¤¸¤á¤Ë¹¶·â¤·¤¿¤È¤Î¾Úµò¤ËÈ¿Çý¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤¬¿½ÀÁ¤¹¤ë¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤È¼çÄ¥¤µ¤ì¤ë¼Ô¤¬²¹Ï¤ÊÀ³Ê¤À¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¡×¡£
[17] McCormick, supra note 6, 318.
[18] Id., 318-319.
[19] Id., 317.
[20] Id., 310.
[21] Id., 315¡Ê¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡË.
[22] Id.
[23] »³²¬°ì¿®¡ÖÊü²ÐÈȺá¤Î·ÁÂ֤˴ؤ¹¤ë½ôÆÃÀ¡§£±Ã±°ìÈȹԷ²¤ÈϢ³ÈȹԷ²¤ÎÈæ³Ó¡×²Ê³Ø·Ù»¡¸¦µæ½êÊó¹ð31-4-95¡Ê1978¡Ë¡¢99ÊÇ¡£
[24] ¾åÌî¸ü¡ØÅÔ»Ô·¿Êü²ÐÈȺ᡽¡½Êü²ÐÈȺῴÍýʬÀÏÆþÌç¡Ù¡ÊΩ²Ö½ñ˼1998¡Ë¡¢29ÊÇ¡£
[25] Åìµþ¾ÃËÉģĴºº²Ý¡Ö¶áǯÅìµþ¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëÊü²Ð²ÐºÒ¤Î¼Â¾ð¡×²ÐºÒ35-5-1¡Ê1985¡Ë¡¢5ÊÇ¡£
[26] »³²¬¡¢Á°Ãí23¡¢100ÊÇ¡£
[27] ¾åÌÁ°Ãí24¡¢30ÊÇ¡£
[28] ²£ÉͻԾÃËɶɡÖÊü²Ð²ÐºÒËÉ»ßÂкö¡½¡½¼ÂÂ֤Ⱥ£¸å¤Î»Üºö¡×²ÐºÒ49-4-49¡Ê1999¡Ë¡¢52ÊÇ¡£
[29] ¾åÌÁ°Ãí24¡¢30ÊÇ¡£
[30] »³²¬°ì¿®¡ÖϢ³Êü²Ð¤ÎÈȺá³Ø¡×·Ù»¡³ØÏÀ½¸33-12-88¡Ê1980¡Ë¡¢94~99ÊÇ¡£
[31] ƱÁ°¡¢94ÊÇ¡£
[32] ƱÁ°¡£
[33] ¾åÌÁ°Ãí24¡¢33ÊÇ¡£
¡Ú¤³¤ì¤ÏºÇ¹âºÛȽ½êÂ裲¾®Ë¡ÄîÊ¿À®24ǯ9·î7ÆüȽ·è¤Î¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ½ñ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡Û
£²¡¡À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý
±ÑÊƤΥ³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤Ç¤Ï¡¢¸Ä¿Í¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤ò¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ò°ìÈ̤˶ػߤ·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òˡŵ²½¤·¤¿[6]Ϣˮ¾Úµòµ¬Â§(Federal Rules of Evidence: FRE)404(a)¤ÏÌÀʸ¤Ç¤³¤Î¸¶Â§¤òÄê¤á¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö¡Êa¡ËÀ³Ê¾Úµò°ìÈÌ¡¡¿Í¤ÎÀ³ÊËô¤Ï¤½¤ÎÆÃÀ¤Î¾Úµò¤Ï¡¢¸ÄÊ̤ε¡²ñ¤ËÈब¤½¤ì¤Ë±è¤Ã¤¿¹ÔÆ°¤ò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ëÌÜŪ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢µöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¡×¤³¤Î¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï¡¢Ë¡Î§Åª´ØÏ¢À¤Ø¤Î¹Íθ[7]¤«¤éÀ¸¤ß½Ð¤µ¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢¸Ä¿Í¤Î¤¢¤ëÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤ò¤½¤Î¿Í¤¬¤½¤ì¤Ë±è¤¦¹ÔÆ°¤ò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤Î¾õ¶·¾Úµò¤Î¤Ò¤È¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢Ä̾ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¾®¤µ¤¤¤Î¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡¢Í½ÃÇÊ諤ò¤â¤¿¤é¤¹´í¸±¤¬Â礤¯¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢ÁèÅÀ¤ò³È»¶¤µ¤»¡¢¿³Íý¤Ë»þ´Ö¤ò¼è¤é¤ì¤ë¤«¤é¤Ç¤¢¤ë[8]¡£¤³¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤¬¸ÄÊ̤λö·ï¤Î¤Ê¤«¤ÇˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÍø±×¹ÍÎÌŪ¤ÊȽÃÇ(balancing-test)¤ò¹Ô¤¦Ééô¤ò²óÈò¤·¤Æ°ì¤Ä¤Î¸ÄÊ̥롼¥ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤³¤ì¤òÄê¼°²½¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[9]¡£
·º»öºÛȽ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¤¢¤ë¼ï¤ÎÈȺá¤òÈȤ¹·¹¸þ¤ò¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÁÊÄɤµ¤ì¤¿ºá¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÄó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£¤³¤Î°À³Ê¤äÈȺ᷹¸þ¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤Î·Á¼°¤Ë¸ÂÄê¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤äÈȺ᷹¸þ¤òľÀÜɽ¸½¤¹¤ë¡ÖɾȽ¡×¤ä¡Ö°Õ¸«¡×¤Î¤Û¤«¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬²áµî¤Ë¹Ô¤Ã¤¿ÆÃÄê¤Î¹ÔÆ°¡¢¤È¤ê¤ï¤±¡¢ÁÊÄɤÎÂоݤȤʤäƤ¤¤Ê¤¤ÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¡Ê¾ºá¡Ë¤Î¾Úµò¤¬¤³¤ì¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤³¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò(other crime evidence)¤Îŵ·¿¤¬ËÜ·ï¤ÇÌäÂê¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ëÁ°²Ê¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò´Þ¤à¾ºá¾Úµò¤òµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ëÈȺá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§404(b)ËÜʸ¤Ï¤³¤¦Äê¤á¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö(b)¡¡Â¾¤Îºá¡¦ÉÔË¡¹Ô°Ù¡¦¹Ô°Ù¡¡¡¡Â¾¤Îºá¡¢ÉÔË¡¹Ô°ÙËô¤Ï¹Ô°Ù¤Î¾Úµò¤Ï¡¢¿Í¤¬¤½¤ì¤Ë±è¤Ã¤¿¹ÔÆ°¤ò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢¤½¤Î¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ëÌÜŪ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡×¡£
¤È¤³¤í¤Ç¡¢Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§¤ÎÌÀʸ¤«¤é¤âÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ê¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤Î»ÈÍѤ¬¶Ø¤¸¤é¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¤¢¤¯¤Þ¤Ç¤â¡ÖÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤È¤·¤ÆÍѤ¤¤é¤ì¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Â¾ºá¤Î¸ºß¤¬¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¡Ê¿äǧ²áÄø¡Ë¤ò·Ð¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Îͺá¤òƳ¤¯¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿äǧ²áÄø¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏA¡Ê¾ºá¡Ë¤Î¸ºß¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤È¾ºá¤È¤¬Æ±¼ï¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¤¢¤ë¤Û¤É¡¢¤³¤Î¿äǧ²áÄø¤¬¶¯²½¤µ¤ì¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò¤Î¤â¤Ä´í¸±À¤¬°ìÁعâ¤Þ¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤ËÃí°Õ¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£
¤·¤«¤·¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤¬¤³¤Î¥Ñ¥¿¡¼¥ó¤Î¿äǧ²áÄø¤ò·Ð¤ë¤³¤È¤Ê¤·¤Ë¡¢¤³¤ì¤È¤ÏÊ̤οäǧ²áÄø¤ò¤È¤ª¤Ã¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Îͺá¤òƳ¤¯¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ï¡ÖÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤ÆµöÍÆÀ¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§404(b)â½ñ¤Ï¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤òÄê¤á¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö⤷¡¢Æ°µ¡¡¢µ¡²ñ¡¢°Õ¿Þ¡¢½àÈ÷¡¢·×²è¡¢Ãμ±¡¢Æ±°ìÀËô¤Ï²á¸í¤ä»ö¸Î¤ÎÉÔ¸ºß¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤Ê¤É¡¢Â¾¤ÎÌÜŪ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏµöÍƤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡£ËÜ·ï¤Ç¤Ï¤³¤Î¤¦¤Á¡ÖƱ°ìÀ¡×(identity)¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¤«¤É¤¦¤«¤¬¤Þ¤µ¤ËÌä¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤ï¤±¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤½¤ÎÌäÂê¤ËÆþ¤ëÁ°¤Ë¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤Î¡ÖÈóÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×Ū¤ÊÍøÍѤΰÕÌ£¤È¤½¤ÎÀµÅö²½º¬µò¤òÍý²ò¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê³°¤ÎŬÍѾìÌ̤δö¤Ä¤«¤ò¸¡Æ¤¤·¤è¤¦¡£
Æ°µ¡¤ÎΩ¾Ú¡¡Î㤨¤Ð¡¢»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤¬¤«¤Ä¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȤ·¤¿ÀàÅð»ö·ï¤Î¸øȽ¤Ç¸¡»¡Â¦¤Î¾Ú¿Í¤È¤·¤Æ½ÐÄ¤¿»ö¼Â¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î¾ì¹ç¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÀàÅðºá¤Çͺá¤È¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¤ÏÈà¤ÎÀ³Ê¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢»¦¿Í¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¡£Éפ¬ºÊ¤ò»¦¤·¤¿ºá¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡¢¤½¤ÎÉפ¬ºÊ¤Ë˽ÎϤò¤Õ¤ë¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤³¤È¤¬µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤«¤ÏÈù̯¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Ã±¤Ë¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Ë½ÎϤËÁʤ¨¤ë·¹¸þ¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹ÄøÅ٤Τâ¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢¤½¤ì¤ÏÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾ºá¤ÎÍøÍѤ˾¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤«¤éµöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢ÆÃÄê¤Î¸Ä¿Í¤ËÂФ·¤Æ½¸Ã椷¤¿·ã¤·¤¤Å¨°Õ¤ò¼¨¤¹¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢Ë½¹Ô¤Î»ö¼Â¤ÏÆ°µ¡¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë²ÄǽÀ¤¬¤¢¤ë[10]¡£
µ¡²ñ¤ÎΩ¾Ú¡¡¡¡¸½¾ì¤Î¶á¤¯¤Ëµï¤¿¤È¤«¡¢Ç½ÎϤ¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤Ê¤É¡¢µ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿ÈȺá¤òÈȤ¹µ¡²ñ¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤òÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£Î㤨¤Ð¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÀìÌçŪ¤ÊÃμ±¤Èµ»½Ñ¤¬¤Ê¤±¤ì¤ÐÆÍÇˤǤ¤Ê¤¤¥¢¥é¡¼¥àÁõÃÖ¤ò¤«¤¤¤¯¤°¤Ã¤Æ¿¯ÆþÅð¤ò¤·¤¿¤È¤·¤Æµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡¢Èब¤«¤Ä¤ÆƱÍͤÎÁõÃÖ¤ò̵³²²½¤·¤Æ¿¯ÆþÅð¤òÈȤ·¤¿»ö¼Â¤Ï¡¢µ¡²ñ¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë[11]¡£
°Õ¿Þ¡¢·×²è¤ä½àÈ÷¤ÎΩ¾Ú¡¡¡¡Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÆÃÄê¤Î°Õ¿Þ¤ò»ý¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤³¤È¤äÈȹԤνàÈ÷¤ò¤·¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¾ºá¾Úµò¤òÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£Î㤨¤Ð¡¢°ãË¡Ìôʪ¤ÎÌ©Í¢¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÂáÊᤵ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤ËÉð´ï¤ò½ê»ý¤·¤Æ¤¤¤¿»ö¼Â¤Ï¡¢¤½¤³¤Ç¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ëÌ©Í¢¼è°ú¤òËɱҤ¹¤ë°Õ¿Þ¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë[12]¡£
ÉԲĹ³ÎϤä»ö¸Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¼çÄ¥¤Ø¤ÎÈ¿¾Ú¡¡¡¡»ö·ï¤¬ÉԲĹ³ÎϤä»ö¸Î¤Ê¤É¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢°Õ¿ÞŪ¤Ê¹ÔÆ°¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¤¿¤á¤ËÎà»÷¤Î½ÐÍè»ö¤ä¹ÔÆ°¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£¤½¤ÎÎã¤È¤·¤Æ¤è¤¯°ú¤«¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¡ÖÍáÁå¤Î²Ö²Ç¡×»ö·ï¤È¸À¤ï¤ì¤ë¥¸¥ç¡¼¥¸¡¦¥¸¥ç¥»¥Õ¡¦¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Î»¦¿Í»ö·ï[13]¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Ï¿·ºÊ¤ò¥Þ¥ó¥·¥ç¥ó¤ÎÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤µ¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»¦¿Í¤Îºá¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¡£¸¡»¡´±¤ÏÈà¤È·ëº§¤·¤¿Â¾¤Î2¿Í¤Î½÷À¤âÁ´¤¯Æ±¤¸¾õ¶·¤ÇÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤¿¡£1·ï¤À¤±¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢»ö¸Î¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤â¤¢¤êÆÀ¤ë¤¬¡¢3¿Í¤â¿·ºÊ¤¬Â³¤±¤ÆÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤¹¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï»ö¸Î¤ä¶öÁ³¤Ç¤ÏÀâÌÀ¤¬¤Ä¤«¤Ê¤¤[14]¡£¤³¤Î¿äǧ¤Î²áÄø¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Î°À³Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȺá¤Î¿äǧ¤È¤¤¤¦¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤ÏÁ´¤¯¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ë¤ï¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢»ö¸Î¤äÉԲĹ³ÎϤȤ¤¤¦ÊÛ²ò¤¬ÉÔ¹çÍý¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤³¤Ë°°Õ¤Î¹Ô°Ù¤Î²ðºß¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤Ë°µÅݤµ¤ì¤Æ¡¢Á°¼Ô¤Î¡ÖÊÀ³²¡×¤Ï¹Íθ¤¹¤ëɬÍפ¬¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ÎȽÎã¤Î¤Ê¤«¤Ç¾¼ÏÂ15ǯȽ·è¡Ê·ëº§º¾µ½»ö·ï¡Ë¤ä¾¼ÏÂ41ǯ·èÄê¡Ê´óÉն⺾µ½»ö·ï¡Ë¤Ï¤³¤ÎÎã³°¤ÎŬÍÑÎã¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»ñ»º²È¤òÁõ¤¤·ëº§¤¹¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¿¨¤ì¹þ¤ß¤ÇÂç¶â¤òº¾¼è¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦ÁÊ°ø¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï·ëº§¤¹¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤À¤Ã¤¿¤·¼Ú¶â¤âÊֺѤ¹¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤À¤Ã¤¿¡¢¤½¤Î¸å¤Î»ö¾ð¤ÎÊѹ¹¤Ç·ëº§¤âÊֺѤâ¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¹³ÊÛ¤òÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¡£¤½¤ÎƱ¤¸Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç¤Ë²¿Å٤⡢½÷À¤Ë·ëº§¤¹¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÂç¶â¤ò»µ¤¤¢¤²¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤Êº¾µ½¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò»ý¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤À¤È¤¹¤ì¤Ð¡¢¤³¤Î¹³ÊۤθúÎϤÏÂ礤¤Ë¸º»¦¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¤³¤Î¿äǧ¤Î²áÄø¤Ë¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤ÏÆþ¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£Á°²Ê¤¬¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤¢¤ë¤¤¤ÏÀÊʤˤè¤Ã¤ÆͺáǧÄꤵ¤ì¤ë´í¸±¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ê¤Ï¤·¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢¤½¤Î¸å¤Î»ö¾ðÊѹ¹¤È¤¤¤¦¹³ÊۤؤÎÈ¿¾Ú¤È¤¤¤¦¾Úµò²ÁÃͤÎÊý¤¬Èó¾ï¤Ë¹â¤¯¡¢¤³¤Î´í¸±¤ò¤Ï¤ë¤«¤Ëο²ï¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¾ºá¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï°À³Ê¤½¤ì¼«ÂΤò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¡¡Â¾ºá¤Î¸ºß¤½¤ì¼«ÂΤ¬ºÛȽ¤ÎΩ¾Ú¥Æ¡¼¥Þ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎÌäÂê¤ÏÁ´¤¯À¸¤¸¤Ê¤¤¡£¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ÎȽÎ㤬·«¤êÊÖ¤·½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢ÈȺṽÀ®Í×·ï¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾ï½¬À¤äÎÌ·º»ö¾ð¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÎßÈȤò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ï¤³¤ì¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤ë¡£Æ±Íͤˡ¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤¬Áʾپå¤ÎÁèÅÀ¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ÎÀ³Ê¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤òÄó½Ð¤Ç¤¤ë[15]¡£¾¼ÏÂ4ǯȽ·è¤Î¶²³åºá¤Î»öÎã¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤Ë¸À¤Ã¤¿¶¼Ç÷ʸ¸À¤ÎÃæ¤Ë¾ºá¤Î¸ºß¤¬¤¢¤ê¡Ê¡Ö¼«Ê¬¥Ï¾¨¥Æ·ö²Þ¥·¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥â¥¢¥êËô¿Í¥ò»Â¥ê¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥â¥¢¥ê¾ì¹ç¥Ë°Í¥ê¥Æ¥Ï·Ù»¡¥ò¸þ¥Õ¥Ë²ö¥·¥Æ¥â°ú¥±¥ò¼è¥é¥Ì¡×¡Ë¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀ¹Ô¤Î¿Íʪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¿®¤¸¤¿¤¬¸Î¤Ë°ÚÉݤ·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Â¾ºá¤Î¸ºß¤äÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁÆ˽¤ÊÀ³Ê¤½¤ì¼«ÂΤ¬Î©¾ÚÂоݤÀ¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤äÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤ò¡ÖÈÈ¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥«ÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥È¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¡×¤È¸Æ¤ó¤À¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
Á±À³Ê¾Úµò¤Þ¤¿¤ÏÈ¿¾Ú¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î°À³Ê¾Úµò¡¡¡¡Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤òÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡½¡½Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤ÎÀ³Ê¤Ë±è¤Ã¤¿¹ÔÆ°¤ò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡½¡½»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬Î㳰Ū¤Ëµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¾ì¹ç¤¬¤¢¤ë¡£¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÏÅÁÅýŪ¤Ë¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¼«Ê¬¤Î¡ÖÎɤ¤À³Ê¡×¤òÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¤òÈÝÄꤹ¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÄó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òǧ¤á¤Æ¤¤¿¡£¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¤ËÈï³²¼Ô¤¬Àè¤Ë¹¶·â¤ò»Å³Ý¤±¤Æ¤¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤Î¹¶·âŪ¤ÊÀ³Ê¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤òÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬Äó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ëȼ¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¦¤¬¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤òÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¸¡»¡Â¦¤Ï¤½¤ì¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÈ¿¾Ú¤È¤·¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤ä¹¶·âÀ¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤òÄó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§¤â¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÎã³°¤È¤·¤Æ¤³¤ì¤òÄê¤á¤Æ¤¤¤ë(FRE404(a)(1))[16]¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¤¬¼«Ê¬¤Î°ìÄê¤ÎÆüÁ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤òÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡Ö¥É¥¢¤ò³«¤±¤¿¡×¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢¸øÊ¿À¤Î´ÑÅÀ¤«¤é¸¡»¡´±¤ËÈ¿¾Ú¤Îµ¡²ñ¤òÍ¿¤¨¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[17]¡£Î㤨¤Ð¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¦¤Î¾Ú¿Í¤¬Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ±ÎɤÊÀ³Ê¡½¡½Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏÁ±ÎɤʼҲñ¿Í¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢ÁÆ˽¤Ê¤È¤³¤í¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤Ê¤É¡½¡½¤ò¾Ú¸À¤·¤¿¾ì¹ç¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¤½¤Î¾Ú¸À¤ÈÌ·½â¤¹¤ë¥¨¥Ô¥½¡¼¥É¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤ÆÈ¿ÂпÒÌä¤ÇÌ䤤¤¿¤À¤¹¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¤·¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢Ê̤ξڿͤò¸Æ¤ó¤ÇÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤ò¾Ú¸À¤µ¤»¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[18]¡£
ºÇ½ªÈ½ÃǤΤ¿¤á¤ÎˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¿³ºº¡Ê¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¡Ë¡¡Á°½Ò¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤ÏˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ÎȽÃǤΰì¤Ä¤Î¶ÉÌ̤ò¼è¤ê½Ð¤·¤ÆÆÈΩ¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤È¤·¤ÆÄê¼°²½¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤¬µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ëÎ㳰Ū¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ë³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÁÊÄɤÎÂоݤȤʤäƤ¤¤Ê¤¤Ê̺á¤òÈȤ·¤¿»ö¼Â¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤·¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤ò¼¨¤¹·¹¸þ¤Î¶¯¤¤¾Úµò¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ËÊѤï¤ê¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤ÎÎ㳰Ū¤Ê¾Úµò²ÁÃͤËÂÐÖµ¤¹¤ëÊÀ³²¡½¡½Í½ÃÇÊи«¡¢ÁèÅÀ¤Îº®Í𡢸íƳ¡¢»þ´Ö¤ÎϲÈñ¡½¡½¤Ï¾Ã¤¨¤Æ¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ë¤ï¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Ã±¤ËÎã³°¤Î¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡Ö³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¾ºá¾Úµò¤òµöÍƤ¹¤Ù¤¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Îã³°¤Î¾ì¹ç¤Ë³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¤ÈȽÃǤ·¤¿¤Ê¤é¤Ð¡¢¤µ¤é¤ËˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ÎÍ̵¤ò¿³ºº¤¹¤ë¡Ê¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¡ËɬÍפ¬¤¢¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤¬¸À¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢
¡ÖÈȺá¤ÎÀÊʤò¼¨¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦¶Ø¤¸¤é¤ì¤¿ÌÜŪ¤Î¤Û¤«¤Ë¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤ò¼õ¤±Æþ¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Îµö¤µ¤ì¤¿ÏÀÍýŪ´ðÁ䬤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¤Ï¡¢Ç濳¤â¤Þ¤¿Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȺ᷹¸þ¤ò½Å¤ó¤¸¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤òÊݾ㤷¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤Û¤È¤ó¤É¤ÎÀèÎã¤Ï¤³¤ÎÌäÂê¤Ïñ¤Ê¤ëÀ°ÍýʬÎà¤ÎÌäÂê¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Ê¬Îष¤«¤ÄÍø±×¹ÍÎ̤¹¤ë(classifying and then balancing)ÌäÂê¤À¤È¹Í¤¨¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ÉÔ¸øÀµ¤ÊͽÃǤ½¤Î¾¤ÎÊÀ³²¤¬¡¢Éղ䵤ì¤ë¾Úµò²ÁÃͤò¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ëο²ï¤¹¤ë¤«¤É¤¦¤«¤ò·èÄꤹ¤ë¤ËºÝ¤·¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤ò´Þ¤àÍÍ¡¹¤Ê»öÊÁ¤¬¹Í褵¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Â¾ºá¤¬ÈȤµ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¾Úµò¤Î¶¯¤µ¡¢ÈȺá´Ö¤ÎÎà»÷À¡¢ÈȺá´Ö¤Î»þ´Ö¤Î·Ð²á¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤ÎɬÍ×À¡¢Â¾¤ÎÂåÂؾڵò¤ÎÍÍÑÀ¡¢¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÇ濳¤¬Å¨°Õ¤Ë°µÅݤµ¤ì¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦²ÄǽÀ¤ÎÄøÅ٤ʤɤǤ¢¤ë¡×[19]¡£
¤³¤Î¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï»ö¼Â¿³ºÛȽ´±¤ÎºÛÎÌŪȽÃǤ¬Âº½Å¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¾Úµò²ÁÃͤÈÊÀ³²¤òÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤¹¤ë»Å»ö¤Ïñ½ã¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£Ê£»¨¤Êºî¶È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸«¼±¤¢¤ëºÛȽ´±¤Î´Ö¤Ç¤â·ëÏÀ¤Ï°Û¤Ê¤ê¤¦¤ë¡£Æ±°ì¤Î¾Úµò¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤Î»ö·ïÁ´ÂΤˤª¤±¤ë°ÌÃ֤Ť±¤ä¾¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤Î´Ø·¸¤Ê¤É¤Ë±þ¤¸¤Æ¡¢»ö·ï¤´¤È¤Ë·ëÏÀ¤Ï°Û¤Ê¤ê¤¦¤ë¡£¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢ºÛȽŤ¬Ç濳¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¹Ô¤¦Ãí°Õ´µ¯¤ÎÀ⼨(cautionary instructions; limiting instruction)¤¬¤É¤ÎÄøÅÙ͸ú¤Ê¤Î¤«¤â»ö·ï¤´¤È¤Ë°Û¤Ê¤ê¤¦¤ë¡£¤À¤«¤é¡¢¤³¤Î¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï»ö¼Â¿³ºÛȽ´±¤ÎºÛÎ̤¬Âº½Å¤µ¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ÎȽÃǤ¬°ìÊýŪ¤Ç¤¢¤êÍôÍѤµ¤ì¤¿¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤È¤¤Ë¸Â¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¾åÁÊ¿³¤Ï¤½¤ì¤òʤ¤¹¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë[20]¡£
¡Ú³¤¯¡Û
£²¡¡À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý
±ÑÊƤΥ³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤Ç¤Ï¡¢¸Ä¿Í¤ÎÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤ò¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ò°ìÈ̤˶ػߤ·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òˡŵ²½¤·¤¿[6]Ϣˮ¾Úµòµ¬Â§(Federal Rules of Evidence: FRE)404(a)¤ÏÌÀʸ¤Ç¤³¤Î¸¶Â§¤òÄê¤á¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö¡Êa¡ËÀ³Ê¾Úµò°ìÈÌ¡¡¿Í¤ÎÀ³ÊËô¤Ï¤½¤ÎÆÃÀ¤Î¾Úµò¤Ï¡¢¸ÄÊ̤ε¡²ñ¤ËÈब¤½¤ì¤Ë±è¤Ã¤¿¹ÔÆ°¤ò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ëÌÜŪ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢µöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¡×¤³¤Î¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï¡¢Ë¡Î§Åª´ØÏ¢À¤Ø¤Î¹Íθ[7]¤«¤éÀ¸¤ß½Ð¤µ¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢¸Ä¿Í¤Î¤¢¤ëÀ³ÊÆÃÀ¤ò¤½¤Î¿Í¤¬¤½¤ì¤Ë±è¤¦¹ÔÆ°¤ò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤Î¾õ¶·¾Úµò¤Î¤Ò¤È¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢Ä̾ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¾®¤µ¤¤¤Î¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡¢Í½ÃÇÊ諤ò¤â¤¿¤é¤¹´í¸±¤¬Â礤¯¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢ÁèÅÀ¤ò³È»¶¤µ¤»¡¢¿³Íý¤Ë»þ´Ö¤ò¼è¤é¤ì¤ë¤«¤é¤Ç¤¢¤ë[8]¡£¤³¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤¬¸ÄÊ̤λö·ï¤Î¤Ê¤«¤ÇˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÍø±×¹ÍÎÌŪ¤ÊȽÃÇ(balancing-test)¤ò¹Ô¤¦Ééô¤ò²óÈò¤·¤Æ°ì¤Ä¤Î¸ÄÊ̥롼¥ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤³¤ì¤òÄê¼°²½¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[9]¡£
·º»öºÛȽ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¤¢¤ë¼ï¤ÎÈȺá¤òÈȤ¹·¹¸þ¤ò¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÁÊÄɤµ¤ì¤¿ºá¤òÈȤ·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÄó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£¤³¤Î°À³Ê¤äÈȺ᷹¸þ¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤Î·Á¼°¤Ë¸ÂÄê¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤äÈȺ᷹¸þ¤òľÀÜɽ¸½¤¹¤ë¡ÖɾȽ¡×¤ä¡Ö°Õ¸«¡×¤Î¤Û¤«¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬²áµî¤Ë¹Ô¤Ã¤¿ÆÃÄê¤Î¹ÔÆ°¡¢¤È¤ê¤ï¤±¡¢ÁÊÄɤÎÂоݤȤʤäƤ¤¤Ê¤¤ÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¡Ê¾ºá¡Ë¤Î¾Úµò¤¬¤³¤ì¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤³¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò(other crime evidence)¤Îŵ·¿¤¬ËÜ·ï¤ÇÌäÂê¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ëÁ°²Ê¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò´Þ¤à¾ºá¾Úµò¤òµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ëÈȺá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§404(b)ËÜʸ¤Ï¤³¤¦Äê¤á¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö(b)¡¡Â¾¤Îºá¡¦ÉÔË¡¹Ô°Ù¡¦¹Ô°Ù¡¡¡¡Â¾¤Îºá¡¢ÉÔË¡¹Ô°ÙËô¤Ï¹Ô°Ù¤Î¾Úµò¤Ï¡¢¿Í¤¬¤½¤ì¤Ë±è¤Ã¤¿¹ÔÆ°¤ò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢¤½¤Î¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ëÌÜŪ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡×¡£
¤È¤³¤í¤Ç¡¢Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§¤ÎÌÀʸ¤«¤é¤âÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ê¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤Î»ÈÍѤ¬¶Ø¤¸¤é¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¤¢¤¯¤Þ¤Ç¤â¡ÖÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤È¤·¤ÆÍѤ¤¤é¤ì¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Â¾ºá¤Î¸ºß¤¬¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¡Ê¿äǧ²áÄø¡Ë¤ò·Ð¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Îͺá¤òƳ¤¯¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¡¡¡Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¤«¤Ä¤ÆA¤È¤¤¤¦ºá¤òÈȤ·¤¿¡£
¢
¢¡¡Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏA¤ÈƱÍͤκá¤òÈȤ¹À³Ê·¹¸þ¤ò»ý¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
¢
£¡¡Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏA¤ÈƱÍͤκá¤Ç¤¢¤ëµ¯ÁʾõµºÜ¤Îºá¤òÈȤ·¤¿²ÄǽÀ¤¬¤¢¤ë¡£
¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿äǧ²áÄø¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏA¡Ê¾ºá¡Ë¤Î¸ºß¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤È¾ºá¤È¤¬Æ±¼ï¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¤¢¤ë¤Û¤É¡¢¤³¤Î¿äǧ²áÄø¤¬¶¯²½¤µ¤ì¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾ºá¾Úµò¤Î¤â¤Ä´í¸±À¤¬°ìÁعâ¤Þ¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤ËÃí°Õ¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£
¤·¤«¤·¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤¬¤³¤Î¥Ñ¥¿¡¼¥ó¤Î¿äǧ²áÄø¤ò·Ð¤ë¤³¤È¤Ê¤·¤Ë¡¢¤³¤ì¤È¤ÏÊ̤οäǧ²áÄø¤ò¤È¤ª¤Ã¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Îͺá¤òƳ¤¯¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ï¡ÖÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤ÆµöÍÆÀ¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§404(b)â½ñ¤Ï¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤òÄê¤á¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡½¡½¡Ö⤷¡¢Æ°µ¡¡¢µ¡²ñ¡¢°Õ¿Þ¡¢½àÈ÷¡¢·×²è¡¢Ãμ±¡¢Æ±°ìÀËô¤Ï²á¸í¤ä»ö¸Î¤ÎÉÔ¸ºß¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤Ê¤É¡¢Â¾¤ÎÌÜŪ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏµöÍƤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡£ËÜ·ï¤Ç¤Ï¤³¤Î¤¦¤Á¡ÖƱ°ìÀ¡×(identity)¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¤«¤É¤¦¤«¤¬¤Þ¤µ¤ËÌä¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤ï¤±¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤½¤ÎÌäÂê¤ËÆþ¤ëÁ°¤Ë¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤Î¡ÖÈóÀ³Ê¾Úµò¡×Ū¤ÊÍøÍѤΰÕÌ£¤È¤½¤ÎÀµÅö²½º¬µò¤òÍý²ò¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê³°¤ÎŬÍѾìÌ̤δö¤Ä¤«¤ò¸¡Æ¤¤·¤è¤¦¡£
Æ°µ¡¤ÎΩ¾Ú¡¡Î㤨¤Ð¡¢»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤¬¤«¤Ä¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȤ·¤¿ÀàÅð»ö·ï¤Î¸øȽ¤Ç¸¡»¡Â¦¤Î¾Ú¿Í¤È¤·¤Æ½ÐÄ¤¿»ö¼Â¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î¾ì¹ç¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÀàÅðºá¤Çͺá¤È¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¤ÏÈà¤ÎÀ³Ê¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢»¦¿Í¤ÎÆ°µ¡¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¡£Éפ¬ºÊ¤ò»¦¤·¤¿ºá¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡¢¤½¤ÎÉפ¬ºÊ¤Ë˽ÎϤò¤Õ¤ë¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤³¤È¤¬µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤«¤ÏÈù̯¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Ã±¤Ë¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Ë½ÎϤËÁʤ¨¤ë·¹¸þ¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹ÄøÅ٤Τâ¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢¤½¤ì¤ÏÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾ºá¤ÎÍøÍѤ˾¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤«¤éµöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢ÆÃÄê¤Î¸Ä¿Í¤ËÂФ·¤Æ½¸Ã椷¤¿·ã¤·¤¤Å¨°Õ¤ò¼¨¤¹¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢Ë½¹Ô¤Î»ö¼Â¤ÏÆ°µ¡¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë²ÄǽÀ¤¬¤¢¤ë[10]¡£
µ¡²ñ¤ÎΩ¾Ú¡¡¡¡¸½¾ì¤Î¶á¤¯¤Ëµï¤¿¤È¤«¡¢Ç½ÎϤ¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤Ê¤É¡¢µ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿ÈȺá¤òÈȤ¹µ¡²ñ¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤òÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£Î㤨¤Ð¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÀìÌçŪ¤ÊÃμ±¤Èµ»½Ñ¤¬¤Ê¤±¤ì¤ÐÆÍÇˤǤ¤Ê¤¤¥¢¥é¡¼¥àÁõÃÖ¤ò¤«¤¤¤¯¤°¤Ã¤Æ¿¯ÆþÅð¤ò¤·¤¿¤È¤·¤Æµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡¢Èब¤«¤Ä¤ÆƱÍͤÎÁõÃÖ¤ò̵³²²½¤·¤Æ¿¯ÆþÅð¤òÈȤ·¤¿»ö¼Â¤Ï¡¢µ¡²ñ¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë[11]¡£
°Õ¿Þ¡¢·×²è¤ä½àÈ÷¤ÎΩ¾Ú¡¡¡¡Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÆÃÄê¤Î°Õ¿Þ¤ò»ý¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤³¤È¤äÈȹԤνàÈ÷¤ò¤·¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¾ºá¾Úµò¤òÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£Î㤨¤Ð¡¢°ãË¡Ìôʪ¤ÎÌ©Í¢¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÂáÊᤵ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤ËÉð´ï¤ò½ê»ý¤·¤Æ¤¤¤¿»ö¼Â¤Ï¡¢¤½¤³¤Ç¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ëÌ©Í¢¼è°ú¤òËɱҤ¹¤ë°Õ¿Þ¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë[12]¡£
ÉԲĹ³ÎϤä»ö¸Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¼çÄ¥¤Ø¤ÎÈ¿¾Ú¡¡¡¡»ö·ï¤¬ÉԲĹ³ÎϤä»ö¸Î¤Ê¤É¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢°Õ¿ÞŪ¤Ê¹ÔÆ°¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¤¿¤á¤ËÎà»÷¤Î½ÐÍè»ö¤ä¹ÔÆ°¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£¤½¤ÎÎã¤È¤·¤Æ¤è¤¯°ú¤«¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¡ÖÍáÁå¤Î²Ö²Ç¡×»ö·ï¤È¸À¤ï¤ì¤ë¥¸¥ç¡¼¥¸¡¦¥¸¥ç¥»¥Õ¡¦¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Î»¦¿Í»ö·ï[13]¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Ï¿·ºÊ¤ò¥Þ¥ó¥·¥ç¥ó¤ÎÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤µ¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»¦¿Í¤Îºá¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¡£¸¡»¡´±¤ÏÈà¤È·ëº§¤·¤¿Â¾¤Î2¿Í¤Î½÷À¤âÁ´¤¯Æ±¤¸¾õ¶·¤ÇÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤¿¡£1·ï¤À¤±¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢»ö¸Î¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤â¤¢¤êÆÀ¤ë¤¬¡¢3¿Í¤â¿·ºÊ¤¬Â³¤±¤ÆÍáÁå¤ÇÅ®»à¤¹¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï»ö¸Î¤ä¶öÁ³¤Ç¤ÏÀâÌÀ¤¬¤Ä¤«¤Ê¤¤[14]¡£¤³¤Î¿äǧ¤Î²áÄø¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¥¹¥ß¥¹¤Î°À³Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȺá¤Î¿äǧ¤È¤¤¤¦¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤ÏÁ´¤¯¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ë¤ï¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢»ö¸Î¤äÉԲĹ³ÎϤȤ¤¤¦ÊÛ²ò¤¬ÉÔ¹çÍý¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤³¤Ë°°Õ¤Î¹Ô°Ù¤Î²ðºß¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¥í¥¸¥Ã¥¯¤Ë°µÅݤµ¤ì¤Æ¡¢Á°¼Ô¤Î¡ÖÊÀ³²¡×¤Ï¹Íθ¤¹¤ëɬÍפ¬¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ÎȽÎã¤Î¤Ê¤«¤Ç¾¼ÏÂ15ǯȽ·è¡Ê·ëº§º¾µ½»ö·ï¡Ë¤ä¾¼ÏÂ41ǯ·èÄê¡Ê´óÉն⺾µ½»ö·ï¡Ë¤Ï¤³¤ÎÎã³°¤ÎŬÍÑÎã¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»ñ»º²È¤òÁõ¤¤·ëº§¤¹¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¿¨¤ì¹þ¤ß¤ÇÂç¶â¤òº¾¼è¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦ÁÊ°ø¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï·ëº§¤¹¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤À¤Ã¤¿¤·¼Ú¶â¤âÊֺѤ¹¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤À¤Ã¤¿¡¢¤½¤Î¸å¤Î»ö¾ð¤ÎÊѹ¹¤Ç·ëº§¤âÊֺѤâ¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¹³ÊÛ¤òÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¡£¤½¤ÎƱ¤¸Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç¤Ë²¿Å٤⡢½÷À¤Ë·ëº§¤¹¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÂç¶â¤ò»µ¤¤¢¤²¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤Êº¾µ½¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò»ý¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤À¤È¤¹¤ì¤Ð¡¢¤³¤Î¹³ÊۤθúÎϤÏÂ礤¤Ë¸º»¦¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¤³¤Î¿äǧ¤Î²áÄø¤Ë¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤ÏÆþ¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£Á°²Ê¤¬¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤¢¤ë¤¤¤ÏÀÊʤˤè¤Ã¤ÆͺáǧÄꤵ¤ì¤ë´í¸±¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ê¤Ï¤·¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢¤½¤Î¸å¤Î»ö¾ðÊѹ¹¤È¤¤¤¦¹³ÊۤؤÎÈ¿¾Ú¤È¤¤¤¦¾Úµò²ÁÃͤÎÊý¤¬Èó¾ï¤Ë¹â¤¯¡¢¤³¤Î´í¸±¤ò¤Ï¤ë¤«¤Ëο²ï¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¾ºá¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï°À³Ê¤½¤ì¼«ÂΤò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¡¡Â¾ºá¤Î¸ºß¤½¤ì¼«ÂΤ¬ºÛȽ¤ÎΩ¾Ú¥Æ¡¼¥Þ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ï¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎÌäÂê¤ÏÁ´¤¯À¸¤¸¤Ê¤¤¡£¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ÎȽÎ㤬·«¤êÊÖ¤·½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢ÈȺṽÀ®Í×·ï¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î¾ï½¬À¤äÎÌ·º»ö¾ð¤È¤·¤Æ¤ÎÎßÈȤò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ï¤³¤ì¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤ë¡£Æ±Íͤˡ¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤¬Áʾپå¤ÎÁèÅÀ¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤½¤ÎÀ³Ê¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤òÄó½Ð¤Ç¤¤ë[15]¡£¾¼ÏÂ4ǯȽ·è¤Î¶²³åºá¤Î»öÎã¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤Ë¸À¤Ã¤¿¶¼Ç÷ʸ¸À¤ÎÃæ¤Ë¾ºá¤Î¸ºß¤¬¤¢¤ê¡Ê¡Ö¼«Ê¬¥Ï¾¨¥Æ·ö²Þ¥·¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥â¥¢¥êËô¿Í¥ò»Â¥ê¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥â¥¢¥ê¾ì¹ç¥Ë°Í¥ê¥Æ¥Ï·Ù»¡¥ò¸þ¥Õ¥Ë²ö¥·¥Æ¥â°ú¥±¥ò¼è¥é¥Ì¡×¡Ë¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀ¹Ô¤Î¿Íʪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¿®¤¸¤¿¤¬¸Î¤Ë°ÚÉݤ·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Â¾ºá¤Î¸ºß¤äÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁÆ˽¤ÊÀ³Ê¤½¤ì¼«ÂΤ¬Î©¾ÚÂоݤÀ¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤äÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤ò¡ÖÈÈ¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥«ÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥È¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¡×¤È¸Æ¤ó¤À¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
Á±À³Ê¾Úµò¤Þ¤¿¤ÏÈ¿¾Ú¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î°À³Ê¾Úµò¡¡¡¡Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤òÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡½¡½Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤ÎÀ³Ê¤Ë±è¤Ã¤¿¹ÔÆ°¤ò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡½¡½»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬Î㳰Ū¤Ëµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¾ì¹ç¤¬¤¢¤ë¡£¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÏÅÁÅýŪ¤Ë¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¼«Ê¬¤Î¡ÖÎɤ¤À³Ê¡×¤òÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¤òÈÝÄꤹ¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÄó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òǧ¤á¤Æ¤¤¿¡£¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¤ËÈï³²¼Ô¤¬Àè¤Ë¹¶·â¤ò»Å³Ý¤±¤Æ¤¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤Î¹¶·âŪ¤ÊÀ³Ê¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤òÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬Äó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ì¤Ëȼ¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¦¤¬¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤òÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¸¡»¡Â¦¤Ï¤½¤ì¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÈ¿¾Ú¤È¤·¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤ä¹¶·âÀ¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤òÄó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡£Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§¤â¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÎã³°¤È¤·¤Æ¤³¤ì¤òÄê¤á¤Æ¤¤¤ë(FRE404(a)(1))[16]¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¤¬¼«Ê¬¤Î°ìÄê¤ÎÆüÁ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤òÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡Ö¥É¥¢¤ò³«¤±¤¿¡×¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢¸øÊ¿À¤Î´ÑÅÀ¤«¤é¸¡»¡´±¤ËÈ¿¾Ú¤Îµ¡²ñ¤òÍ¿¤¨¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[17]¡£Î㤨¤Ð¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¦¤Î¾Ú¿Í¤¬Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ±ÎɤÊÀ³Ê¡½¡½Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏÁ±ÎɤʼҲñ¿Í¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢ÁÆ˽¤Ê¤È¤³¤í¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤Ê¤É¡½¡½¤ò¾Ú¸À¤·¤¿¾ì¹ç¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¤½¤Î¾Ú¸À¤ÈÌ·½â¤¹¤ë¥¨¥Ô¥½¡¼¥É¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤ÆÈ¿ÂпÒÌä¤ÇÌ䤤¤¿¤À¤¹¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¤·¡¢¤Þ¤¿¡¢Ê̤ξڿͤò¸Æ¤ó¤ÇÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ³Ê¤ò¾Ú¸À¤µ¤»¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë[18]¡£
ºÇ½ªÈ½ÃǤΤ¿¤á¤ÎˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¿³ºº¡Ê¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¡Ë¡¡Á°½Ò¤·¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤ÏˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ÎȽÃǤΰì¤Ä¤Î¶ÉÌ̤ò¼è¤ê½Ð¤·¤ÆÆÈΩ¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤È¤·¤ÆÄê¼°²½¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤¬µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ëÎ㳰Ū¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ë³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÁÊÄɤÎÂоݤȤʤäƤ¤¤Ê¤¤Ê̺á¤òÈȤ·¤¿»ö¼Â¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤·¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î°À³Ê¤ò¼¨¤¹·¹¸þ¤Î¶¯¤¤¾Úµò¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ËÊѤï¤ê¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤ÎÎ㳰Ū¤Ê¾Úµò²ÁÃͤËÂÐÖµ¤¹¤ëÊÀ³²¡½¡½Í½ÃÇÊи«¡¢ÁèÅÀ¤Îº®Í𡢸íƳ¡¢»þ´Ö¤ÎϲÈñ¡½¡½¤Ï¾Ã¤¨¤Æ¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ë¤ï¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Ã±¤ËÎã³°¤Î¾ì¹ç¤Ë¡Ö³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¾ºá¾Úµò¤òµöÍƤ¹¤Ù¤¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Îã³°¤Î¾ì¹ç¤Ë³ºÅö¤¹¤ë¤ÈȽÃǤ·¤¿¤Ê¤é¤Ð¡¢¤µ¤é¤ËˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ÎÍ̵¤ò¿³ºº¤¹¤ë¡Ê¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¡ËɬÍפ¬¤¢¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¥Þ¥³¡¼¥ß¥Ã¥¯¤¬¸À¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢
¡ÖÈȺá¤ÎÀÊʤò¼¨¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦¶Ø¤¸¤é¤ì¤¿ÌÜŪ¤Î¤Û¤«¤Ë¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤ò¼õ¤±Æþ¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Îµö¤µ¤ì¤¿ÏÀÍýŪ´ðÁ䬤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¤Ï¡¢Ç濳¤â¤Þ¤¿Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈȺ᷹¸þ¤ò½Å¤ó¤¸¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤òÊݾ㤷¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤Û¤È¤ó¤É¤ÎÀèÎã¤Ï¤³¤ÎÌäÂê¤Ïñ¤Ê¤ëÀ°ÍýʬÎà¤ÎÌäÂê¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Ê¬Îष¤«¤ÄÍø±×¹ÍÎ̤¹¤ë(classifying and then balancing)ÌäÂê¤À¤È¹Í¤¨¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ÉÔ¸øÀµ¤ÊͽÃǤ½¤Î¾¤ÎÊÀ³²¤¬¡¢Éղ䵤ì¤ë¾Úµò²ÁÃͤò¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ëο²ï¤¹¤ë¤«¤É¤¦¤«¤ò·èÄꤹ¤ë¤ËºÝ¤·¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤ò´Þ¤àÍÍ¡¹¤Ê»öÊÁ¤¬¹Í褵¤ì¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Â¾ºá¤¬ÈȤµ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¾Úµò¤Î¶¯¤µ¡¢ÈȺá´Ö¤ÎÎà»÷À¡¢ÈȺá´Ö¤Î»þ´Ö¤Î·Ð²á¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤ÎɬÍ×À¡¢Â¾¤ÎÂåÂؾڵò¤ÎÍÍÑÀ¡¢¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÇ濳¤¬Å¨°Õ¤Ë°µÅݤµ¤ì¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤¦²ÄǽÀ¤ÎÄøÅ٤ʤɤǤ¢¤ë¡×[19]¡£
¤³¤Î¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï»ö¼Â¿³ºÛȽ´±¤ÎºÛÎÌŪȽÃǤ¬Âº½Å¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¾Úµò²ÁÃͤÈÊÀ³²¤òÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤¹¤ë»Å»ö¤Ïñ½ã¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£Ê£»¨¤Êºî¶È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸«¼±¤¢¤ëºÛȽ´±¤Î´Ö¤Ç¤â·ëÏÀ¤Ï°Û¤Ê¤ê¤¦¤ë¡£Æ±°ì¤Î¾Úµò¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤Î»ö·ïÁ´ÂΤˤª¤±¤ë°ÌÃ֤Ť±¤ä¾¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤Î´Ø·¸¤Ê¤É¤Ë±þ¤¸¤Æ¡¢»ö·ï¤´¤È¤Ë·ëÏÀ¤Ï°Û¤Ê¤ê¤¦¤ë¡£¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢ºÛȽŤ¬Ç濳¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¹Ô¤¦Ãí°Õ´µ¯¤ÎÀ⼨(cautionary instructions; limiting instruction)¤¬¤É¤ÎÄøÅÙ͸ú¤Ê¤Î¤«¤â»ö·ï¤´¤È¤Ë°Û¤Ê¤ê¤¦¤ë¡£¤À¤«¤é¡¢¤³¤Î¥Ð¥é¥ó¥·¥ó¥°¡¦¥Æ¥¹¥È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï»ö¼Â¿³ºÛȽ´±¤ÎºÛÎ̤¬Âº½Å¤µ¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ÎȽÃǤ¬°ìÊýŪ¤Ç¤¢¤êÍôÍѤµ¤ì¤¿¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¤È¤¤Ë¸Â¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¾åÁÊ¿³¤Ï¤½¤ì¤òʤ¤¹¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë[20]¡£
¡Ú³¤¯¡Û
¡Ú¤³¤ì¤ÏºÇ¹âºÛȽ½êÂ裲¾®Ë¡ÄîÊ¿À®£²£´Ç¯£¹·î£·ÆüȽ·è¤Î¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ½ñ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡Û
¾¼ÏÂ2ǯ¡Ê1927ǯ¡Ë¤ÎÂ翳±¡È½Îã¤Ï¤Ä¤®¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»¦¿ÍͽÈ÷¤È½Æˤ²ÐÌôÎà¼èÄùË¡»Ü¹Ôµ¬Â§°ãÈ¿¡Ê½¿´ï·ÈÂÓ¡Ë»ö·ï¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤Îͽ¿³Ä´½ñ¤Ë¡Ö¼«Ê¬¤Ï£³²óÅÒÇîºá¤Ë½è¤»¤é¤ì¤¿¤ë¿È¡×¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤ÎµºÜ¤¬¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤ì¤¬Íºá¤Î¾ÚµòÀâÌÀ¤ËµºÜ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤¬ºÎ¾Úˡ§¤ËÈ¿¤¹¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¾å¹ð¤µ¤ì¤¿¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£
¡Ö¸µÍèÁ°²Ê¥Ê¥ë¥â¥Î¥ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÏÁ½¥ÆÈȺá¥Ë°Í¥ê·ºÈ³¥Ë½è¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ê¥È±¾¥Õ²áµî¥Ë±÷¥±¥ëÈï¹ð¿ÍÀ¹Ô¥Î°ìü¥ò¼¨¥¹¥Ë»ß¥Þ¥ê¶¥Î¸å¥ËÀ¸¥·¥¿¥ëÈȺá»ö¼Â¥È¥Ï²¿Åù´Ø¾Ä¥¹¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ë¥«¸Î¥ËÈï¹ð¿Í¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë¥Î»ö¼Â¥«¾ÚÌÀ¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥â¶¥Î»ö¼Â¥Ï¸øÁÊ¥ÎÌÜŪ¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥ÎÀ®Î©¥òÃÇÄꥹ¥ë¥Ë¥ÏŬÅö¥Ê¥é¥µ¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ê¥È¥¹½¾¥Æ»Û¥ëÁ°²Ê¥òºÎ¥ê¥ÆÈȺá»ö¼Â¾ÚÌÀ¥Î»ñÎÁ¥Ë¶¡¥·¥¿¥ê¥È¥»¥ÏºÎ¾Ú¥Îˡ§¥Ë°ãÈ¿¥¹¥ë¥â¥Î¥È±¾¥Ï¥µ¥ë¥òÆÀ¥¹¡×
Â翳±¡¤Ï¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÁ°²Ê¤òºÎÍѤ·¤¿¤³¤È¼«ÂΤò°ãË¡¤ÈÃǤ¸¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤Î»ö°Æ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¾¤Î¾Úµò¤ÇÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤¬¶ñÂÎŪ¾ÜºÙ¤Ë¾ÚÌÀ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢¾ÚµòÀâÌÀ¤ËàìáÓ¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¤·¤Æ¤âȽ·è¤Ë±Æ¶Á¤òµÚ¤Ü¤µ¤Ê¤¤¤È¤·¤Æ¾å¹ð¤ò´þµÑ¤·¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡ÊÂçȽ¾¼2¡¦9¡¦3¿·Ê¹2750-9¡Ë¡£
¤³¤ÎÆó¤Ä¤ÎÀèÎã¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï¸øÁÊ»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Î¾Úµò¤¿¤ê¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤È¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï³ÎΩ¤·¤¿¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¸å¤ÎȽÎã¤Ï¤³¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤¬Â¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òÁ°Äó¤Ë¡¢¤½¤ÎÎã³°¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤«¡½¡½¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤ËÁ°²Ê¤Ï¾ÚµòǽÎϤò»ý¤Ä¤Î¤«¡½¡½¤È¤¤¤¦ÌäÂê¤òÏÀ¤¸¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
Â翳±¡¾¼ÏÂ4ǯ11·î16ÆüȽ·è¡Ê·º½¸8-568¡Ë¤Ï¡ÖÁ°²Ê¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤ê¤âÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î˽ÎÏŪ¤Ê¡ÖÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¡×¤Î¾ÚµòǽÎϤòľÀÜÌäÂê¤È¤·¤¿È½Îã¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ÇÛ²¼¤Î¼Ô¤È¶¦ËŤ·¤Æ¸ø¶¦¹©»ö¤ÎÆþ»¥²ñ¾ì¤Ë¾è¤ê¹þ¤ó¤Ç¡¢Æþ»¥´Ø·¸¼Ô¤Ë¡Ö¼«Ê¬¥Ï¾¨¥Æ·ö²Þ¥·¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥â¥¢¥êËô¿Í¥ò»Â¥ê¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥â¥¢¥ê¾ì¹ç¥Ë°Í¥ê¥Æ¥Ï·Ù»¡¥ò¸þ¥Õ¥Ë²ö¥·¥Æ¥â°ú¥±¥ò¼è¥é¥Ì¡×¤Ê¤É¤È¶¼Ç÷¤·¤Æ¡¢¡ÖÊÛÅöÂå¡×¤Ê¤É¤Î̾ÌܤǶâ°÷¤òÍ׵ᤷ¡¢¡ÖÇ·¥ËØ楻¥µ¥ì¥ÏƱ¿ÍÅù¥Î¿Èñó¥Ë´í³²¥ò²Ã¥Ø¥ó¥È¥¹¥ë¥«Ç¡¥ÂÖÅÙ¥ò¼¨¥·¡×¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤é¤ò°ÚÉݤ»¤·¤á¤Æ¶â°÷¤ò¶²³å¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤¬¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¡Ö¾ï¥ËÇÛ²¼¥òÍÊ¥·¥Æ˽°Ò¥òí÷¥Õ¥·¹©»öÀÁÉéÆþ»¥¾ì¥Ë½ÐÆþ¥·¥Æ¥Ï¶¥Î°ÒÎÏ¥ò°Ê¥ÆÆþ»¥ï𷸿ͥè¥ê¶â°÷¥ò¶¯Í×¥·ÄË¥¯À¤¿Í¥Ë°ÚÉÝ·ù±Þ¥»¥é¥ìµï¥ê¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¡ÖÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¡×¤òͤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òǧÄꤷ¤¿¤¦¤¨¤Ç¡¢¤³¤ì¤ò¤â»²¼à¤·¤Æͺá¤òǧÄꤷ¤¿¤ÈÀâÌÀ¤·¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎòÅù¤ÏÃê¾ÝŪ¤Ê»ö¼Â¤Ë²á¤®¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢·º¤ÎÎÌÄê¤Î»ñÎÁ¤È¤Ê¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤â¡¢À¹Ô·ÐÎò¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¤¤ÆÈȺá»ö¼Â¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÇË´þ¤òµá¤á¤¿¡£
Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢¤Þ¤º¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¤¤ÆÈȺá»ö¼Â¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¸¶Â§¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤ë¡£
¡ÖÈÈ¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ôå´Îò¥ÏÇ·¥Ë°ÍÚ¡¥·¥Æ¶¥Î¼Ô¥ÎÈȺá¹ÔથòǧÄꥹ¥ë¥Î»ñÎÁ¥Èથ¹¥òµö¥¹¥Ø¥¥â¥Î¥Ë¥¢¥é¥¹¡Ä¡ÄÇ·°ì¥Ë¶¥ÎÀ¹Ôå´Îò¥ÈÈȺá¹Ôથȥδ֥˲¿Åù¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë½ê¥Ê¥¥«àª¥Ë³°¥Ê¥é¥µ¥ë¥äÌÞÏÀ¥Ê¥ê¡×
¤³¤¦½Ò¤Ù¤¿¤¦¤¨¤Ç¡¢Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢À¹Ô·ÐÎò¤È¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤¬¡Ö¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¡×¤ÏÊ̤À¤È¤¤¤¦¡£
¡ÖÈÈ¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ôå´Îò¥ÈÈȺá¹Ôથȥ«¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ëºß¥ê¥Æ¥Ï·è¥·¥ÆÚƾå°ìÈÌÉáḀ̈λöÍý¥Ë¹´¥Ï¥ë¥Ø¥¥â¥Î¥Ë¥¢¥é¥¹¥·¥Æ¶¥ÎÈȺá¥È¸ò¾Ä¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¸ÂÅ٥˱÷¥ÆëúÚ¡¥Ë°Í¥êǧÄꥻ¥é¥ë¥ëÀ¹Ôå´Îò¥âÇ·¥òËòáijºÈȺáǧÄê¥Î»ñÎÁ¥Èથ¹¥ò˸¥±¥¹¡×
Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡ÖÈï¹ð¿ÍÅù¥ÎÀ¤´Ö¼þÃΥζ¤Ë½¥Ê¥ëÀ¹Ô¡×¤òÈï³²¼Ô¤Ë¼¨¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦¹Ô°Ù¤¬¶²³å¹Ô°Ù¤Î°ìü¤ò¤Ê¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤«¤é¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¤ÈÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¤È¤¬¡Ö¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¡×¤ËÅö¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢¾å¹ð¤ò´þµÑ¤·¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤ÎȽÎã¤Ï¡¢¸å¤Ë»ØŦ¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¸ÂÄꤻ¤º¤Ë¡¢°ìÈÌŪ¤ËÀ³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎË¡Íý¤òÀë¸À¤·¤¿¤ï¤¬¹ñºÇ½é¤ÎȽÎã¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤ÈƱ»þ¤Ë¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎÎã³°¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢À³Ê¤½¤ì¼«ÂΤ¬ÁÊ°ø¤Î°ìÉô¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÀ³Ê¤¬µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤òÀë¸À¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦ÅÀ¤Ç¤â½ÅÍפǤ¢¤ë¡£
Â翳±¡¤ÎȽÎã¤ÎÃæ¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀ³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÎã³°¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤½¤â¤½¤âÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëͺáǧÄê¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¾å¹ð¤ò´þµÑ¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤â¤¢¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¾¼ÏÂ14ǯ3·î25ÆüȽ·è¡ÊÂ翳±¡È½·èÁ´½¸6-14-43¡Ë¤Ï¡¢°û¼òÃæ¤Ë¸ýÏÀ¤È¤Ê¤ê¡¢¾®Åá¤Ç¹¢¤ò»É¤·¤Æ½Ð·ì»à¤µ¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦½ý³²Ã×»à»ö·ï¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¡¢Î±µÈ¡ÊÈï³²¼Ô¡Ë¤¬¡Öº¡Çϼ¯ÌîϺ³°¥Ø½Ð¥í¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ³°¤Ë½Ð¤¿¸å¤·¤Ð¤é¤¯»Ä¤Ã¤Æ¾ÆÃñ¤ò°û¤ß½ª¤¨¡¢¤â¤¦Î±µÈ¤Ï¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤À¤í¤¦¤È»×¤Ã¤Æ¾®Åá¤ò»ý¤Ã¤Æɽ¤Ë½Ð¤¿¤È¤³¤í¡¢Î±µÈ¤¬Çظ夫¤éÈô¤Ó¤«¤«¤Ã¤ÆÍè¤Æ¡¢¼«Ê¬¤â¤í¤È¤â¤è¤í¤±¤Æ¤½¤ÎºÝ¤Ë¾®Å᤬αµÈ¤Î¹¢¤Ë»É¤µ¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢½ý³²¤ËÅö¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÁè¤Ã¤¿¡£¸¶È½·è¤Ï»ö¼ÂÀâÌÀ¤ÎËÁƬ¤Ë¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÏÛ¨¥Ë¶¥ÎºÊ¥ò²¥ÂÇ»à¥ËÅþ¥é¥·¥á¥¿¥ë°ÙÂçÀµ¶åǯϻ·î½½»ÍÆüÀéÍÕÃÏÊýºÛȽ½ê¥Ë±÷¥Æ½ý³²Ã×»àºá¥Ë°Í¥êĨÌò¸Þǯ¥Ë½è¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥¢¥ê¶¥Î¸å¾¼Ï»Íǯ»°·îÃæȬÆü»Ô¾ì¶èºÛȽ½ê¥Ë±÷¥Æ¶²³å̤¿ëºá¥Ë°Í¥êĨÌòÏ»·î¥Ë¾¼Ï½½°ìǯȬ·î»°ÆüƱºÛȽ½ê¥Ë±÷¥Æ½ý³²ºá¥Ë°Í¥êȳ¶â»Í½½±ß¥Ë³Æ½è¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ëÅù¥ÎÁǹԷÐÎò¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ë¥È¥³¥í¡×¤ÈȽ¼¨¤·¤¿¡£¾å¹ð¿³¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢ÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¡¢¤³¤ÎÀ⼨¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤ÆÇË´þ¤òµá¤á¤¿¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¤³¤³¤Ç¤âÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȺá»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¸¶Â§¤ò¤Þ¤º³Îǧ¤¹¤ë¡£
¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ê¥È±¾¥Õ¥«Ç¡¥»ö¼Â¥Ï¡Ä¡ÄËÜÍ趥θå¥ËÀ¸¥·¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥È²¿Åù¥Î´Ø¾Ä¥Ê¥²áµî¥Î»ö¹à¥Ë°¥¹¥ë¥ò°Ê¥ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë¥Î»ö¼Â¥«¾ÚÌÀ¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥â¶¥Î»ö¼Â¥Ë°Í¥ê¸øÁÊ¥ÎÌÜŪ¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥ÎÀ®Î©¥òÃÇÄꥹ¥ë¥«Ç¡¥¥³¥È¥ÏŬÅö¥ÎÁ¼Ã֥ʥê¥È°Ù¥¹¥òÆÀ¥µ¥ë¥ä¸À¥òÐØ¥¿¥µ¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥ë¡×
¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤ì¤Ë³¤±¤Æ¡¢Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¤òǧÄꤷ¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¡Öñ¥ËÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Î°ìü¥ò½ö¥¹¥ë¡×¤â¤Î¤Ë²á¤®¤º¤Ê¤¤¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¡¢¾å¹ð¤ò´þµÑ¤·¤¿¡£
¡Öñ¥ËÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Î°ìü¥ò½ö¥¹¥ë¥«°ÙÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë»ö¼Â¥òȽ¼¨¥¹¥ë¥«Ç¡¥¥³¥È¥Ï¸Ç¥è¥êË¡¥Î¶Ø»ß¥¹¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ë¥¢¥é¥µ¥ë¥â¥Î¥È±¾¥ï¥µ¥ë¥Ø¥«¥é¥¹¸¶È½·è¥Ë°Í¥ì¥ÏȽ¼¨ÈȺá»ö¼Â¥Ï¶¥Îµó¼¨¥»¥ë¾Úµò¥Ë°Í¥êÍ¥¥Ë¾ÚÌÀ¥µ¥é¥ì¥Æ´ÖÁ³¥¹¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥¯Í£Â¶¥ÎËÁƬ¥Ë±÷¥Æ½êÏÀ¥ÎÇ¡¥¯Èï¹ð¿ÍËô¤¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë¥Î»ö¼Â¥òÀ⼨¥·¥¢¥ë¥âǷñ¥ËƱÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Î°ìü¥ò·Ç¥±¥¿¥ë¥Ë»ß¥Þ¥ê»Û¥ë»ö¼Â¥òºÎ¥Æ°Ê¥ÆȽ¼¨ÈȺá»ö¼ÂǧÄê¥Î°ì»ñÎÁ¥Ë¶¡¥·¥¿¥ë¥â¥Î¥ËÈ󥵥륳¥È¸¶È½Ê¸¥òÄÌÆÉ¥·¥ÆÍÆ°×¥ËÇ·¥òλ²ò¥·ÆÀ¤Ø¥¯¡Ä¡Ä¡£¡×
¸å¤Ë¸¡Æ¤¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢±ÑÊÆ¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡¢Á°²Ê¡Ê¾ºá¾Úµò¡Ë¤Ë¤è¤ëͺáǧÄê¤Î¶Ø»ß¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÎã³°¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢°Õ¿Þ¤ä·×²èÀ¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï»ö¸Î¤äÉԲĹ³ÎϤμçÄ¥¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÈ¿¾Ú¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¡Ê¾ºá¾Úµò¡Ë¤òÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬µö¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¤³¤ÎÎã³°¤òŬÍѤ·¤¿¤È¹Í¤¨¤é¤ì¤ëÂ翳±¡È½Î㤬¤¢¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¾¼ÏÂ15ǯ3·î19ÆüȽ·è¡ÊÂ翳±¡È½·èÁ´½¸7-12-26¡Ë¤¬¤½¤ì¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¡¢»ñ»º²È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤Èµ¶¤Ã¤Æ·ëº§¤Î°Õ»×¤â¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ë·ëº§ÁêÃ̽ê¤òÄ̤¸¤Æ½÷À¤Ë·ëº§¤ò¿½¤·¹þ¤ß¡¢ÊֺѤΰջפâ¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ë¤¢¤ë¤è¤¦¤ËÁõ¤Ã¤Æ¡¢½÷À¤«¤é»ö¶È»ñ¶â¤È¤·¤Æ5000±ß¤òñټ褷¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦º¾µ½¤Î»ö¼Â¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¡¢¶âÁ¬¤ò¼õ¤±¼è¤Ã¤¿»ö¼Â¤Ïǧ¤á¤ë¤¬¡¢º¾µ½¤Î°Õ»×¤òÈÝǧ¤·¡¢·ëº§¤Î°Õ»×¤â¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤·ÊֺѤΰջפ⤢¤Ã¤¿¡¢ñÙ¤·¼è¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤Ï¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤¿¡£¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¤¬¶¡½Ò¤¹¤ëƱ¼ï¤Î·ëº§º¾µ½¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ±çÍѤ·¤¿¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡Ö¼«Ê¬¥ÏÁ½¥ÆÉؽ÷¥è¥ê¶âÉÊ¥òñټ襹¥ë¥³¥ÈÅù¥Ë°Í¥ê¿ô²óÁ°²Ê¥ò½Å¥Í¥¿¥ë¥«¾¼ÏÂÆóǯÅìµþ¹µÁʱ¡¥Ë±÷¥Æ½èʬ¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ëÁ°²Ê¥Ï¼«Ê¬¥«ÄëÂç¥Îʸ³ØÇî»Î¥Ê¥ê¥È±¾¥Ò°¿¥Ï²¸»ò¥Î»þ·×¥òÌã¥Ò¥¿¥ë¥«Ç¡¥¥³¥È¥ò¿½¥·¥Æ·ëº§¥¹¥ë¥È¾Î¥·¸ÞÏ»¿Í¥ÎÉØ¿Í¥è¥ê¶â¥ò´¬¥¾å¥±¥¿¥ë»ö°Æ¥Ê¥ê¼¡¥ÎÁ°²Ê¥Ï°ËƦĹ²¬¥ËžÃÏÀÅÍÜÃæ´Ç¸îÉØ¥ò°ú³Ý¥±¶â¥ò¼è¥ê¥¿¥ë»ö°Æ¼¡¥ÎÁ°²Ê¥Ï´î¿¥¥è¥«¥È°ì½ï¥Ë¥Ê¥ê¥ª¥ëÃ漫ʬ¥«°å³ØÇî»ÎÃÓÅĥȵ¶Ì¾¥·¿ÇÎŽê¥ò³«Àߥ·¼¡¥«¥é¼¡¥Ø¥ÈÂô»³¥ÎÉؿͥȴط¸¥·½÷³Ø¹»¥ÎÀèÀ¸¥ò¥Ê¥·¥¿¥ëÉؿͥȰì½ï¥Ë¥Ê¥ê¶â¥ò´¬¥¾å¥±¥¿¥ë»ö°Æ¥Ê¥ê¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤Î¤Ê¤«¤ÇÂçÀµ7ǯȽ·è¤ò°úÍѤ·¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȺá»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤ÆºÎ¾Úˡ§¤Ë°ãÈ¿¤¹¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Â翳±¡¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÀ⼨¤·¤Æ¤³¤Î¼çÄ¥¤òÂऱ¤¿¡£
¡Ö¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¥ËÁ´Á³¸ò¾Ä¥Ê¥Ã±¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë¥Î¸Î¥ò°Ê¥Æ¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¥òǧÄꥹ¥ë¥³¥È¥ÎÉÔË¡¥Ê¥ë¥ÏÏÀ¥òÐØ¥¿¥µ¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥ê¥ÈêÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Ë¥·¥Æ¶¥ÎÈȹԥÈ̮ά¸ò¾Ä¥¢¥ê¥È²ò¥»¥é¥ë¥ë¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥ÏÈÈ¿Í¥«»Û¥¯¥ÎÇ¡¥À¹Ô·ÐÎò¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ê¥È¾Úµò¥Ë°Í¥ê¥ÆÀ⼨¥·Åö³ºÈȺáǧÄê¥Î»ñÎÁ¥È°Ù¥¹¥Ë¥Ï²¿Åù¥Î˸¥±¥¢¥ë¥³¥È¥Ê¥·Á³¥ê¼©¥·¥Æ¸¶È½·è°úÍѥ˷¸¥ë½êÏÀ»ö¹à¥ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ê¥È¥Î»ö¼Â¨¥Áñ¥Ê¥ë¼õ·º»ö¹à¥Î¥ß¥òºá¾Ú¥Ë¶¡¥·¥¿¥ë¥ËÈó¥¹¥·¥Æ¸¶È½¼¨ÈȹԥË̮ά¸ò¾Ä¥¢¥ê¥Èǧ¥à¥ë¥ËÆñ¥«¥é¥µ¥ëÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Ë´Ø¥¹¥ë¸¶¿³¸øȽÄî¥Ë±÷¥±¥ëÈï¹ð¿Í¥Î¶¡½Ò¥ò°úÍÑ¥·¥¿¥ë¥â¥Î¥Èǧ¥à¥ë¥òÀµÅö¥È¥¹½¾¥Ä¥Æ¸¶È½·è¥Ë¥ÏºÎ¾Ú¾å½êÏÀ¥ÎÇ¡¥°ãˡ¸¥¹¥ë¥³¥È¥Ê¥¯ÏÀ»ÝÍýͳ¥Ê¥·¡×
¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¤âÂ翳±¡¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄ꤬¸¶Â§¤È¤·¤Æ°ãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò³Îǧ¤·¤¿¤¨¤Ç¡¢ËÜ·ï¤ÏÎ㳰Ū¤ËÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëǧÄ꤬µö¤µ¤ì¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¡ÖÈȹԥË̮ά¸ò¾Ä¥¢¥ê¥Èǧ¥à¥ë¥ËÆñ¥«¥é¥µ¥ë¡×¤È¤·¤«ÀâÌÀ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢·ëº§º¾µ½¤ÎÈÈ°Õ¤òÈÝǧ¤·¤Æ·ëº§¤Î¤Ä¤â¤ê¤â¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÊֺѤ¹¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤â¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¼çÄ¥¤¹¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡¢Æ±¼ï¤Î·ëº§º¾µ½¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¤â¤Ã¤ÆÈ¿¾Ú¤·¤ÆÈÈ°Õ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ÏÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ç¤¢¤í¤¦¡£
¸½¹Ô·ºÁÊË¡¤ÏÅÁʹ¾Úµò¤ä¼«Çò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë´ö¤Ä¤«¤ÎÌÀʸµ¬Äê¤òÀߤ±¤¿¤¬¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê³°¤Î¾ÚµòË¡¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ë´Ø¤·¤Æ¤ÏÌÀʸµ¬Äê¤òÀߤ±¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£¤¤¤ï¤æ¤ë´ØÏ¢À¤ÎÄêµÁ¤òÄê¤á¤¿µ¬Äê¤â¤Ê¤¤¤·¡¢´ØÏ¢À¤Î¤Ê¤¤¾Úµò¤òÇÓ½ü¤¹¤ë»Ý¤Îµ¬Äê¤â¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢·ºÁÊË¡295¾ò1¹à¤Îµ¬Äê[3]¤Ê¤É¤òº¬µò¤Ë¡¢¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤âˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ò¾ÚµòǽÎϤÎÍ×·ï¤È¹Í¤¨¤ë¤Î¤¬°ìÈÌŪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë[4]¡£Â翳±¡¤¬Îß¼¡¤ÎȽÎã¤òÄ̤¸¤Æ³ÎΩ¤·¤¿À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¡½¡½¤Ê¤«¤ó¤º¤¯Á°²Ê¡Ê¾ºá¾Úµò¡Ë¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Î¶Ø»ß¤È¤½¤ÎÎã³°¡½¡½¤òºÇ¹âºÛ¤¬Êѹ¹¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£ºÇ¹âºÛ¤¬¤³¤ÎÌäÂê¤ò¼è¤ê¾å¤²¤¿¤Î¤Ï¼¡¤Ë·Ç¤²¤ë2¤Ä¤ÎÀèÎã¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Î¤ß¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¬¡¢ºÇ¹âºÛ¤ÏÂ翳±¡¤Î°ä»º¤ò°ú¤·Ñ¤¤¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
ºÇ½é¤ÎÀèÎã¤Ï¾¼ÏÂ28ǯ¤ÎºÇ¹âºÛȽ·è¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£·Ù»¡´±¤Ç¤¢¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬¡¢ÂáÊᤷ¤¿Èﵿ¼Ô¤ò¼è¤êÄ´¤Ù¤ëºÝ¤Ë¡¢Æ¬È±¤òÄϤó¤Ç°úÄ¥¤ê¡¢¼ê·ý¤Çº¸Ìܤò²¥ÂǤ·¡¢¼£ÎÅ1½µ´Ö¤Î½ý³²¤òÉé¤ï¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦ÆÃÊ̸ø̳°÷˽¹ÔÎ͵ԤÎÁÊ°ø¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Áʾ٤νªÈפˤʤäơ¢¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ë˽¹Ô¤ò²Ã¤¨¤ë½¬Êʤ¬¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤«¤Ä¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¼èÄ´¤Ù¤ò¼õ¤±¤¿¤³¤È¤Î¤¢¤ë¼Ô2¿Í¤ò¾Ú¿Í¿½ÀÁ¤·¤¿¡£ÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¡ÖÎà»÷»ö¼Â¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤ÏºÛȽ½ê¤ËÊи«Ëô¤ÏͽÃǤòÀ¸¤¼¤·¤á¤ë¡×¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ°ÛµÄ¤ò¾§¤¨¤¿¡£ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡Ö¾ð¾õ¤Ë´Ø¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ¹¤ë¡×¤ÈÀë¸À¤·¤Æ¡¢2¿Í¤Î¾Ú¿Í¡Ê¸µÈﵿ¼Ô¡Ë¼è¤êÄ´¤Ù¤¿¡£¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¾Ú¿Í¿ÒÌä¤Ï¼Â¼ÁŪ¤ËÎà»÷»ö¼Â¤Ë¤è¤ë°À³ÊΩ¾Ú¤òµö¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸Ä¿Í¤È¤·¤Æ¤Îº¸·¤òÈȤ·¡¢¤«¤Ä¡¢Í½ÃÇÊ諤òÊú¤¸øÊ¿¤ÊºÛȽ½ê¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤Ã¤¿ºÛȽ´±¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿ºÛȽ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢·ûË¡13¾ò¡¢37¾ò1¹à¤Ë°ãÈ¿¤¹¤ë¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤¿¡£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½êÂè3¾®Ë¡Äî¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¡¢¾å¹ð¤òÂऱ¤¿¡£
¡ÖÂè°ì¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢Åö»ö¼ÔÁÐÊý¤Ë¡¢Í×¾Ú»ö¼Â¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëΩ¾Ú¤ò°ì±þ¿Ô¤µ¤·¤á¤¿¸å¤Ë¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤Î¿½ÀÁ¤Ë¤«¡µ¤ë½êÏÀ¤Î¾Ú¿Í¤ò¡¢¾ð¾õ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤È¤·¤Æ¿ÒÌ䤷¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ä¤Æ¡¢Æ±ºÛȽ½ê¤âÀ⼨¤¹¤ëÇ¡¤¯¡¢¤¤¤ï¤ÐÍ×¾Ú»ö¼Â¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾ÚµòÄ´¤ò½ªÎ»¤·¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë½ôÈ̤ξð¾õ¤òÄ´ºº¤¹¤ë¼ê³¾å¤ÎÃʳ¬¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢±¦¤ÎÇ¡¤¾Ú¿Í¿ÒÌ䤬¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢½êÏÀ¾Ú¿Í¿ÒÌ䤬¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë˽¹Ô¤Î½¬ÊʤΤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òΩ¾Ú¤»¤ó¤È¤¹¤ë¤Ë¤¢¤Ä¤¿¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤ì¤ÏÌÞÏÀËÜ·ï¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Î°Ù¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤¯¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾ð¾õ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Èǧ¤à¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤«¤«¤ë¾Ú¿Í¿ÒÌä¤ò¡¢¤«¤«¤ë¼ê³¾å¤ÎÃʳ¬¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÀ©¸Â¤¹¤Ù¤¤¤¤ï¤ì¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤«¤é¡¢Âè°ì¿³¤Î±¦¤ÎÇ¡¤¸øȽ¼ê³¤Ë½êÏÀ¤ÎÇ¡¤ÁʾÙË¡¤Î°ãÈ¿¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¡ÊºÇ3¾®È½¾¼28¡¦5¡¦12·º½¸7-5-981¡Ë¡£
¤³¤ÎȽ·è¤¬Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ï¸¶Â§¤È¤·¤Æ¶Ø¤¸¤é¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦Â翳±¡°ÊÍè¤ÎË¡Íý¤òÁ°Äó¤È¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤ÏÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ç¤¢¤í¤¦¡£¤½¤Î¤¦¤¨¤Ç¡¢¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¤Ï¤¢¤¯¤Þ¤Ç¤â¡Ö¾ð¾õ¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¾ºá¾Úµò¤ò¼õ¤±Æþ¤ì¤¿¤À¤±¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¶Ø»ß¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ËÄñ¿¨¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
ºÇ¹âºÛÂè3¾®Ë¡Äî¾¼ÏÂ41ǯ11·î22Æü·èÄê¡Ê·º½¸20-9-1035¡Ë¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¡¢¡Ö¿È´ó¤ê¤Î¤Ê¤¤Ï·¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¼Ò²ñÊ¡»ã»ö¶È¤ËÂФ¹¤ë´óÉÕ¶â¡×¤Èµ¶¤Ã¤Æ¡¢´óÉÕ¶â̾²¼¤Ë¸½¶â¤òñټ褷¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦º¾µ½»ö·ï¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¡¢¼Ò²ñÊ¡»ã»ö¶È¤Ë»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¼Ò²ñÊ¡»ãÂ¥¿Ê¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÆüÏ¡Àµ½¡¤ÎÂç¸æËܺÍͤ˵§Ç°¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢¤½¤Î»¿½õ¶â¤òµá¤á¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¼«¸Ê¤Îµ§Ç°¤È¤¤¤¦½¡¶µ³èÆ°¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¤ªÉۻܤòµá¤á¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢µ½æ¨¹Ô°Ù¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÁè¤Ã¤¿¡£¸¶È½·è¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¡ÖËÜ·ï¤ÈƱÍͼêÃʤˤè¤ëº¾µ½ºá¤Ë¤è¤êĨÌò·º¤Ë½è¤»¤é¤ì¸½ºß¤Ê¤ª¼¹¹ÔͱͽÃæ¤Î¿È¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢ËÜ·ïÈȹԤ⤽¤ÎÂÖÍͤ˾Ȥ·º¾µ½ºá¤ò¹½À®¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤Îǧ¼±¤¬¤¢¤Ä¤¿¤È»×¤ï¤ì¤ë¡×¤ÈȽ¼¨¤·¤ÆÂè°ì¿³¤ÎͺáȽ·è¤ò»Ù»ý¤·¤¿¡£¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤Ï¡¢¸¶È½·è¤ÎǧÄê¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȺá»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Â翳±¡¤ÎȽÎã¤Ë°ãÈ¿¤¹¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÇË´þ¤òµá¤á¤¿¡£ºÇ¹âºÛ¤Ï¡¢°úÍѤÎÂ翳±¡È½Îã¤Ï¡Ö»ö°Æ¤ò°Û¤Ë¤·ËÜ·ï¤ËŬÀڤǤʡΤ¤¡Ï¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¾å¹ð¤òÂऱ¤¿¤¬¡¢¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀâÌÀ¤òÉÕ¤±²Ã¤¨¤¿¡£
¡ÖÈȺá¤ÎµÒ´ÑŪÍ×ÁǤ¬Â¾¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ëËÜ·ï»ö°Æ¤Î²¼¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Îº¾µ½¤Î¸Î°Õ¤ÎÇ¡¤ÈȺá¤Î¼ç´ÑŪÍ×ÁǤò¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎƱ¼ïÁ°²Ê¤ÎÆâÍƤˤè¤Ã¤ÆǧÄꤷ¤¿¸¶È½·è¤Ë½êÏÀ¤Î°ãË¡¤Ïǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¡×
¤³¤ÎÀ⼨¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëͺáǧÄê¶Ø»ß¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÎã³°¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢°Õ¿Þ¤ä·×²èÀ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤ò»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬µö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤í¤¦¡£¾¼ÏÂ15ǯȽ·è¡Ê·ëº§º¾µ½»ö·ï¡Ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¤ÏÌÀ³Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢¤½¤Î¼ñ»Ý¤ÏƱ¤¸¤È¤³¤í¤Ë¤¢¤ë¡£
Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤Ï100ǯ¶á¤¯Á°¤«¤é¾ºá¾Úµò¤ä°À³Ê¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Îͺá¤òǧÄꤷ¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¥ë¡¼¥ë¤¬³ÎΩ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¤¬ÌÀʸ¤Îµ¬Äê¤Î¤Ê¤¤¤È¤³¤í¤«¤é¡¢¤½¤Î±ÑÃΤˤè¤Ã¤Æ¤³¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òÃÛ¤¾å¤²¼é¤êÈ´¤¤¤Æ¤¤¿¤³¤È¤Ï¾Î»¿¤ËÃͤ¹¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢½ÐȯÅÀ¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤¿ÂçÀµ7ǯȽ·è¤Î¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤äÎã³°¤òÀë¸À¤·¤¿¤½¤Î¸å¤ÎȽÎã¤ÎÆâÍƤ«¤é¤â¤ï¤«¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¤³¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï±ÑÊƤΥ³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤¬Ä¹Ç¯¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ·ÁÀ®¤·¤Æ¤¤¿À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤ò¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ËÍ¢Æþ¤·ÄêÃ夵¤»¤è¤¦¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµ¿¤¤¤Ê¤¤[5]¡£ËÜ·ï¤Ï¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤¿¤ëÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤ÎǧÄê¤È¤¤¤¦¿·¤·¤¤²ÝÂê¤òºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤ËÄ󶡤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î²ÝÂ꼫ÂΡ¢¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤Î°ìŬÍѾìÌ̤Ǥ¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤³¤³¤Ç¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤ò»²¾È¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ÏÍý¤Ë¤«¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤¬Ä󼨤¹¤ë¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ïº£¸å100ǯ´Ö¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Î·º»öºÛȽ¤ÇŬÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤Ë¤Õ¤µ¤ï¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤Î¾ì¤Î»×¤¤¤Ä¤¤äÊص¹¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òºî¤ë¤Ù¤¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£³Î¤«¤Êº¬µò¤ÈÀâÆÀÎϤΤ¢¤ë¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òÄ󼨤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¿ôɴǯ¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ±Ä¡¹¤È¤·¤Æ¤³¤ÎË¡Íý¤òÃÛ¤¾å¤²¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¿Àè¿Í¤Î±ÑÃΤ˳ؤ֤³¤È¤¬É¬ÍפǤ¢¤ë¡£
¡Ú³¤¯¡Û
¾¼ÏÂ2ǯ¡Ê1927ǯ¡Ë¤ÎÂ翳±¡È½Îã¤Ï¤Ä¤®¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»¦¿ÍͽÈ÷¤È½Æˤ²ÐÌôÎà¼èÄùË¡»Ü¹Ôµ¬Â§°ãÈ¿¡Ê½¿´ï·ÈÂÓ¡Ë»ö·ï¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤Îͽ¿³Ä´½ñ¤Ë¡Ö¼«Ê¬¤Ï£³²óÅÒÇîºá¤Ë½è¤»¤é¤ì¤¿¤ë¿È¡×¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤ÎµºÜ¤¬¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤ì¤¬Íºá¤Î¾ÚµòÀâÌÀ¤ËµºÜ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤¬ºÎ¾Úˡ§¤ËÈ¿¤¹¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¾å¹ð¤µ¤ì¤¿¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£
¡Ö¸µÍèÁ°²Ê¥Ê¥ë¥â¥Î¥ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÏÁ½¥ÆÈȺá¥Ë°Í¥ê·ºÈ³¥Ë½è¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ê¥È±¾¥Õ²áµî¥Ë±÷¥±¥ëÈï¹ð¿ÍÀ¹Ô¥Î°ìü¥ò¼¨¥¹¥Ë»ß¥Þ¥ê¶¥Î¸å¥ËÀ¸¥·¥¿¥ëÈȺá»ö¼Â¥È¥Ï²¿Åù´Ø¾Ä¥¹¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ë¥«¸Î¥ËÈï¹ð¿Í¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë¥Î»ö¼Â¥«¾ÚÌÀ¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥â¶¥Î»ö¼Â¥Ï¸øÁÊ¥ÎÌÜŪ¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥ÎÀ®Î©¥òÃÇÄꥹ¥ë¥Ë¥ÏŬÅö¥Ê¥é¥µ¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ê¥È¥¹½¾¥Æ»Û¥ëÁ°²Ê¥òºÎ¥ê¥ÆÈȺá»ö¼Â¾ÚÌÀ¥Î»ñÎÁ¥Ë¶¡¥·¥¿¥ê¥È¥»¥ÏºÎ¾Ú¥Îˡ§¥Ë°ãÈ¿¥¹¥ë¥â¥Î¥È±¾¥Ï¥µ¥ë¥òÆÀ¥¹¡×
Â翳±¡¤Ï¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÁ°²Ê¤òºÎÍѤ·¤¿¤³¤È¼«ÂΤò°ãË¡¤ÈÃǤ¸¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤Î»ö°Æ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¾¤Î¾Úµò¤ÇÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤¬¶ñÂÎŪ¾ÜºÙ¤Ë¾ÚÌÀ¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢¾ÚµòÀâÌÀ¤ËàìáÓ¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¤·¤Æ¤âȽ·è¤Ë±Æ¶Á¤òµÚ¤Ü¤µ¤Ê¤¤¤È¤·¤Æ¾å¹ð¤ò´þµÑ¤·¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡ÊÂçȽ¾¼2¡¦9¡¦3¿·Ê¹2750-9¡Ë¡£
¤³¤ÎÆó¤Ä¤ÎÀèÎã¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ï¸øÁÊ»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Î¾Úµò¤¿¤ê¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤È¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï³ÎΩ¤·¤¿¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¸å¤ÎȽÎã¤Ï¤³¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤¬Â¸ºß¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òÁ°Äó¤Ë¡¢¤½¤ÎÎã³°¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤«¡½¡½¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤ËÁ°²Ê¤Ï¾ÚµòǽÎϤò»ý¤Ä¤Î¤«¡½¡½¤È¤¤¤¦ÌäÂê¤òÏÀ¤¸¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
Â翳±¡¾¼ÏÂ4ǯ11·î16ÆüȽ·è¡Ê·º½¸8-568¡Ë¤Ï¡ÖÁ°²Ê¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤ê¤âÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î˽ÎÏŪ¤Ê¡ÖÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¡×¤Î¾ÚµòǽÎϤòľÀÜÌäÂê¤È¤·¤¿È½Îã¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ÇÛ²¼¤Î¼Ô¤È¶¦ËŤ·¤Æ¸ø¶¦¹©»ö¤ÎÆþ»¥²ñ¾ì¤Ë¾è¤ê¹þ¤ó¤Ç¡¢Æþ»¥´Ø·¸¼Ô¤Ë¡Ö¼«Ê¬¥Ï¾¨¥Æ·ö²Þ¥·¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥â¥¢¥êËô¿Í¥ò»Â¥ê¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥â¥¢¥ê¾ì¹ç¥Ë°Í¥ê¥Æ¥Ï·Ù»¡¥ò¸þ¥Õ¥Ë²ö¥·¥Æ¥â°ú¥±¥ò¼è¥é¥Ì¡×¤Ê¤É¤È¶¼Ç÷¤·¤Æ¡¢¡ÖÊÛÅöÂå¡×¤Ê¤É¤Î̾ÌܤǶâ°÷¤òÍ׵ᤷ¡¢¡ÖÇ·¥ËØ楻¥µ¥ì¥ÏƱ¿ÍÅù¥Î¿Èñó¥Ë´í³²¥ò²Ã¥Ø¥ó¥È¥¹¥ë¥«Ç¡¥ÂÖÅÙ¥ò¼¨¥·¡×¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤é¤ò°ÚÉݤ»¤·¤á¤Æ¶â°÷¤ò¶²³å¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤¬¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¡Ö¾ï¥ËÇÛ²¼¥òÍÊ¥·¥Æ˽°Ò¥òí÷¥Õ¥·¹©»öÀÁÉéÆþ»¥¾ì¥Ë½ÐÆþ¥·¥Æ¥Ï¶¥Î°ÒÎÏ¥ò°Ê¥ÆÆþ»¥ï𷸿ͥè¥ê¶â°÷¥ò¶¯Í×¥·ÄË¥¯À¤¿Í¥Ë°ÚÉÝ·ù±Þ¥»¥é¥ìµï¥ê¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¡ÖÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¡×¤òͤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òǧÄꤷ¤¿¤¦¤¨¤Ç¡¢¤³¤ì¤ò¤â»²¼à¤·¤Æͺá¤òǧÄꤷ¤¿¤ÈÀâÌÀ¤·¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎòÅù¤ÏÃê¾ÝŪ¤Ê»ö¼Â¤Ë²á¤®¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢·º¤ÎÎÌÄê¤Î»ñÎÁ¤È¤Ê¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤â¡¢À¹Ô·ÐÎò¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¤¤ÆÈȺá»ö¼Â¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÇË´þ¤òµá¤á¤¿¡£
Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢¤Þ¤º¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¤¤ÆÈȺá»ö¼Â¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¸¶Â§¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤ë¡£
¡ÖÈÈ¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ôå´Îò¥ÏÇ·¥Ë°ÍÚ¡¥·¥Æ¶¥Î¼Ô¥ÎÈȺá¹ÔથòǧÄꥹ¥ë¥Î»ñÎÁ¥Èથ¹¥òµö¥¹¥Ø¥¥â¥Î¥Ë¥¢¥é¥¹¡Ä¡ÄÇ·°ì¥Ë¶¥ÎÀ¹Ôå´Îò¥ÈÈȺá¹Ôથȥδ֥˲¿Åù¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë½ê¥Ê¥¥«àª¥Ë³°¥Ê¥é¥µ¥ë¥äÌÞÏÀ¥Ê¥ê¡×
¤³¤¦½Ò¤Ù¤¿¤¦¤¨¤Ç¡¢Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢À¹Ô·ÐÎò¤È¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤¬¡Ö¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¡×¤ÏÊ̤À¤È¤¤¤¦¡£
¡ÖÈÈ¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ôå´Îò¥ÈÈȺá¹Ôથȥ«¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ëºß¥ê¥Æ¥Ï·è¥·¥ÆÚƾå°ìÈÌÉáḀ̈λöÍý¥Ë¹´¥Ï¥ë¥Ø¥¥â¥Î¥Ë¥¢¥é¥¹¥·¥Æ¶¥ÎÈȺá¥È¸ò¾Ä¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¸ÂÅ٥˱÷¥ÆëúÚ¡¥Ë°Í¥êǧÄꥻ¥é¥ë¥ëÀ¹Ôå´Îò¥âÇ·¥òËòáijºÈȺáǧÄê¥Î»ñÎÁ¥Èથ¹¥ò˸¥±¥¹¡×
Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡ÖÈï¹ð¿ÍÅù¥ÎÀ¤´Ö¼þÃΥζ¤Ë½¥Ê¥ëÀ¹Ô¡×¤òÈï³²¼Ô¤Ë¼¨¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦¹Ô°Ù¤¬¶²³å¹Ô°Ù¤Î°ìü¤ò¤Ê¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤«¤é¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¤ÈÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¤È¤¬¡Ö¸ò¾Ä¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¡×¤ËÅö¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢¾å¹ð¤ò´þµÑ¤·¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤ÎȽÎã¤Ï¡¢¸å¤Ë»ØŦ¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¸ÂÄꤻ¤º¤Ë¡¢°ìÈÌŪ¤ËÀ³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎË¡Íý¤òÀë¸À¤·¤¿¤ï¤¬¹ñºÇ½é¤ÎȽÎã¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤ì¤ÈƱ»þ¤Ë¡¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎÎã³°¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢À³Ê¤½¤ì¼«ÂΤ¬ÁÊ°ø¤Î°ìÉô¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÀ³Ê¤¬µöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤òÀë¸À¤·¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦ÅÀ¤Ç¤â½ÅÍפǤ¢¤ë¡£
Â翳±¡¤ÎȽÎã¤ÎÃæ¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀ³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÎã³°¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¤½¤â¤½¤âÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëͺáǧÄê¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¾å¹ð¤ò´þµÑ¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤â¤¢¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¾¼ÏÂ14ǯ3·î25ÆüȽ·è¡ÊÂ翳±¡È½·èÁ´½¸6-14-43¡Ë¤Ï¡¢°û¼òÃæ¤Ë¸ýÏÀ¤È¤Ê¤ê¡¢¾®Åá¤Ç¹¢¤ò»É¤·¤Æ½Ð·ì»à¤µ¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦½ý³²Ã×»à»ö·ï¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¡¢Î±µÈ¡ÊÈï³²¼Ô¡Ë¤¬¡Öº¡Çϼ¯ÌîϺ³°¥Ø½Ð¥í¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ³°¤Ë½Ð¤¿¸å¤·¤Ð¤é¤¯»Ä¤Ã¤Æ¾ÆÃñ¤ò°û¤ß½ª¤¨¡¢¤â¤¦Î±µÈ¤Ï¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤À¤í¤¦¤È»×¤Ã¤Æ¾®Åá¤ò»ý¤Ã¤Æɽ¤Ë½Ð¤¿¤È¤³¤í¡¢Î±µÈ¤¬Çظ夫¤éÈô¤Ó¤«¤«¤Ã¤ÆÍè¤Æ¡¢¼«Ê¬¤â¤í¤È¤â¤è¤í¤±¤Æ¤½¤ÎºÝ¤Ë¾®Å᤬αµÈ¤Î¹¢¤Ë»É¤µ¤Ã¤Æ¤·¤Þ¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢½ý³²¤ËÅö¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÁè¤Ã¤¿¡£¸¶È½·è¤Ï»ö¼ÂÀâÌÀ¤ÎËÁƬ¤Ë¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÏÛ¨¥Ë¶¥ÎºÊ¥ò²¥ÂÇ»à¥ËÅþ¥é¥·¥á¥¿¥ë°ÙÂçÀµ¶åǯϻ·î½½»ÍÆüÀéÍÕÃÏÊýºÛȽ½ê¥Ë±÷¥Æ½ý³²Ã×»àºá¥Ë°Í¥êĨÌò¸Þǯ¥Ë½è¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ë¥³¥È¥¢¥ê¶¥Î¸å¾¼Ï»Íǯ»°·îÃæȬÆü»Ô¾ì¶èºÛȽ½ê¥Ë±÷¥Æ¶²³å̤¿ëºá¥Ë°Í¥êĨÌòÏ»·î¥Ë¾¼Ï½½°ìǯȬ·î»°ÆüƱºÛȽ½ê¥Ë±÷¥Æ½ý³²ºá¥Ë°Í¥êȳ¶â»Í½½±ß¥Ë³Æ½è¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ëÅù¥ÎÁǹԷÐÎò¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ë¥È¥³¥í¡×¤ÈȽ¼¨¤·¤¿¡£¾å¹ð¿³¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢ÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¡¢¤³¤ÎÀ⼨¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤ÆÇË´þ¤òµá¤á¤¿¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¤³¤³¤Ç¤âÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȺá»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¸¶Â§¤ò¤Þ¤º³Îǧ¤¹¤ë¡£
¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ê¥È±¾¥Õ¥«Ç¡¥»ö¼Â¥Ï¡Ä¡ÄËÜÍ趥θå¥ËÀ¸¥·¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥È²¿Åù¥Î´Ø¾Ä¥Ê¥²áµî¥Î»ö¹à¥Ë°¥¹¥ë¥ò°Ê¥ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë¥Î»ö¼Â¥«¾ÚÌÀ¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥â¶¥Î»ö¼Â¥Ë°Í¥ê¸øÁÊ¥ÎÌÜŪ¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥ÎÀ®Î©¥òÃÇÄꥹ¥ë¥«Ç¡¥¥³¥È¥ÏŬÅö¥ÎÁ¼Ã֥ʥê¥È°Ù¥¹¥òÆÀ¥µ¥ë¥ä¸À¥òÐØ¥¿¥µ¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥ë¡×
¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤ì¤Ë³¤±¤Æ¡¢Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¤òǧÄꤷ¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¡Öñ¥ËÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Î°ìü¥ò½ö¥¹¥ë¡×¤â¤Î¤Ë²á¤®¤º¤Ê¤¤¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¡¢¾å¹ð¤ò´þµÑ¤·¤¿¡£
¡Öñ¥ËÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Î°ìü¥ò½ö¥¹¥ë¥«°ÙÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë»ö¼Â¥òȽ¼¨¥¹¥ë¥«Ç¡¥¥³¥È¥Ï¸Ç¥è¥êË¡¥Î¶Ø»ß¥¹¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ë¥¢¥é¥µ¥ë¥â¥Î¥È±¾¥ï¥µ¥ë¥Ø¥«¥é¥¹¸¶È½·è¥Ë°Í¥ì¥ÏȽ¼¨ÈȺá»ö¼Â¥Ï¶¥Îµó¼¨¥»¥ë¾Úµò¥Ë°Í¥êÍ¥¥Ë¾ÚÌÀ¥µ¥é¥ì¥Æ´ÖÁ³¥¹¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥¯Í£Â¶¥ÎËÁƬ¥Ë±÷¥Æ½êÏÀ¥ÎÇ¡¥¯Èï¹ð¿ÍËô¤¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë¥Î»ö¼Â¥òÀ⼨¥·¥¢¥ë¥âǷñ¥ËƱÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Î°ìü¥ò·Ç¥±¥¿¥ë¥Ë»ß¥Þ¥ê»Û¥ë»ö¼Â¥òºÎ¥Æ°Ê¥ÆȽ¼¨ÈȺá»ö¼ÂǧÄê¥Î°ì»ñÎÁ¥Ë¶¡¥·¥¿¥ë¥â¥Î¥ËÈ󥵥륳¥È¸¶È½Ê¸¥òÄÌÆÉ¥·¥ÆÍÆ°×¥ËÇ·¥òλ²ò¥·ÆÀ¤Ø¥¯¡Ä¡Ä¡£¡×
¸å¤Ë¸¡Æ¤¤¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢±ÑÊÆ¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤Ë¤è¤ì¤Ð¡¢Á°²Ê¡Ê¾ºá¾Úµò¡Ë¤Ë¤è¤ëͺáǧÄê¤Î¶Ø»ß¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÎã³°¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢°Õ¿Þ¤ä·×²èÀ¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï»ö¸Î¤äÉԲĹ³ÎϤμçÄ¥¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÈ¿¾Ú¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¡Ê¾ºá¾Úµò¡Ë¤òÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬µö¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¤³¤ÎÎã³°¤òŬÍѤ·¤¿¤È¹Í¤¨¤é¤ì¤ëÂ翳±¡È½Î㤬¤¢¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¾¼ÏÂ15ǯ3·î19ÆüȽ·è¡ÊÂ翳±¡È½·èÁ´½¸7-12-26¡Ë¤¬¤½¤ì¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¡¢»ñ»º²È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤Èµ¶¤Ã¤Æ·ëº§¤Î°Õ»×¤â¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ë·ëº§ÁêÃ̽ê¤òÄ̤¸¤Æ½÷À¤Ë·ëº§¤ò¿½¤·¹þ¤ß¡¢ÊֺѤΰջפâ¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ë¤¢¤ë¤è¤¦¤ËÁõ¤Ã¤Æ¡¢½÷À¤«¤é»ö¶È»ñ¶â¤È¤·¤Æ5000±ß¤òñټ褷¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦º¾µ½¤Î»ö¼Â¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¡¢¶âÁ¬¤ò¼õ¤±¼è¤Ã¤¿»ö¼Â¤Ïǧ¤á¤ë¤¬¡¢º¾µ½¤Î°Õ»×¤òÈÝǧ¤·¡¢·ëº§¤Î°Õ»×¤â¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤·ÊֺѤΰջפ⤢¤Ã¤¿¡¢ñÙ¤·¼è¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤Ï¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤¿¡£¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¤¬¶¡½Ò¤¹¤ëƱ¼ï¤Î·ëº§º¾µ½¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ±çÍѤ·¤¿¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡Ö¼«Ê¬¥ÏÁ½¥ÆÉؽ÷¥è¥ê¶âÉÊ¥òñټ襹¥ë¥³¥ÈÅù¥Ë°Í¥ê¿ô²óÁ°²Ê¥ò½Å¥Í¥¿¥ë¥«¾¼ÏÂÆóǯÅìµþ¹µÁʱ¡¥Ë±÷¥Æ½èʬ¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ëÁ°²Ê¥Ï¼«Ê¬¥«ÄëÂç¥Îʸ³ØÇî»Î¥Ê¥ê¥È±¾¥Ò°¿¥Ï²¸»ò¥Î»þ·×¥òÌã¥Ò¥¿¥ë¥«Ç¡¥¥³¥È¥ò¿½¥·¥Æ·ëº§¥¹¥ë¥È¾Î¥·¸ÞÏ»¿Í¥ÎÉØ¿Í¥è¥ê¶â¥ò´¬¥¾å¥±¥¿¥ë»ö°Æ¥Ê¥ê¼¡¥ÎÁ°²Ê¥Ï°ËƦĹ²¬¥ËžÃÏÀÅÍÜÃæ´Ç¸îÉØ¥ò°ú³Ý¥±¶â¥ò¼è¥ê¥¿¥ë»ö°Æ¼¡¥ÎÁ°²Ê¥Ï´î¿¥¥è¥«¥È°ì½ï¥Ë¥Ê¥ê¥ª¥ëÃ漫ʬ¥«°å³ØÇî»ÎÃÓÅĥȵ¶Ì¾¥·¿ÇÎŽê¥ò³«Àߥ·¼¡¥«¥é¼¡¥Ø¥ÈÂô»³¥ÎÉؿͥȴط¸¥·½÷³Ø¹»¥ÎÀèÀ¸¥ò¥Ê¥·¥¿¥ëÉؿͥȰì½ï¥Ë¥Ê¥ê¶â¥ò´¬¥¾å¥±¥¿¥ë»ö°Æ¥Ê¥ê¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤Î¤Ê¤«¤ÇÂçÀµ7ǯȽ·è¤ò°úÍѤ·¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȺá»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤ÆºÎ¾Úˡ§¤Ë°ãÈ¿¤¹¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Â翳±¡¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ËÀ⼨¤·¤Æ¤³¤Î¼çÄ¥¤òÂऱ¤¿¡£
¡Ö¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¥ËÁ´Á³¸ò¾Ä¥Ê¥Ã±¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ë¥Î¸Î¥ò°Ê¥Æ¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¥òǧÄꥹ¥ë¥³¥È¥ÎÉÔË¡¥Ê¥ë¥ÏÏÀ¥òÐØ¥¿¥µ¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥ê¥ÈêÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Ë¥·¥Æ¶¥ÎÈȹԥÈ̮ά¸ò¾Ä¥¢¥ê¥È²ò¥»¥é¥ë¥ë¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥ÏÈÈ¿Í¥«»Û¥¯¥ÎÇ¡¥À¹Ô·ÐÎò¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ê¥È¾Úµò¥Ë°Í¥ê¥ÆÀ⼨¥·Åö³ºÈȺáǧÄê¥Î»ñÎÁ¥È°Ù¥¹¥Ë¥Ï²¿Åù¥Î˸¥±¥¢¥ë¥³¥È¥Ê¥·Á³¥ê¼©¥·¥Æ¸¶È½·è°úÍѥ˷¸¥ë½êÏÀ»ö¹à¥ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¥ËÁ°²Ê¥¢¥ê¥È¥Î»ö¼Â¨¥Áñ¥Ê¥ë¼õ·º»ö¹à¥Î¥ß¥òºá¾Ú¥Ë¶¡¥·¥¿¥ë¥ËÈó¥¹¥·¥Æ¸¶È½¼¨ÈȹԥË̮ά¸ò¾Ä¥¢¥ê¥Èǧ¥à¥ë¥ËÆñ¥«¥é¥µ¥ëÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÀ¹Ô·ÐÎò¥Ë´Ø¥¹¥ë¸¶¿³¸øȽÄî¥Ë±÷¥±¥ëÈï¹ð¿Í¥Î¶¡½Ò¥ò°úÍÑ¥·¥¿¥ë¥â¥Î¥Èǧ¥à¥ë¥òÀµÅö¥È¥¹½¾¥Ä¥Æ¸¶È½·è¥Ë¥ÏºÎ¾Ú¾å½êÏÀ¥ÎÇ¡¥°ãˡ¸¥¹¥ë¥³¥È¥Ê¥¯ÏÀ»ÝÍýͳ¥Ê¥·¡×
¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¤âÂ翳±¡¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄ꤬¸¶Â§¤È¤·¤Æ°ãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò³Îǧ¤·¤¿¤¨¤Ç¡¢ËÜ·ï¤ÏÎ㳰Ū¤ËÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëǧÄ꤬µö¤µ¤ì¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¡ÖÈȹԥË̮ά¸ò¾Ä¥¢¥ê¥Èǧ¥à¥ë¥ËÆñ¥«¥é¥µ¥ë¡×¤È¤·¤«ÀâÌÀ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢·ëº§º¾µ½¤ÎÈÈ°Õ¤òÈÝǧ¤·¤Æ·ëº§¤Î¤Ä¤â¤ê¤â¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÊֺѤ¹¤ë¤Ä¤â¤ê¤â¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¼çÄ¥¤¹¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ·¤Æ¡¢Æ±¼ï¤Î·ëº§º¾µ½¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ò¤â¤Ã¤ÆÈ¿¾Ú¤·¤ÆÈÈ°Õ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ÏÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ç¤¢¤í¤¦¡£
¸½¹Ô·ºÁÊË¡¤ÏÅÁʹ¾Úµò¤ä¼«Çò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë´ö¤Ä¤«¤ÎÌÀʸµ¬Äê¤òÀߤ±¤¿¤¬¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê³°¤Î¾ÚµòË¡¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ë´Ø¤·¤Æ¤ÏÌÀʸµ¬Äê¤òÀߤ±¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£¤¤¤ï¤æ¤ë´ØÏ¢À¤ÎÄêµÁ¤òÄê¤á¤¿µ¬Äê¤â¤Ê¤¤¤·¡¢´ØÏ¢À¤Î¤Ê¤¤¾Úµò¤òÇÓ½ü¤¹¤ë»Ý¤Îµ¬Äê¤â¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢·ºÁÊË¡295¾ò1¹à¤Îµ¬Äê[3]¤Ê¤É¤òº¬µò¤Ë¡¢¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤âˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ò¾ÚµòǽÎϤÎÍ×·ï¤È¹Í¤¨¤ë¤Î¤¬°ìÈÌŪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë[4]¡£Â翳±¡¤¬Îß¼¡¤ÎȽÎã¤òÄ̤¸¤Æ³ÎΩ¤·¤¿À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¡½¡½¤Ê¤«¤ó¤º¤¯Á°²Ê¡Ê¾ºá¾Úµò¡Ë¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Î¶Ø»ß¤È¤½¤ÎÎã³°¡½¡½¤òºÇ¹âºÛ¤¬Êѹ¹¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£ºÇ¹âºÛ¤¬¤³¤ÎÌäÂê¤ò¼è¤ê¾å¤²¤¿¤Î¤Ï¼¡¤Ë·Ç¤²¤ë2¤Ä¤ÎÀèÎã¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Î¤ß¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤¬¡¢ºÇ¹âºÛ¤ÏÂ翳±¡¤Î°ä»º¤ò°ú¤·Ñ¤¤¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
ºÇ½é¤ÎÀèÎã¤Ï¾¼ÏÂ28ǯ¤ÎºÇ¹âºÛȽ·è¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£·Ù»¡´±¤Ç¤¢¤ëÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬¡¢ÂáÊᤷ¤¿Èﵿ¼Ô¤ò¼è¤êÄ´¤Ù¤ëºÝ¤Ë¡¢Æ¬È±¤òÄϤó¤Ç°úÄ¥¤ê¡¢¼ê·ý¤Çº¸Ìܤò²¥ÂǤ·¡¢¼£ÎÅ1½µ´Ö¤Î½ý³²¤òÉé¤ï¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦ÆÃÊ̸ø̳°÷˽¹ÔÎ͵ԤÎÁÊ°ø¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Áʾ٤νªÈפˤʤäơ¢¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤Ë˽¹Ô¤ò²Ã¤¨¤ë½¬Êʤ¬¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤«¤Ä¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¼èÄ´¤Ù¤ò¼õ¤±¤¿¤³¤È¤Î¤¢¤ë¼Ô2¿Í¤ò¾Ú¿Í¿½ÀÁ¤·¤¿¡£ÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¡ÖÎà»÷»ö¼Â¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤ÏºÛȽ½ê¤ËÊи«Ëô¤ÏͽÃǤòÀ¸¤¼¤·¤á¤ë¡×¤È½Ò¤Ù¤Æ°ÛµÄ¤ò¾§¤¨¤¿¡£ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡Ö¾ð¾õ¤Ë´Ø¤·¤Æ¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ¹¤ë¡×¤ÈÀë¸À¤·¤Æ¡¢2¿Í¤Î¾Ú¿Í¡Ê¸µÈﵿ¼Ô¡Ë¼è¤êÄ´¤Ù¤¿¡£¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¾Ú¿Í¿ÒÌä¤Ï¼Â¼ÁŪ¤ËÎà»÷»ö¼Â¤Ë¤è¤ë°À³ÊΩ¾Ú¤òµö¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸Ä¿Í¤È¤·¤Æ¤Îº¸·¤òÈȤ·¡¢¤«¤Ä¡¢Í½ÃÇÊ諤òÊú¤¸øÊ¿¤ÊºÛȽ½ê¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤Ã¤¿ºÛȽ´±¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿ºÛȽ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢·ûË¡13¾ò¡¢37¾ò1¹à¤Ë°ãÈ¿¤¹¤ë¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤¿¡£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½êÂè3¾®Ë¡Äî¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¡¢¾å¹ð¤òÂऱ¤¿¡£
¡ÖÂè°ì¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢Åö»ö¼ÔÁÐÊý¤Ë¡¢Í×¾Ú»ö¼Â¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëΩ¾Ú¤ò°ì±þ¿Ô¤µ¤·¤á¤¿¸å¤Ë¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤Î¿½ÀÁ¤Ë¤«¡µ¤ë½êÏÀ¤Î¾Ú¿Í¤ò¡¢¾ð¾õ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤È¤·¤Æ¿ÒÌ䤷¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ä¤Æ¡¢Æ±ºÛȽ½ê¤âÀ⼨¤¹¤ëÇ¡¤¯¡¢¤¤¤ï¤ÐÍ×¾Ú»ö¼Â¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾ÚµòÄ´¤ò½ªÎ»¤·¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë½ôÈ̤ξð¾õ¤òÄ´ºº¤¹¤ë¼ê³¾å¤ÎÃʳ¬¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢±¦¤ÎÇ¡¤¾Ú¿Í¿ÒÌ䤬¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢½êÏÀ¾Ú¿Í¿ÒÌ䤬¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë˽¹Ô¤Î½¬ÊʤΤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òΩ¾Ú¤»¤ó¤È¤¹¤ë¤Ë¤¢¤Ä¤¿¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤ì¤ÏÌÞÏÀËÜ·ï¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Î°Ù¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤¯¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾ð¾õ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Èǧ¤à¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤«¤«¤ë¾Ú¿Í¿ÒÌä¤ò¡¢¤«¤«¤ë¼ê³¾å¤ÎÃʳ¬¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÀ©¸Â¤¹¤Ù¤¤¤¤ï¤ì¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤«¤é¡¢Âè°ì¿³¤Î±¦¤ÎÇ¡¤¸øȽ¼ê³¤Ë½êÏÀ¤ÎÇ¡¤ÁʾÙË¡¤Î°ãÈ¿¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡×¡ÊºÇ3¾®È½¾¼28¡¦5¡¦12·º½¸7-5-981¡Ë¡£
¤³¤ÎȽ·è¤¬Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ï¸¶Â§¤È¤·¤Æ¶Ø¤¸¤é¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦Â翳±¡°ÊÍè¤ÎË¡Íý¤òÁ°Äó¤È¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤ÏÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ç¤¢¤í¤¦¡£¤½¤Î¤¦¤¨¤Ç¡¢¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¤Ï¤¢¤¯¤Þ¤Ç¤â¡Ö¾ð¾õ¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¾ºá¾Úµò¤ò¼õ¤±Æþ¤ì¤¿¤À¤±¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¶Ø»ß¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ËÄñ¿¨¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
ºÇ¹âºÛÂè3¾®Ë¡Äî¾¼ÏÂ41ǯ11·î22Æü·èÄê¡Ê·º½¸20-9-1035¡Ë¤Ï¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¡¢¡Ö¿È´ó¤ê¤Î¤Ê¤¤Ï·¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¼Ò²ñÊ¡»ã»ö¶È¤ËÂФ¹¤ë´óÉÕ¶â¡×¤Èµ¶¤Ã¤Æ¡¢´óÉÕ¶â̾²¼¤Ë¸½¶â¤òñټ褷¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦º¾µ½»ö·ï¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï¡¢¼Ò²ñÊ¡»ã»ö¶È¤Ë»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢¼Ò²ñÊ¡»ãÂ¥¿Ê¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÆüÏ¡Àµ½¡¤ÎÂç¸æËܺÍͤ˵§Ç°¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢¤½¤Î»¿½õ¶â¤òµá¤á¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¼«¸Ê¤Îµ§Ç°¤È¤¤¤¦½¡¶µ³èÆ°¤ËÂФ¹¤ë¤ªÉۻܤòµá¤á¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢µ½æ¨¹Ô°Ù¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÁè¤Ã¤¿¡£¸¶È½·è¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¼«¿È¡ÖËÜ·ï¤ÈƱÍͼêÃʤˤè¤ëº¾µ½ºá¤Ë¤è¤êĨÌò·º¤Ë½è¤»¤é¤ì¸½ºß¤Ê¤ª¼¹¹ÔͱͽÃæ¤Î¿È¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢ËÜ·ïÈȹԤ⤽¤ÎÂÖÍͤ˾Ȥ·º¾µ½ºá¤ò¹½À®¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤Îǧ¼±¤¬¤¢¤Ä¤¿¤È»×¤ï¤ì¤ë¡×¤ÈȽ¼¨¤·¤ÆÂè°ì¿³¤ÎͺáȽ·è¤ò»Ù»ý¤·¤¿¡£¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤Ï¡¢¸¶È½·è¤ÎǧÄê¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈȺá»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Â翳±¡¤ÎȽÎã¤Ë°ãÈ¿¤¹¤ë¤È¸À¤Ã¤ÆÇË´þ¤òµá¤á¤¿¡£ºÇ¹âºÛ¤Ï¡¢°úÍѤÎÂ翳±¡È½Îã¤Ï¡Ö»ö°Æ¤ò°Û¤Ë¤·ËÜ·ï¤ËŬÀڤǤʡΤ¤¡Ï¡×¤È¸À¤Ã¤Æ¾å¹ð¤òÂऱ¤¿¤¬¡¢¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÀâÌÀ¤òÉÕ¤±²Ã¤¨¤¿¡£
¡ÖÈȺá¤ÎµÒ´ÑŪÍ×ÁǤ¬Â¾¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ëËÜ·ï»ö°Æ¤Î²¼¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Îº¾µ½¤Î¸Î°Õ¤ÎÇ¡¤ÈȺá¤Î¼ç´ÑŪÍ×ÁǤò¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎƱ¼ïÁ°²Ê¤ÎÆâÍƤˤè¤Ã¤ÆǧÄꤷ¤¿¸¶È½·è¤Ë½êÏÀ¤Î°ãË¡¤Ïǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¡×
¤³¤ÎÀ⼨¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëͺáǧÄê¶Ø»ß¤ËÂФ¹¤ëÎã³°¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢°Õ¿Þ¤ä·×²èÀ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤ò»ÈÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬µö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤ò»ØŦ¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤í¤¦¡£¾¼ÏÂ15ǯȽ·è¡Ê·ëº§º¾µ½»ö·ï¡Ë¤Û¤É¤Ë¤ÏÌÀ³Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢¤½¤Î¼ñ»Ý¤ÏƱ¤¸¤È¤³¤í¤Ë¤¢¤ë¡£
Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤Ï100ǯ¶á¤¯Á°¤«¤é¾ºá¾Úµò¤ä°À³Ê¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Îͺá¤òǧÄꤷ¤Æ¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¥ë¡¼¥ë¤¬³ÎΩ¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Â翳±¡¤¬ÌÀʸ¤Îµ¬Äê¤Î¤Ê¤¤¤È¤³¤í¤«¤é¡¢¤½¤Î±ÑÃΤˤè¤Ã¤Æ¤³¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òÃÛ¤¾å¤²¼é¤êÈ´¤¤¤Æ¤¤¿¤³¤È¤Ï¾Î»¿¤ËÃͤ¹¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢½ÐȯÅÀ¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤¿ÂçÀµ7ǯȽ·è¤Î¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤äÎã³°¤òÀë¸À¤·¤¿¤½¤Î¸å¤ÎȽÎã¤ÎÆâÍƤ«¤é¤â¤ï¤«¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¤³¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï±ÑÊƤΥ³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤¬Ä¹Ç¯¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ·ÁÀ®¤·¤Æ¤¤¿À³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤ò¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤ËÍ¢Æþ¤·ÄêÃ夵¤»¤è¤¦¤È¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµ¿¤¤¤Ê¤¤[5]¡£ËÜ·ï¤Ï¡¢Â¾ºá¾Úµò¤¿¤ëÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤ÎǧÄê¤È¤¤¤¦¿·¤·¤¤²ÝÂê¤òºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤ËÄ󶡤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î²ÝÂ꼫ÂΡ¢¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤Î°ìŬÍѾìÌ̤Ǥ¢¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤³¤³¤Ç¥³¥â¥ó¥í¡¼¤ÎÀ³Ê¾Úµò¤ÎË¡Íý¤ò»²¾È¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ÏÍý¤Ë¤«¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤¬Ä󼨤¹¤ë¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ïº£¸å100ǯ´Ö¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Î·º»öºÛȽ¤ÇŬÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤Ë¤Õ¤µ¤ï¤·¤¤¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤Î¾ì¤Î»×¤¤¤Ä¤¤äÊص¹¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òºî¤ë¤Ù¤¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£³Î¤«¤Êº¬µò¤ÈÀâÆÀÎϤΤ¢¤ë¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òÄ󼨤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¿ôɴǯ¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ±Ä¡¹¤È¤·¤Æ¤³¤ÎË¡Íý¤òÃÛ¤¾å¤²¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¿Àè¿Í¤Î±ÑÃΤ˳ؤ֤³¤È¤¬É¬ÍפǤ¢¤ë¡£
¡Ú³¤¯¡Û
¡ÎÉ®¼ÔÃí¡§¤³¤ì¤ÏºÇ¹âºÛȽ½êÂè2¾®Ë¡ÄîÊ¿À®24ǯ9·î7ÆüȽ·è¤Î¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ½ñ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡Ï
Ê¿À®21ǯ9·î8Æü¸áÁ°11»þ50ʬ¤³¤í¡¢ÅìµþÅÔ³ë¾þ¶è¶âÄ®¤Î½»ÂðÃϤˤ¢¤ëÌÚ¤2³¬·ú¤Æ¥¢¥Ñ¡¼¥È¡Ö¸åÆ£Áñ¡×£±³¬101¹æ¼¼¶â»Ò¥è¥·¥¨Êý¤«¤é±ì¤¬½Ð¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤ò¶á½ê¤Î½»Ì±¤¬È¯¸«¤·¡¢119ÈÖÄÌÊó¤·¤¿¡£¿ôʬ¸å¤Ë¶î¤±ÉÕ¤±¤¿¾ÃËÉÃÄ°÷¤¬¾Ã²Ð´ï¤ÇÄòФ·¤¿¡£µï´Ö¤ÎÃæ±ûÉô¤Î¥«¡¼¥Ú¥Ã¥ÈÉÕ¶á¤Î¾²Ìó1.1Ê¿Êý¥á¡¼¥È¥ë¤¬¾Æ¤±¤¿¡£¤½¤³¤Ë¤ÏÀÐÌý¥¹¥È¡¼¥Ö¤ÎµëÌý¥«¡¼¥È¥ê¥Ã¥¸¤¬ÊüÃÖ¤µ¤ì¡¢¾Æ¤±¤¿¾²¤«¤éÅôÌý¤ÎÀ®Ê¬¤¬¸¡½Ð¤µ¤ì¤¿¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢Âæ½ê¤Î¿©´ïê¤ËÊݴɤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤¿¥«¥Ã¥×Ìͤ¬¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ê¡¢¥È¥¤¥ì¤Î꤫¤é¥«¥Ã¥×Ìͤζõ¤ÎÍƴ郎ȯ¸«¤µ¤ì¤¿¡£¤´¤ßÆþ¤ì¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ·¤Æ¤¤¤¿Âæ½ê¤Î»æÂÞ¤«¤é¤Ï»ÈÍѺѤߤγä¤ê¤Ð¤·¤¬¸«¤Ä¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£¿²¼¼¤Î¥Ü¥Ã¥¯¥¹¤Ë¾è¤»¤Æ¤ª¤¤¤¿500±ß¶Ì2¤Ä¤¬¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤¬¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê³°¤ËÅð¤Þ¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ï²¿¤â¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£
Èï¹ð¿ÍOK»á¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î2½µ´Ö¸å9·î21Æü¤ËÊÌ·ï¤ÎÀàÅðÍƵ¿¤ÇÂáÊᤵ¤ì¡¢°Ê¸å¿¿ô¤Î;ºá¤ò¹ðÇò¤¹¤ë¾å¿½½ñ¤ò·Ù»¡¤ËÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¸åÆ£Áñ¤ÎÀàÅð¤äÊü²Ð¤ò¹ðÇò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¡£O»á¤Ï12·î18ÆüÀàÅð»ö·ï¤Ë¤è¤êͺáȽ·è¤ò¼õ¤±¤¿¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢Ê¿À®22ǯ1·î12Æü¤Ë·Ù»¡¤ËDNA¥µ¥ó¥×¥ë¤òÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¤È¤³¤í¡¢¸åÆ£Áñ¤Çȯ¸«¤µ¤ì¤¿¥«¥Ã¥×ÌÍÍÆ´ï¤ä³ä¤ê¤Ð¤·¤«¤é¸¡½Ð¤µ¤ì¤¿DNA·¿¤È°ìÃפ·¤¿¡£2·î16ÆüO»á¤Ï½»µï¿¯Æþ¡¢ÀàÅðµÚ¤Ó¸½½»·ú¤ʪÊü²Ð¤ÎÍƵ¿¤ÇºÆÂáÊᤵ¤ì¤¿¡£O»á¤Ï¶â»ÒÊý¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤Æ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤È¥«¥Ã¥×ÌͤòÅð¤ó¤À¤³¤È¤òǧ¤á¤¿¤â¤Î¤Î¡¢ÅöÆü¸áÁ°7»þÂæ¤Ë¤Ï¸½¾ì¤òΩ¤Áµî¤Ã¤¿¡¢Êü²Ð¤Ï¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤¿¡£O»á¤Ï3·î9Æü¡¢½»µï¿¯Æþ¡¢ÀàÅðµÚ¤Ó¸½½»·ú¤ʪÊü²Ð¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¡£
ÅìµþÃÏÊýºÛȽ½ê·º»öÂè1Éô¤Ï¤³¤ì¤é¤Î»ö·ï¤ÈÊ̤ÎÀàÅð»ö·ï¤òÊ»¹ç¤·¤¿¡£O»á¤ÏÊü²Ð°Ê³°¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤ÏÁ´¤Æǧ¤á¤¿¡£Êü²Ð¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¼«Ê¬¤Ï¤ä¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤È½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£7²ó¤Î¸øȽÁ°À°Íý¼ê³´üÆü¤ò·Ð¤Æ¡¢Ê¿À®22ǯ7·î5Æü¤«¤é7Æü¤Þ¤ÇºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øȽ¿³Íý¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¡£¸øȽ¤Ç¤ÎÍ£°ì¤ÎÁèÅÀ¤ÏO»á¤¬¸åÆ£Áñ¤ËÊü²Ð¤ò¤·¤¿¤«¤É¤¦¤«¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡£¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢O»á¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȿͤǤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Èà¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤Î¼èÄ´¤Ù¤òÀÁµá¤·¤¿¡£O»á¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ï¤Î17ǯ°Ê¾åÁ°¡¢Ê¿À®4ǯ3·î¤«¤é6·î¤Ë¤«¤±¤Æ¹ç·×11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ò¹Ô¤¤¡¢Ê¿À®6ǯ4·î¤ËĨÌò15ǯ¤ÎͺáȽ·è¤ò¼õ¤±¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤é11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÏÁ´¤ÆÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£10·ï¤Ï¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤¦¤Á7·ï¤Ï¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µïÂðÆâ¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÅôÌý¤òÍøÍѤ·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Á3·ï¤ÏÅôÌý¥«¡¼¥È¥ê¥Ã¥¸¤ò¥¹¥È¡¼¥Ö¤«¤é¼è¤ê½Ð¤·¤ÆÃæ¤ÎÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤ÆÃå²Ð¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢¤½¤Î¼ç¤¿¤ëÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Åð¤ß¤ò¤·¤è¤¦¤È¤·¤¿¤¬¡Ö»×¤Ã¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¸½¶â¤ò¼ê¤ËÆþ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤ê¡¢ÁÀ¤Ã¤¿¼¼Æâ¤ËÆþ¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ê¤É¤ËÊ¢¤òΩ¤Æ¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¤Î¤¿¤á¡×¤ÈǧÄꤵ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡Ê¶üÏ©ÃϺ۷º»öÉôÊ¿À®6ǯ4·î13ÆüȽ·è¡¦Âè1¿³²µ11¡¢µÏ¿120ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Î¼ê¸ý¤ÈÁ°²Ê¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Î¼ê¸ý¤Ï¶Ë¤á¤Æ¹ó»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëͺá¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤¿¡£¤½¤¦¤·¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÎÊü²Ð¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢³ÎÄêȽ·è¡Ê²µ11¡Ë¤Î¤Û¤«¡¢Åö»þ¤ÎO»á¤Î¼«ÇòÄ´½ñ16Ä̡ʲµ4¡¢23~37¡Ë¤òÀÁµá¤·¤¿¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤¬Æüì¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢Êü²ÐÁܺº¤Î¥Ù¥Æ¥é¥ó·Ù»¡´±¤Ç¡Öµ»Ç½ÅÁ¾µ´±¡×¤Î¾Î¹æ¤ò¤â¤Ä¿ûÌî°ìÉ×·ÙÉô¡Ê¿Í5¡Ë¤ò¾Ú¿Í¿½ÀÁ¤·¤¿¡£ÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÈËÜ·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Î¼ê¸ý¤Ï¤¤¤º¤ì¤âÆüì¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëͺá¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¤·¤Æ°ÛµÄ¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Ç¤¢¤ëÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Ï¡¢¤¤¤º¤ì¤âÆüì¤Ê¼êÃÊ¡¢ÊýË¡¤Ë¤è¤ê¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤È¸À¤¨¤º¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤òÄ̤¸¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬µö¤µ¤ì¤ëÎ㳰Ū¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÅö¤¿¤é¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¡ÊµÏ¿44ÊÇ¡Ë¡¢¤³¤ì¤é¤Î¾ÚµòÀÁµá¤ò¤¤¤º¤ì¤âµÑ²¼¤·¤¿¡£Ã¢¤·¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÎȽ·èÆ¥Ëܡʲµ11¡Ë¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¡Ö¾ð¾õ¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Ë¸Â¤Ã¤Æ¡×¤ÈÃǤ俤¦¤¨¤ÇºÎÍѤ·¤¿¡ÊµÏ¿140ÊÇ¡Ë[1]¡£Âè1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢½»µï¿¯Æþ¤ÈÀàÅð¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æͺá¤È¤·¤ÆO»á¤Ë1ǯ6¥«·î¤ÎĨÌò·º¤ò¸À¤¤ÅϤ·¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȿͤǤ¢¤ë¤È¤¹¤ë¤Ë¤Ï¡Ö¹çÍýŪ¤Êµ¿Ì䤬»Ä¤ë¡×¤ÈȽÃǤ·¤¿¡ÊµÏ¿118~119ÊÇ¡Ë¡£
¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÎȽ·èÆ¥ËÜ¡¢¼«ÇòÄ´½ñ¤½¤·¤Æ¿ûÌî¾Ú¿Í¤òµÑ²¼¤·¤¿1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎÁ¼Ã֤ϰãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¹µÁʤ·¤¿¡£¹µÁÊ¿³¤Ç¤¢¤ëÅìµþ¹âÅùºÛȽ½êÂè8·º»öÉô¤Ï¡¢O»á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤Ë¤Ï¡Ö¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤¿¡×¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤Ê¡×Îà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ê¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤È¤·¤¿¡£¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢¤Þ¤º¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Î¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÎÎà»÷À¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡¢¤³¤¦½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£
¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÎÂçȾ¡Ê10·ï¡Ë¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Ï¡¢¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¡¢¤½¤ÎÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤ËÎà»÷À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î°ìÉôʬ¤Ë¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¾å¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤¬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¡¢¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤¬¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤ÎÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡Ê5~6ÊÇ¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£
¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î¤¢¤¤¤À¤Ë¤Ï¤½¤Î¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÎà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¡£
¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤Î¤¤¤º¤ì¤â¤¬¡¢ÀàÅð¤ò»î¤ß¤ÆÍߤ¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¶âÉʤ¬ÆÀ¤é¤ì¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ËÂФ¹¤ëʢΩ¤Á¤ò²ò¾Ã¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¼ç¤ÊÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¾¿Í¤Î½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£Â¾Êý¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÈÀÜÃ夷¤¿»þ´ÖÂӤˡ¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤ÎÈȹԾì½ê¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤ÆÀàÅð¤ò¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÏÁ褤¤¬¤Ê¤¯¡¢Æ±ÀàÅð¤ÎÈï³²ÉʤÏ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤È¥«¥Ã¥×ÌÍ1¸Ä¤Ë¤È¤É¤Þ¤Ã¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤òËþ¤µ¤»¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¤Ï»Ç¤ï¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤«¤é¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ÎÊ¢¤¤¤»¤ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ËµÚ¤ó¤À²ÄǽÀ¤¬¹Í¤¨¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Ï¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢Îà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¡¢¤½¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡Ê6ÊÇ¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£
¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤ÈÈȹԤˤ¤¤¿¤ë·Àµ¡¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤¤¤º¤ì¤âÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¡Ö¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤¿¡×¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Ëº¬º¹¤·¤¿¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢Á°²Ê´Ø·¸¾Úµò¤Î¤¦¤Á¡¢¡ÖÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡¢ÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¡×¤Ï¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ´ØÏ¢À¤¬¤¢¤ë¡¢¤È¸¶È½·è¤Ï½Ò¤Ù¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤Î·ëÏÀ¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£±¡ËȽ·èÆ¥ËܤˤĤ¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÈÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¤Î¤¢¤ë¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¤È¡Ö¼êÃÊÊýË¡¡×¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë»ö¼Â¤òǧÄꤷ¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤½¤Î¼èÄ´¤ÙÀÁµá¤òµÑ²¼¤·¤¿¸¶¿³¤ÎÁ¼Ã֤ϰãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£²¡Ë¶¡½ÒÄ´½ñ¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¤È¡Ö¼êÃÊÊýË¡¡×¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÉôʬ¤Ï´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤¬¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê³°¤ÎÉôʬ¤Ï´ØÏ¢À¤¬¤Ê¤¤¡£´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ëÉôʬ¤òÆÃÄê¤Ç¤¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¿³Íý¤ò¹Ô¤ï¤º¤Ë¡¢Á´ÉôµÑ²¼¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤Ï°ãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£³¡Ë¿ûÌî¾Ú¿Í¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢Æ±°ìÀ¤ÎȽÃǤϡÖ¾¤Î´ÖÀÜ»ö¼Â¤È¶¦¤Ë¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Î³ÆÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡¢³ÆÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤òÈæ³Ó¸¡Æ¤¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤è¤êȽÃǤµ¤ì¤ë¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Æ±¾Ú¿Í¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¡¢ÀìÌçŪ¤ÊÃθ«¡Ê¤½¤ÎÆâÍƤϡ¢²Ê³ØŪ¤Ê¼êË¡¤Ë¤è¤ëʬÀϤǤϤʤ¯¡¢Â¿¤¯¤ÎÁܺº¤ò¼ê¤¬¤±¤¿¼Ô¤Ë¤è¤ë·Ð¸³Åª¤ÊȽÃǤˤȤɤޤë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡Ë¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÆÃħ¤òÀâÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤ò¼è¤êÄ´¤Ù¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢ÁêÅö¤Ç¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¡Ê11ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Æ±¾Ú¿Í¿½ÀÁ¤òµÑ²¼¤·¤¿¸¶¿³¤ÎÁ¼Ã֤˰ãË¡¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢È½·èÆ¥Ëܤȶ¡½ÒÄ´½ñ¤òÁ´ÉôµÑ²¼¤·¤¿1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎÁ¼ÃÖ¤ÏȽ·è¤Ë±Æ¶Á¤òµÚ¤Ü¤¹¤³¤È¤¬ÌÀ¤é¤«¤ÊÁʾټ곤ÎË¡Îá°ãÈ¿¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢1¿³È½·è¤òÇË´þ¤·¤ÆËÜ·ï¤òÅìµþÃϺۤ˺¹¤·Ì᤹¤ÈȽ·è¤·¤¿¡£
¤·¤«¤·¡¢O»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤ÎˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ò¹ÎÄꤷ¤¿¸¶È½·è¤ÎȽÃǤϸí¤ê¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Êü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤ÎˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤òÈÝÄꤷ¡¢È½·èÆ¥Ëܤ䶡½ÒÄ´½ñ¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤òÈÝÄꤷ¤¿Âè1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÃǤÏÀµ¤·¤¤¡£
O»á¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤òËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤǤ¤ë¤È¤·¤¿¸¶È½·è¤ÎȽÃǤϡ¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎË¡Íý¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤ï¤¬¹ñºÇ½ª¿³ºÛȽ½ê¡ÊÂ翳±¡µÚ¤ÓºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¡Ë¤ÎȽÎã¤Ë°ãÈ¿¤¹¤ë¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢¤½¤ÎȽÃǤϡ¢Á°²Ê¤Î¤¢¤ë·º»öÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËͽÃÇÊ諤ò¤â¤Ä»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆºÛȽ¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¶¯Íפ¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Á°²Ê¼Ô¤ËÂФ·¤ÆÉÔ½½Ê¬¤Ê¾Úµò¤ÇͺáȽ·è¤¬²¼¤µ¤ì¤ë´í¸±¤ò¤â¤¿¤é¤¹¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Èà¤é¤Î¸øÊ¿¤ÊºÛȽ½ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÀµ¤Ê¿³Íý¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¸¢Íø¡ÊÆüËܹñ·ûË¡37¾ò1¹à¡¢»Ô̱ŪµÚ¤ÓÀ¯¼£Åª¸¢Íø¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¹ñºÝµ¬Ìó14¾ò1¹à¡Ë¤ò¿¯³²¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£±¡¡Â翳±¡µÚ¤ÓºÇ¹âºÛ¤ÎȽÎã¤Î³µ´Ñ
ÌÀ¼£·º»öÁʾÙË¡¡ÊÌÀ¼£23ǯˡΧÂè96¹æ¡Ë¤Ë¤â¡¢ÂçÀµ·º»öÁʾÙË¡¡ÊÂçÀµ11ǯˡΧÂè75¹æ¡Ë¤Ë¤â¡¢¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òÄê¤á¤¿µ¬Äê¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£ÌÀ¼£·ºÁÊË¡¤Ï¡Ö¡Ä¡Ä½ôÈ̥ξÚØá¥ÏȽ»ö¥ÎȽÃÇ¥ËǤ¥¹¡×¡Ê90¾ò¡Ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢¾Úµò¤ÎºÎÈݤ⤽¤Îɾ²Á¤âµó¤²¤ÆºÛȽ´±¤Î¼«Í³ºÛÎ̤˰Ѥͤë¼ñ»Ý¤òÌÀ¸À¤·¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£ÂçÀµ·ºÁÊË¡¤Ï¡Ö¾Úµò¥Î¾ÚÌÀÎÏ¥ÏȽ»ö¥Î¼«Í³¥Ê¥ëȽÃÇ¥ËǤ¥¹¡×¡Ê337¾ò¡Ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Î¼«Í³ºÛÎ̤ÎÈϰϤò¡Ö¾Úµò¥Î¾ÚÌÀÎϡפ¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¾Úµò¤Îɾ²Á¤Ë¸ÂÄꤷ¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¡½¡½²¿¤¬¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤ê¡¢²¿¤¬¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤«¡½¡½¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëµ¬Äê¤Ï¤ä¤Ï¤êÄê¤á¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Ë¡Î§¤Îµ¬Äê¾å¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Ï¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤â¼«Í³¤Ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ·¤Æ¤â¤«¤Þ¤ï¤Ê¤¤¤«¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÂκۤˤʤäƤ¤¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¼Â̳¤Ï¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢ÌÀ¼£·ºÁʤλþÂ夫¤é¡¢¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤êÆÀ¤ë¤â¤Î¤È¤Ê¤êÆÀ¤Ê¤¤¤â¤Î¤È¤Î¶èÊ̤¬¤¢¤ê¡¢¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤êÆÀ¤Ê¤¤¤â¤Î¤òºÎÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï°ãË¡¤Ê¼ê³¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î°ãË¡¤ÏͺáȽ·èÇËÔ̤ÎÍýͳ¤È¤Ê¤ë¤³¤È¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤·Àë¸À¤·¤Æ¤¤¿[2]¡£
Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Ï¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤¿¤ëÈȺá¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¸¶Â§¤Ï¡¢¤¹¤Ç¤ËÌÀ¼£·ºÁÊË¡¤Î»þÂå¤ËÂ翳±¡¤ÎȽÎã¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£ÂçÀµ7ǯ¡Ê1918ǯ¡Ë5·î24ÆüÂ翳±¡È½·è¡Ê·ºÏ¿24-647¡Ë¤Ï¡¢2¿Í¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬²ñ¼Ò¤Î»ö̳¼¼Æâ¤ÇƱν¤ò²¥¤Ã¤Æ¤±¤¬¤ò¤µ¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦½ý³²Èï¹ð»ö·ï¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÎȽÎã¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶¿³¤Ï¡¢²áµî¤ËÊ£¿ô²ó¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ½ý³²¤ÇͺáȽ·è¤ò¼õ¤±ÉþÌò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤¬¤¢¤ë»Ý¤Î1̾¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸øȽ¶¡½Ò¤È¤â¤¦£±¿Í¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²ÊÄ´½ñ¤ÎµºÜ¤ò°úÍѤ·¤Æͺá¤òǧÄꤷ¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤ËÂФ·¤ÆÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£
¡ÖÁ°²Ê¥ÏÁ°²Ê¥Ë¥·¥Æľ¥Á¥ËÈȺá¥ò¾ÚÌÀ¥¹¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ë¥¢¥é¥¹¼©¥ÆÁ°²Ê¥ò°Ê¥ÆÈȺá»ö¼Â¥Î¾ÚÌÀ»ñÎÁ¥È°Ù¥¹¥Ï·º»öÁʾÙË¡¥Îµö¥µ¥µ¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥ê¥È»×ÎÁ¥¹Ç·¥ò¾ÚµòË¡¥Î±è³×¥Ëħ¥¹¥ë¥âÉʹԼ㥯¥ÏÁ°²Ê¥ò°Ê¥Æͺá¥ò¿ä¬¥¹¥ë¥Î´í¸±¥ò²ò¥«¥µ¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥·±Ñ¹ñ¥ÎÇ¡¥¥ÏÉʹԥξÚÌÀ¥òµö¥¹¥ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÍø±×¥òÊݸ¥ë»üÁ±¿´¥Ë½Ð¥Æ¥¿¥ë¥â¥Î¥È°Ù¥·Â¿Ç¯¥Î´·Îã¥Ï°¿¾ì¹ç¥ò½ü¥¯¥Î³°Èï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÁ±°Õ¥ò¾ÚÌÀ¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥Î¥ßÇ·¥òµö¥»¥ë¥Ë²á¥¥¹¸¶È½·è¥«Á°µ¡Ê°ì¡Ë¡ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¶¡½Ò¡Ï¡Ê¶å¡Ë¡ÎÁ°²ÊÄ´½ñ¡Ï¥ò°Ê¥ÆÈȺá¥Î¾ÚÎÁ¥Ë¶¡¥·¥¿¥ë¥ÏºÎ¾Ú¥ÎË¡µ¬¥ËØ£¥ë¿Ó¥·¥¥â¥Î¥È¿®¥¹¡×
Â翳±¡¤Ï¤³¤Î¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤òǧ¤á¤Æ¡¢¸¶È½·è¤òÇË´þ¤·¤Æ»ö·ï¤ò¸¶¿³¤Ëº¹¤·Ìᤷ¤¿¡£
¡Ö°Ä¥¹¥ë¥Ë·º»öÁʾÙË¡¥Ï¾Úµò¥Î¼ïÎà¥ò¸ÂÄꥻ¥¹¥Èê¥â¾Úµò¥Î¼Â¼Á¥«°ìÄê¥ÎÈȺá»ö¼Â¥òǧÄꥹ¥ë¥ËŬÅö¥Ê¥é¥µ¥ë¥â¥Î¥ÏÇ·¥òȽÃǥλñÎÁ¥Ë¶¡¥¹¥ë¥òÆÀ¥¹º£Á°²Ê¥ËÉÕ¥ÆÇ·¥ò´Ñ¥ë¥ËÁ°²Ê¥Ï¶¸å¥ËÀ¸¥·¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥È²¿Åù´Ø¾Ä¥¹¥ë½ê¥Ê¥¯Á´Á³²áµî¥Î»ö¼Â¥Ë°¥¹¥ë¥ò°Ê¥ÆÈï¹ð¥«Á°²Ê¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¥Î»ö¼Â¾ÚÌÀ¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ë¶»ö¼Â¥Ï°¿¥ÏºÆÈȲýťθ¶°ø¥È¥Ê¥ê°¿¥ÏÈï¹ð¥ÎÀ¹Ô¥òȽÃÇ¥··º¥ÎÎÌÄê¥òº¸±¦¥¹¥ëº¬µò¥È¥Ê¥ê°¿¥ÏÅÒÇîºá¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥ÏÈï¹ð¥«ÅÒÇî¾ï½¬¼Ô¥¿¥ë¿Èʬ¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¥äÈÝ¥ä¥òȽÃÇ¥¹¥ë»ñÎÁ¥È¥Ê¥êÆÀ¥Ø¥±¥ó¥â¸øÁÊ¥ÎÌÜŪ¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥ÎÀ®Î©¥òÃÇÄꥹ¥ë¥ËÉեƥÏŬÅö¥Ê¥é¥¹¸Î¥Ë»ö¼ÂºÛȽ½ê¥«Á°²Ê¥Ë´Ø¥¹¥ë¾Úµò¥Î¥ß¥Ë°Í¥ê¥¿¥ë¾ì¹ç¥ÏÌÞÏÀÇ·¥ò¾¥Î¾Úµò¥ÈÁî¹ç¥·¥¿¥ë¥È¥¥Èê¥âçñ¥â³º¾Úµò¥ò±çÍÑ¥·ÈȺá¥ÎÀ®Î©¥òǧÄꥷ¥¿¥ë°Ê¾å¥Ï¶Ƚ·è¥ÏºÎ¾Ú¥Ë°ãË¡¥¢¥ë¥â¥Î¥È¥·¥ÆÇËÔÌ¥òÌȥ쥹¸¶È½·è¥ÏÈï¹ð±¬Ç·½õ¥Î¸¶¿³¸øÄî¥Ë±÷¥ëƱ¿Í¥«Á°²Ê¥òÍ¥¹¥ë»Ý¥Î¶¡½ÒµÚ¥ÒÈï¹ðͧͺ¥ËÂÐ¥¹¥ëÁ°²ÊÄ´½ñ¥ò±çÍÑ¥·Ç·¥ò¾¥Î¾Úµò¥ÈÁî¹ç¥·¥ÆÈï¹ðÅù¥«¶¦Æ±¥·¥ÆÁ°À»°³°°ì̾¥ò²¥ÂÇ¥·¥¿¥ë»ö¼Â¥òǧÄꥷ¥¿¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ì¥Ï½ö¾å¥ÎÍýͳ¥Ë°Í¥êÇË´þ¥¹¥Ø¥¥â¥Î¥È¥¹ÏÀ»Ý¥ÏÍýͳ¥¢¥ê¡×
¡Ú³¤¯¡Û
¤Ï¤¸¤á¤Ë
Ê¿À®21ǯ9·î8Æü¸áÁ°11»þ50ʬ¤³¤í¡¢ÅìµþÅÔ³ë¾þ¶è¶âÄ®¤Î½»ÂðÃϤˤ¢¤ëÌÚ¤2³¬·ú¤Æ¥¢¥Ñ¡¼¥È¡Ö¸åÆ£Áñ¡×£±³¬101¹æ¼¼¶â»Ò¥è¥·¥¨Êý¤«¤é±ì¤¬½Ð¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤ò¶á½ê¤Î½»Ì±¤¬È¯¸«¤·¡¢119ÈÖÄÌÊó¤·¤¿¡£¿ôʬ¸å¤Ë¶î¤±ÉÕ¤±¤¿¾ÃËÉÃÄ°÷¤¬¾Ã²Ð´ï¤ÇÄòФ·¤¿¡£µï´Ö¤ÎÃæ±ûÉô¤Î¥«¡¼¥Ú¥Ã¥ÈÉÕ¶á¤Î¾²Ìó1.1Ê¿Êý¥á¡¼¥È¥ë¤¬¾Æ¤±¤¿¡£¤½¤³¤Ë¤ÏÀÐÌý¥¹¥È¡¼¥Ö¤ÎµëÌý¥«¡¼¥È¥ê¥Ã¥¸¤¬ÊüÃÖ¤µ¤ì¡¢¾Æ¤±¤¿¾²¤«¤éÅôÌý¤ÎÀ®Ê¬¤¬¸¡½Ð¤µ¤ì¤¿¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢Âæ½ê¤Î¿©´ïê¤ËÊݴɤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤¿¥«¥Ã¥×Ìͤ¬¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ê¡¢¥È¥¤¥ì¤Î꤫¤é¥«¥Ã¥×Ìͤζõ¤ÎÍƴ郎ȯ¸«¤µ¤ì¤¿¡£¤´¤ßÆþ¤ì¤È¤·¤ÆÍøÍѤ·¤Æ¤¤¤¿Âæ½ê¤Î»æÂÞ¤«¤é¤Ï»ÈÍѺѤߤγä¤ê¤Ð¤·¤¬¸«¤Ä¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£¿²¼¼¤Î¥Ü¥Ã¥¯¥¹¤Ë¾è¤»¤Æ¤ª¤¤¤¿500±ß¶Ì2¤Ä¤¬¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤¬¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê³°¤ËÅð¤Þ¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ï²¿¤â¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£
Èï¹ð¿ÍOK»á¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î2½µ´Ö¸å9·î21Æü¤ËÊÌ·ï¤ÎÀàÅðÍƵ¿¤ÇÂáÊᤵ¤ì¡¢°Ê¸å¿¿ô¤Î;ºá¤ò¹ðÇò¤¹¤ë¾å¿½½ñ¤ò·Ù»¡¤ËÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¸åÆ£Áñ¤ÎÀàÅð¤äÊü²Ð¤ò¹ðÇò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¡£O»á¤Ï12·î18ÆüÀàÅð»ö·ï¤Ë¤è¤êͺáȽ·è¤ò¼õ¤±¤¿¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢Ê¿À®22ǯ1·î12Æü¤Ë·Ù»¡¤ËDNA¥µ¥ó¥×¥ë¤òÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¤È¤³¤í¡¢¸åÆ£Áñ¤Çȯ¸«¤µ¤ì¤¿¥«¥Ã¥×ÌÍÍÆ´ï¤ä³ä¤ê¤Ð¤·¤«¤é¸¡½Ð¤µ¤ì¤¿DNA·¿¤È°ìÃפ·¤¿¡£2·î16ÆüO»á¤Ï½»µï¿¯Æþ¡¢ÀàÅðµÚ¤Ó¸½½»·ú¤ʪÊü²Ð¤ÎÍƵ¿¤ÇºÆÂáÊᤵ¤ì¤¿¡£O»á¤Ï¶â»ÒÊý¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤Æ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤È¥«¥Ã¥×ÌͤòÅð¤ó¤À¤³¤È¤òǧ¤á¤¿¤â¤Î¤Î¡¢ÅöÆü¸áÁ°7»þÂæ¤Ë¤Ï¸½¾ì¤òΩ¤Áµî¤Ã¤¿¡¢Êü²Ð¤Ï¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤È¸À¤Ã¤¿¡£O»á¤Ï3·î9Æü¡¢½»µï¿¯Æþ¡¢ÀàÅðµÚ¤Ó¸½½»·ú¤ʪÊü²Ð¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤Çµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤¿¡£
ÅìµþÃÏÊýºÛȽ½ê·º»öÂè1Éô¤Ï¤³¤ì¤é¤Î»ö·ï¤ÈÊ̤ÎÀàÅð»ö·ï¤òÊ»¹ç¤·¤¿¡£O»á¤ÏÊü²Ð°Ê³°¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤ÏÁ´¤Æǧ¤á¤¿¡£Êü²Ð¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¼«Ê¬¤Ï¤ä¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤È½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£7²ó¤Î¸øȽÁ°À°Íý¼ê³´üÆü¤ò·Ð¤Æ¡¢Ê¿À®22ǯ7·î5Æü¤«¤é7Æü¤Þ¤ÇºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øȽ¿³Íý¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¡£¸øȽ¤Ç¤ÎÍ£°ì¤ÎÁèÅÀ¤ÏO»á¤¬¸åÆ£Áñ¤ËÊü²Ð¤ò¤·¤¿¤«¤É¤¦¤«¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡£¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢O»á¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȿͤǤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Èà¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤Î¼èÄ´¤Ù¤òÀÁµá¤·¤¿¡£O»á¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ï¤Î17ǯ°Ê¾åÁ°¡¢Ê¿À®4ǯ3·î¤«¤é6·î¤Ë¤«¤±¤Æ¹ç·×11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ò¹Ô¤¤¡¢Ê¿À®6ǯ4·î¤ËĨÌò15ǯ¤ÎͺáȽ·è¤ò¼õ¤±¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤é11·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÏÁ´¤ÆÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£10·ï¤Ï¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿¼¼Æâ¤ËÅôÌý¤ò»µ¤¤¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤¦¤Á7·ï¤Ï¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µïÂðÆâ¤Ë¤¢¤Ã¤¿ÅôÌý¤òÍøÍѤ·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Á3·ï¤ÏÅôÌý¥«¡¼¥È¥ê¥Ã¥¸¤ò¥¹¥È¡¼¥Ö¤«¤é¼è¤ê½Ð¤·¤ÆÃæ¤ÎÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤ÆÃå²Ð¤·¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢¤½¤Î¼ç¤¿¤ëÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢Åð¤ß¤ò¤·¤è¤¦¤È¤·¤¿¤¬¡Ö»×¤Ã¤¿¤è¤¦¤Ë¸½¶â¤ò¼ê¤ËÆþ¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤ê¡¢ÁÀ¤Ã¤¿¼¼Æâ¤ËÆþ¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ê¤É¤ËÊ¢¤òΩ¤Æ¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¤Î¤¿¤á¡×¤ÈǧÄꤵ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡Ê¶üÏ©ÃϺ۷º»öÉôÊ¿À®6ǯ4·î13ÆüȽ·è¡¦Âè1¿³²µ11¡¢µÏ¿120ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Î¼ê¸ý¤ÈÁ°²Ê¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Î¼ê¸ý¤Ï¶Ë¤á¤Æ¹ó»÷¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëͺá¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤¿¡£¤½¤¦¤·¤Æ¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÎÊü²Ð¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢³ÎÄêȽ·è¡Ê²µ11¡Ë¤Î¤Û¤«¡¢Åö»þ¤ÎO»á¤Î¼«ÇòÄ´½ñ16Ä̡ʲµ4¡¢23~37¡Ë¤òÀÁµá¤·¤¿¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤¬Æüì¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¡¢Êü²ÐÁܺº¤Î¥Ù¥Æ¥é¥ó·Ù»¡´±¤Ç¡Öµ»Ç½ÅÁ¾µ´±¡×¤Î¾Î¹æ¤ò¤â¤Ä¿ûÌî°ìÉ×·ÙÉô¡Ê¿Í5¡Ë¤ò¾Ú¿Í¿½ÀÁ¤·¤¿¡£ÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÈËÜ·ï¤ÎÊü²Ð¤Î¼ê¸ý¤Ï¤¤¤º¤ì¤âÆüì¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢Á°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëͺá¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤È¤·¤Æ°ÛµÄ¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢¡ÖÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Ç¤¢¤ëÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Ï¡¢¤¤¤º¤ì¤âÆüì¤Ê¼êÃÊ¡¢ÊýË¡¤Ë¤è¤ê¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤È¸À¤¨¤º¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤òÄ̤¸¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬µö¤µ¤ì¤ëÎ㳰Ū¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÅö¤¿¤é¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¤·¤Æ¡ÊµÏ¿44ÊÇ¡Ë¡¢¤³¤ì¤é¤Î¾ÚµòÀÁµá¤ò¤¤¤º¤ì¤âµÑ²¼¤·¤¿¡£Ã¢¤·¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÎȽ·èÆ¥Ëܡʲµ11¡Ë¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¡Ö¾ð¾õ¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Ë¸Â¤Ã¤Æ¡×¤ÈÃǤ俤¦¤¨¤ÇºÎÍѤ·¤¿¡ÊµÏ¿140ÊÇ¡Ë[1]¡£Âè1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢½»µï¿¯Æþ¤ÈÀàÅð¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æͺá¤È¤·¤ÆO»á¤Ë1ǯ6¥«·î¤ÎĨÌò·º¤ò¸À¤¤ÅϤ·¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȿͤǤ¢¤ë¤È¤¹¤ë¤Ë¤Ï¡Ö¹çÍýŪ¤Êµ¿Ì䤬»Ä¤ë¡×¤ÈȽÃǤ·¤¿¡ÊµÏ¿118~119ÊÇ¡Ë¡£
¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÎȽ·èÆ¥ËÜ¡¢¼«ÇòÄ´½ñ¤½¤·¤Æ¿ûÌî¾Ú¿Í¤òµÑ²¼¤·¤¿1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎÁ¼Ã֤ϰãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¹µÁʤ·¤¿¡£¹µÁÊ¿³¤Ç¤¢¤ëÅìµþ¹âÅùºÛȽ½êÂè8·º»öÉô¤Ï¡¢O»á¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤Ë¤Ï¡Ö¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤¿¡×¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤Ê¡×Îà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ê¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾ì¹ç¤Ë¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤Ë¤è¤ëËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎΩ¾Ú¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤È¤·¤¿¡£¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢¤Þ¤º¡¢Á°²Ê¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Î¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÎÎà»÷À¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡¢¤³¤¦½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£
¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÎÂçȾ¡Ê10·ï¡Ë¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Ï¡¢¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿µï¼¼Æâ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÅôÌý¤ò»¶ÉÛ¤·¤Æ¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¡¢¤½¤ÎÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤ËÎà»÷À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤ÇÊü²Ð¤ò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤È¤¤¤¦Îà·¿¤Î°ìÉôʬ¤Ë¸ÂÄꤵ¤ì¤ë¾å¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤¬·«¤êÊÖ¤µ¤ì¡¢¤½¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤¬¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤ÎÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡Ê5~6ÊÇ¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£
¤µ¤é¤Ë¡¢¸¶È½·è¤ÏÁ°²Ê¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î¤¢¤¤¤À¤Ë¤Ï¤½¤Î¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÎà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¡£
¡ÖÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤Î¤¤¤º¤ì¤â¤¬¡¢ÀàÅð¤ò»î¤ß¤ÆÍߤ¹¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¶âÉʤ¬ÆÀ¤é¤ì¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤ËÂФ¹¤ëʢΩ¤Á¤ò²ò¾Ã¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¼ç¤ÊÆ°µ¡¤È¤·¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Ã¤×¤óÀ²¤é¤·¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¾¿Í¤Î½»Âð¤Ø¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤¹¤È¤¤¤¦¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ç¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£Â¾Êý¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÈÀÜÃ夷¤¿»þ´ÖÂӤˡ¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬¤½¤ÎÈȹԾì½ê¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤ÆÀàÅð¤ò¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÏÁ褤¤¬¤Ê¤¯¡¢Æ±ÀàÅð¤ÎÈï³²ÉʤÏ500±ß¹Å²ß2Ëç¤È¥«¥Ã¥×ÌÍ1¸Ä¤Ë¤È¤É¤Þ¤Ã¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤òËþ¤µ¤»¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¤È¤Ï»Ç¤ï¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤«¤é¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤ÎÊ¢¤¤¤»¤ËÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ËµÚ¤ó¤À²ÄǽÀ¤¬¹Í¤¨¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Ï¡¢ÀàÅ𤫤éÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢Îà»÷À¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Èǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÁ°·ºÊü²Ð¤Î¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤¬¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¡¢¤½¤ÎÎà»÷À¤ò¤è¤êÆÃħŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤ë¡×¡Ê6ÊÇ¡£¶¯Ä´¤Ï°úÍѼԡˡ£
¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤È¤Î´Ö¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤ÈÈȹԤˤ¤¤¿¤ë·Àµ¡¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤¤¤º¤ì¤âÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¡Ö¸ÇÃå²½¤·¤¿¡×¹ÔÆ°·¹¸þ¤Ëº¬º¹¤·¤¿¡ÖÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¡×¤¬¤¢¤ë¤Î¤Ç¡¢Á°²Ê´Ø·¸¾Úµò¤Î¤¦¤Á¡¢¡ÖÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡¢ÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¡×¤Ï¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈȿͤÎƱ°ìÀ¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ´ØÏ¢À¤¬¤¢¤ë¡¢¤È¸¶È½·è¤Ï½Ò¤Ù¤ë¡£¸¶È½·è¤Î·ëÏÀ¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£±¡ËȽ·èÆ¥ËܤˤĤ¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÈÆÃħŪ¤ÊÎà»÷À¤Î¤¢¤ë¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¤È¡Ö¼êÃÊÊýË¡¡×¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë»ö¼Â¤òǧÄꤷ¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¤½¤Î¼èÄ´¤ÙÀÁµá¤òµÑ²¼¤·¤¿¸¶¿³¤ÎÁ¼Ã֤ϰãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£²¡Ë¶¡½ÒÄ´½ñ¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢¡Ö·Àµ¡¡×¤È¡Ö¼êÃÊÊýË¡¡×¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëÉôʬ¤Ï´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ë¤¬¡¢¤½¤ì°Ê³°¤ÎÉôʬ¤Ï´ØÏ¢À¤¬¤Ê¤¤¡£´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ëÉôʬ¤òÆÃÄê¤Ç¤¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ê¿³Íý¤ò¹Ô¤ï¤º¤Ë¡¢Á´ÉôµÑ²¼¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤Ï°ãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£³¡Ë¿ûÌî¾Ú¿Í¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¡¢Æ±°ìÀ¤ÎȽÃǤϡÖ¾¤Î´ÖÀÜ»ö¼Â¤È¶¦¤Ë¡¢Á°·ºÊü²Ð¤ÈËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤Î³ÆÈȹԤ˻ê¤ë·Àµ¡¡¢³ÆÈȹԤμêÃÊÊýË¡¤òÈæ³Ó¸¡Æ¤¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤è¤êȽÃǤµ¤ì¤ë¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Æ±¾Ú¿Í¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¡¢ÀìÌçŪ¤ÊÃθ«¡Ê¤½¤ÎÆâÍƤϡ¢²Ê³ØŪ¤Ê¼êË¡¤Ë¤è¤ëʬÀϤǤϤʤ¯¡¢Â¿¤¯¤ÎÁܺº¤ò¼ê¤¬¤±¤¿¼Ô¤Ë¤è¤ë·Ð¸³Åª¤ÊȽÃǤˤȤɤޤë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡Ë¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯ËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÆÃħ¤òÀâÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤ò¼è¤êÄ´¤Ù¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¡¢ÁêÅö¤Ç¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¡Ê11ÊÇ¡Ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Æ±¾Ú¿Í¿½ÀÁ¤òµÑ²¼¤·¤¿¸¶¿³¤ÎÁ¼Ã֤˰ãË¡¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£
¸¶È½·è¤Ï¡¢È½·èÆ¥Ëܤȶ¡½ÒÄ´½ñ¤òÁ´ÉôµÑ²¼¤·¤¿1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎÁ¼ÃÖ¤ÏȽ·è¤Ë±Æ¶Á¤òµÚ¤Ü¤¹¤³¤È¤¬ÌÀ¤é¤«¤ÊÁʾټ곤ÎË¡Îá°ãÈ¿¤Ë¤¢¤¿¤ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢1¿³È½·è¤òÇË´þ¤·¤ÆËÜ·ï¤òÅìµþÃϺۤ˺¹¤·Ì᤹¤ÈȽ·è¤·¤¿¡£
¤·¤«¤·¡¢O»á¤ÎÊü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤ÎˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤ò¹ÎÄꤷ¤¿¸¶È½·è¤ÎȽÃǤϸí¤ê¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Êü²ÐÁ°²Ê¤ÎˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤òÈÝÄꤷ¡¢È½·èÆ¥Ëܤ䶡½ÒÄ´½ñ¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤òÈÝÄꤷ¤¿Âè1¿³ºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÃǤÏÀµ¤·¤¤¡£
¾å¹ð¼ñ°ÕÂè1¡§ÈÈ¿ÍÀǧÄê¤Î¤¿¤á¤ËÎà»÷Á°²Ê¤òµöÍƤ·¤¿¤³¤È
O»á¤ÎÊü²Ð¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤òËÜ·ïÊü²Ð¤ÎÈÈ¿ÍÀ¤òǧÄꤹ¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤǤ¤ë¤È¤·¤¿¸¶È½·è¤ÎȽÃǤϡ¢À³Ê¾Úµò¶Ø»ß¤ÎË¡Íý¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¤ï¤¬¹ñºÇ½ª¿³ºÛȽ½ê¡ÊÂ翳±¡µÚ¤ÓºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¡Ë¤ÎȽÎã¤Ë°ãÈ¿¤¹¤ë¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢¤½¤ÎȽÃǤϡ¢Á°²Ê¤Î¤¢¤ë·º»öÈï¹ð¿Í¤ËͽÃÇÊ諤ò¤â¤Ä»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆºÛȽ¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¶¯Íפ¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢Á°²Ê¼Ô¤ËÂФ·¤ÆÉÔ½½Ê¬¤Ê¾Úµò¤ÇͺáȽ·è¤¬²¼¤µ¤ì¤ë´í¸±¤ò¤â¤¿¤é¤¹¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Èà¤é¤Î¸øÊ¿¤ÊºÛȽ½ê¤Ë¤è¤ë¸øÀµ¤Ê¿³Íý¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¸¢Íø¡ÊÆüËܹñ·ûË¡37¾ò1¹à¡¢»Ô̱ŪµÚ¤ÓÀ¯¼£Åª¸¢Íø¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¹ñºÝµ¬Ìó14¾ò1¹à¡Ë¤ò¿¯³²¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
£±¡¡Â翳±¡µÚ¤ÓºÇ¹âºÛ¤ÎȽÎã¤Î³µ´Ñ
ÌÀ¼£·º»öÁʾÙË¡¡ÊÌÀ¼£23ǯˡΧÂè96¹æ¡Ë¤Ë¤â¡¢ÂçÀµ·º»öÁʾÙË¡¡ÊÂçÀµ11ǯˡΧÂè75¹æ¡Ë¤Ë¤â¡¢¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ë¥ë¡¼¥ë¤òÄê¤á¤¿µ¬Äê¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£ÌÀ¼£·ºÁÊË¡¤Ï¡Ö¡Ä¡Ä½ôÈ̥ξÚØá¥ÏȽ»ö¥ÎȽÃÇ¥ËǤ¥¹¡×¡Ê90¾ò¡Ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢¾Úµò¤ÎºÎÈݤ⤽¤Îɾ²Á¤âµó¤²¤ÆºÛȽ´±¤Î¼«Í³ºÛÎ̤˰Ѥͤë¼ñ»Ý¤òÌÀ¸À¤·¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£ÂçÀµ·ºÁÊË¡¤Ï¡Ö¾Úµò¥Î¾ÚÌÀÎÏ¥ÏȽ»ö¥Î¼«Í³¥Ê¥ëȽÃÇ¥ËǤ¥¹¡×¡Ê337¾ò¡Ë¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Î¼«Í³ºÛÎ̤ÎÈϰϤò¡Ö¾Úµò¥Î¾ÚÌÀÎϡפ¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¾Úµò¤Îɾ²Á¤Ë¸ÂÄꤷ¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¡½¡½²¿¤¬¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤ê¡¢²¿¤¬¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤«¡½¡½¤Ë´Ø¤¹¤ëµ¬Äê¤Ï¤ä¤Ï¤êÄê¤á¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢Ë¡Î§¤Îµ¬Äê¾å¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Ï¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤â¼«Í³¤Ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤ·¤Æ¤â¤«¤Þ¤ï¤Ê¤¤¤«¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÂκۤˤʤäƤ¤¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¼Â̳¤Ï¤½¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£Â翳±¡¤Ï¡¢ÌÀ¼£·ºÁʤλþÂ夫¤é¡¢¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤êÆÀ¤ë¤â¤Î¤È¤Ê¤êÆÀ¤Ê¤¤¤â¤Î¤È¤Î¶èÊ̤¬¤¢¤ê¡¢¾Úµò¤È¤Ê¤êÆÀ¤Ê¤¤¤â¤Î¤òºÎÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï°ãË¡¤Ê¼ê³¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤Î°ãË¡¤ÏͺáȽ·èÇËÔ̤ÎÍýͳ¤È¤Ê¤ë¤³¤È¤ò·«¤êÊÖ¤·Àë¸À¤·¤Æ¤¤¿[2]¡£
Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤Ï¸øÁÊ»ö¼Â¤¿¤ëÈȺá¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¸¶Â§¤Ï¡¢¤¹¤Ç¤ËÌÀ¼£·ºÁÊË¡¤Î»þÂå¤ËÂ翳±¡¤ÎȽÎã¤È¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£ÂçÀµ7ǯ¡Ê1918ǯ¡Ë5·î24ÆüÂ翳±¡È½·è¡Ê·ºÏ¿24-647¡Ë¤Ï¡¢2¿Í¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤¬²ñ¼Ò¤Î»ö̳¼¼Æâ¤ÇƱν¤ò²¥¤Ã¤Æ¤±¤¬¤ò¤µ¤»¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦½ý³²Èï¹ð»ö·ï¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÎȽÎã¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¸¶¿³¤Ï¡¢²áµî¤ËÊ£¿ô²ó¤Ë¤ï¤¿¤Ã¤Æ½ý³²¤ÇͺáȽ·è¤ò¼õ¤±ÉþÌò¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤¬¤¢¤ë»Ý¤Î1̾¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸øȽ¶¡½Ò¤È¤â¤¦£±¿Í¤ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²ÊÄ´½ñ¤ÎµºÜ¤ò°úÍѤ·¤Æͺá¤òǧÄꤷ¤¿¡£¤³¤ì¤ËÂФ·¤ÆÊÛ¸î¿Í¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£
¡ÖÁ°²Ê¥ÏÁ°²Ê¥Ë¥·¥Æľ¥Á¥ËÈȺá¥ò¾ÚÌÀ¥¹¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ë¥¢¥é¥¹¼©¥ÆÁ°²Ê¥ò°Ê¥ÆÈȺá»ö¼Â¥Î¾ÚÌÀ»ñÎÁ¥È°Ù¥¹¥Ï·º»öÁʾÙË¡¥Îµö¥µ¥µ¥ë¥È¥³¥í¥Ê¥ê¥È»×ÎÁ¥¹Ç·¥ò¾ÚµòË¡¥Î±è³×¥Ëħ¥¹¥ë¥âÉʹԼ㥯¥ÏÁ°²Ê¥ò°Ê¥Æͺá¥ò¿ä¬¥¹¥ë¥Î´í¸±¥ò²ò¥«¥µ¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥·±Ñ¹ñ¥ÎÇ¡¥¥ÏÉʹԥξÚÌÀ¥òµö¥¹¥ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÍø±×¥òÊݸ¥ë»üÁ±¿´¥Ë½Ð¥Æ¥¿¥ë¥â¥Î¥È°Ù¥·Â¿Ç¯¥Î´·Îã¥Ï°¿¾ì¹ç¥ò½ü¥¯¥Î³°Èï¹ð¿Í¥ÎÁ±°Õ¥ò¾ÚÌÀ¥¹¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥Î¥ßÇ·¥òµö¥»¥ë¥Ë²á¥¥¹¸¶È½·è¥«Á°µ¡Ê°ì¡Ë¡ÎÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¶¡½Ò¡Ï¡Ê¶å¡Ë¡ÎÁ°²ÊÄ´½ñ¡Ï¥ò°Ê¥ÆÈȺá¥Î¾ÚÎÁ¥Ë¶¡¥·¥¿¥ë¥ÏºÎ¾Ú¥ÎË¡µ¬¥ËØ£¥ë¿Ó¥·¥¥â¥Î¥È¿®¥¹¡×
Â翳±¡¤Ï¤³¤Î¾å¹ð¼ñ°Õ¤òǧ¤á¤Æ¡¢¸¶È½·è¤òÇË´þ¤·¤Æ»ö·ï¤ò¸¶¿³¤Ëº¹¤·Ìᤷ¤¿¡£
¡Ö°Ä¥¹¥ë¥Ë·º»öÁʾÙË¡¥Ï¾Úµò¥Î¼ïÎà¥ò¸ÂÄꥻ¥¹¥Èê¥â¾Úµò¥Î¼Â¼Á¥«°ìÄê¥ÎÈȺá»ö¼Â¥òǧÄꥹ¥ë¥ËŬÅö¥Ê¥é¥µ¥ë¥â¥Î¥ÏÇ·¥òȽÃǥλñÎÁ¥Ë¶¡¥¹¥ë¥òÆÀ¥¹º£Á°²Ê¥ËÉÕ¥ÆÇ·¥ò´Ñ¥ë¥ËÁ°²Ê¥Ï¶¸å¥ËÀ¸¥·¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥È²¿Åù´Ø¾Ä¥¹¥ë½ê¥Ê¥¯Á´Á³²áµî¥Î»ö¼Â¥Ë°¥¹¥ë¥ò°Ê¥ÆÈï¹ð¥«Á°²Ê¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¥Î»ö¼Â¾ÚÌÀ¥»¥é¥ì¥¿¥ë¾ì¹ç¥Ë¶»ö¼Â¥Ï°¿¥ÏºÆÈȲýťθ¶°ø¥È¥Ê¥ê°¿¥ÏÈï¹ð¥ÎÀ¹Ô¥òȽÃÇ¥··º¥ÎÎÌÄê¥òº¸±¦¥¹¥ëº¬µò¥È¥Ê¥ê°¿¥ÏÅÒÇîºá¥Ë±÷¥Æ¥ÏÈï¹ð¥«ÅÒÇî¾ï½¬¼Ô¥¿¥ë¿Èʬ¥òÍ¥¹¥ë¥äÈÝ¥ä¥òȽÃÇ¥¹¥ë»ñÎÁ¥È¥Ê¥êÆÀ¥Ø¥±¥ó¥â¸øÁÊ¥ÎÌÜŪ¥¿¥ëÈȺá¹Ô°Ù¥ÎÀ®Î©¥òÃÇÄꥹ¥ë¥ËÉեƥÏŬÅö¥Ê¥é¥¹¸Î¥Ë»ö¼ÂºÛȽ½ê¥«Á°²Ê¥Ë´Ø¥¹¥ë¾Úµò¥Î¥ß¥Ë°Í¥ê¥¿¥ë¾ì¹ç¥ÏÌÞÏÀÇ·¥ò¾¥Î¾Úµò¥ÈÁî¹ç¥·¥¿¥ë¥È¥¥Èê¥âçñ¥â³º¾Úµò¥ò±çÍÑ¥·ÈȺá¥ÎÀ®Î©¥òǧÄꥷ¥¿¥ë°Ê¾å¥Ï¶Ƚ·è¥ÏºÎ¾Ú¥Ë°ãË¡¥¢¥ë¥â¥Î¥È¥·¥ÆÇËÔÌ¥òÌȥ쥹¸¶È½·è¥ÏÈï¹ð±¬Ç·½õ¥Î¸¶¿³¸øÄî¥Ë±÷¥ëƱ¿Í¥«Á°²Ê¥òÍ¥¹¥ë»Ý¥Î¶¡½ÒµÚ¥ÒÈï¹ðͧͺ¥ËÂÐ¥¹¥ëÁ°²ÊÄ´½ñ¥ò±çÍÑ¥·Ç·¥ò¾¥Î¾Úµò¥ÈÁî¹ç¥·¥ÆÈï¹ðÅù¥«¶¦Æ±¥·¥ÆÁ°À»°³°°ì̾¥ò²¥ÂÇ¥·¥¿¥ë»ö¼Â¥òǧÄꥷ¥¿¥ë¥â¥Î¥Ê¥ì¥Ï½ö¾å¥ÎÍýͳ¥Ë°Í¥êÇË´þ¥¹¥Ø¥¥â¥Î¥È¥¹ÏÀ»Ý¥ÏÍýͳ¥¢¥ê¡×
¡Ú³¤¯¡Û
2009ǯ03·î06Æü
¹¾Åì¶è¤Î½÷À»¦³²»ö·ï(À±Åç»ö·ï¡Ë¤Î¸øȽ¤Ç¸¡»¡´±¤ÏÀÚÃǤµ¤ì¤¿Èï³²¼Ô¤ÎÆùÊÒ¤ä¹üÊҤμ̿¿£²£°£°Ëç°Ê¾å¤òË¡ÄîÆâ¤Î¥â¥Ë¥¿¡¼¤Ë±Ç¤·¤ÆËÁƬÄĽҤäÈï¹ð¿Í¼ÁÌä¤ò¹Ô¤¤¡¢»Ð¤Î¾Ú¿Í¿ÒÌä¤Ç¤ÏÈï³²¼Ô¤Î¸µµ¤¤À¤Ã¤¿¤³¤í¤Î¥¹¥Ê¥Ã¥×¼Ì¿¿¤ò»È¤Ã¤¿¥¹¥é¥¤¥É¥·¥ç¡¼¤ò¹Ô¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£ÊóÆ»¤Ë¤è¤ë¤È¡¢¤³¤ì¤é¤Ï¡ÖºÛȽ°÷À©ÅÙ¤ò¶¯¤¯°Õ¼±¤·¤¿Î©¾Ú¡×¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡ÊÆüËܷкѿ·Ê¹1·î26Æüͼ´©21ÊÇ¡Ë¡¢ÅìµþÃϸ¡¤Ï¤³¤Î¸øȽ¤òºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Î¥â¥Ç¥ë¤È°ÌÃ֤Ť±¡¢¡ÖºÛȽ°÷¤Ë¤âË¡Äî¤Ç¸«¤Æ¤â¤é¤¦¤È¤¤¤¦¥á¥Ã¥»¡¼¥¸¤ò¹þ¤á¤¿¡×¤ÈÀâÌÀ¤·¤¿¤½¤¦¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡ÊMSN»º·Ð¥Ë¥å¡¼¥¹2009ǯ1·î20Æühttp://www.iza.ne.jp/news/newsarticle/event/trial/214068/¡Ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢ºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Ç¤Ï¤³¤¦¤·¤¿¿Í¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ÆÍýÀŪ¤ÊȽÃǤò¸í¤é¤»¤ë²ÄǽÀ¤Î¤¢¤ë¾Úµò¤ÎÍøÍѤϿµ½Å¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Ç濳ºÛȽ¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤Ç¤Ï¤³¤¦¤·¤¿¾Úµò¤ÎÍøÍѤòºÛȽ´±¤¬µñÈݤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ÏÄÁ¤·¤¯¤Ê¤¤¡£¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¸½¹ÔË¡¤Î±¿ÍѤȤ·¤Æ¤³¤¦¤·¤¿¾Úµò¤òÇÓ½ü¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï²Äǽ¤Ê¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤¦¤¹¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë
ºÛȽ¤ÇÄó½Ð¤µ¤ì¤ë¾Úµò¤ÏʶÁè¤Î²ò·è¤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£ºÛȽ¤ÇÁè¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë»ö¼Â¤Î²òÌÀ¤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ½é¤á¤Æ¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î»ñ³Ê¤¬¤¢¤ë¡£¤¿¤È¤¨¤Ð¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤ò»¦¤·¤¿¤Î¤«¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î¹Ô°Ù¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤ÏË´¤¯¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤«¡¢ÈȹԤϷײèŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤«¡¢¾×ưŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤«¡£»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤ÎÁ°¤ËÄó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬µö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê»ö¼Â¤Î¸ÈݤÎǧÄê¤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Áʾ٤ε¢·ë¤Ë±Æ¶Á¤òÍ¿¤¨¤ë»ö¼Â¤Î³¸Á³À¤ò¹â¤á¤¿¤êÄã¤á¤¿¤ê¤¹¤ë·¹¸þ¤ò»ý¤Ä¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï»È¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê·¹¸þ¤Î¤³¤È¤òˡΧ²È¤Ï¡Ö´ØÏ¢À¡×(¡Èrelevance¡É)¡¢¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï¼¡¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤ë¡ÖˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¡×¤È¶èÊ̤¹¤ë°ÕÌ£¤Ç¡¢¡Ö¼«Á³Åª´ØÏ¢À¡×(¡Ènatural relevance¡É)¤È¸Æ¤ó¤Ç¤¤¤ë¡£
»ö¼Â¤Î¸ÈݤÎȽÃǤË¿¾¯¤Ê¤ê¤È¤â±Æ¶Á¤òµÚ¤Ü¤¹¤â¤Î¡½¡½¼«Á³Åª´ØÏ¢À¤Î¤¢¤ë¾Úµò¡½¡½¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤ò¸«Ê¹¤¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆµÑ¤Ã¤Æ»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤ò¿¿Á꤫¤é±ó¤¶¤±¤ë´í¸±À¤Î¤¢¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤¬Â¸ºß¤¹¤ë¡£¤¿¤È¤¨¤Ð¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ä°É¾¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ê¾Úµò¤Ï¡¢¤¤¤Þµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ëÈȺá¤Î¾ÚÌÀ¤Ë¤È¤Ã¤Æ¿¾¯¤Î°ÕÌ£¤ò»ý¤Ä¤«¤â¤·¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÆÃÄê¤ÎÈȺá¤òÈȤ·¤¿¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î°ÕÌ£¤Ï¾®¤µ¤¤¡£¤½¤ÎȾÌÌ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ëͽÃǤäÊ諤ò¤â¤¿¤é¤·¡¢¤µ¤é¤ËºÛȽ¤ÎÁèÅÀ¤òº®Í𤵤»¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤â¤Ê¤ê¤«¤Í¤Ê¤¤¡£¤À¤«¤éÁ°²Ê¤ä°É¾¤Ïµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ëÈȺá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï»È¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£°ìÈÌŪ¤Ë¡¢Áʾ٤ε¢·ë¤Ë±Æ¶Á¤òÍ¿¤¨¤ë»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤ËÌòΩ¤ÄÄøÅ١ʾڵò²ÁÃ͡ˤȤ½¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¤â¤¿¤é¤µ¤ì¤ëͽÃÇ¡¦Êи«¡¢ÁèÅÀ¤Îº®Íð¡¢½ÅÊ£¡¦»þ´Ö¤Î̵Â̤Ȥ¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤ÊÊÀ³²¤ÎÄøÅÙ¤òÈæ³Ó¤·¤Æ¡¢¸å¼Ô¤ÎÊÀ³²¤¬Á°¼Ô¤Î²ÁÃͤè¤ê¤â¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ë½Å¤¤¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤òºÛȽ¤Ç»È¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤³¤Î²ÁÃͤÈÊÀ³²¤ÎÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤ηë²Ì¤òˡΧ²È¤Ï¡ÖˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¡×(¡Èlegal relevance¡É)¤È¸À¤¤¡¢Ë¡Î§Åª´ØÏ¢À¤¬¡Ö¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¤«¡Ö¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¤«¸À¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¾Úµò¤ÎºÎÈݤò·è¤á¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤Ç¤Ï¡¢Ï¢Ë®¤Ç¤â½£¤Ç¤â¡¢¤³¤Î¼«Á³Åª´ØÏ¢À¤ÈˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤¬À©ÄêË¡¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÄê¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡ÊÎ㤨¤Ð¡¢Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§401¡¢403¡Ë¡£ÆüËܤˤϴØÏ¢À¤Î°ìÈ̸¶Íý¤òÄê¤á¤¿¾òʸ¤Ï¸ºß¤·¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤¢¤ë»ñÎÁ¤¬¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÛȽ¤ÇÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡Ö´ØÏ¢À¡×¤¬É¬ÍפǤ¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¹Í¤¨¤ÏÀΤ«¤é¼Â̳¤Çǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢Á°²Ê¤ä°À³Ê¤ÏÈȺáǧÄê¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤ÏÂ翳±¡°ÊÍè¤ÎȽÎã¤Ç¤â¤¢¤ë¡ÊÂçȽ¾¼2¡¦9¡¦3¿·Ê¹2750¡Ý9¡¢Ï²λ³ÃÏ·èÊ¿13¡¦10¡¦10Ƚ¥¿1122¡Ý132¡Ë¡£¤À¤«¤é¡ÖˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ç¤â°ìÈÌŪ¤Ë¾µÇ§¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¡£Áʾٴط¸¿Í¤¬¡Ö»ö·ï¤Ë´Ø·¸¤Î¤Ê¤¤»ö¹à¡×¤ä¡Ö½ÅÊ£¡×¤¹¤ë»ö¹à¤ÎÄĽҤò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òÀ©¸Â¤·¡¢Åö»ö¼Ô¤¬ËÁƬÄĽҤǡÖÊи«Ëô¤ÏͽÃǤòÀ¸¤¼¤·¤á¤ë¶ó¤Î¤¢¤ë»ö¹à¡×¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¶Ø»ß¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ëˡΧ¤Î¾òʸ¡Ê·º»öÁʾÙË¡295¾ò¡¢296¾ò¡Ë¤Ë´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ÎÀ©ÄêË¡¾å¤Îº¬µò¤òǧ¤á¤ë¹Í¤¨¤â¤¢¤ë¡£
´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¾Úµò
¤µ¤Æ¡¢¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤Î·º»öºÛȽ¤Ç¤Ï¡¢Ë¡Î§Åª´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¡½¡½¾Úµò²ÁÃͤÈÊÀ³²¤ÎÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎÌ¡½¡½¤¬Å¬ÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤Ù¤Åµ·¿Åª¤Ê¾ìÌ̤ΰì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢¡Ö´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¾Úµò¡×(inflammatory evidence)¤ÎÌäÂ꤬¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤Ð¤·¤ÐÌäÂê¤È¤Ê¤ë¤Î¤¬¡¢»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëÈï³²¼Ô¤ÎÉåÇÔ¤·¤¿¤ê¹ó¤¯Â»½ý¤·¤¿»àÂΤμ̿¿¤ä²ò˶¼Ì¿¿¡¢¤½¤·¤Æ¤½¤ì¤ÈÂÐÈ椵¤»¤é¤ì¤ëÀ¸Á°¤ÎÈï³²¼Ô¤Î·ò¹¯Åª¤Ê¼Ì¿¿¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
Ç濳°÷¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¼Ì¿¿¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤ÏÇÓ½ü¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£ºÛȽ´±¤Ï¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤¬Ç濳¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ÆÍýÀŪ¤ÊȽÃǤò˸¤²¤ë´í¸±À¤ÎÅٹ礤¤È¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Î¤¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î²ÁÃͤòÈæ³Ó¸¡Æ¤¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¾Úµò²ÁÃͤè¤ê¤â´í¸±À¤ÎÊý¤¬¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ë¾å²ó¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Ï¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤òºÎÍѤ»¤ºÇ濳¤Ë¸«¤»¤Ê¤¤¡½¡½¾ÚµòÇÓ½ü¤¹¤ë¡½¡½¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î´í¸±À¤È²ÁÃͤÎÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤ϺÛȽ´±¤ÎºÛÎÌŪ¤ÊȽÃǤȤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¾åÁÊ¿³¤Î¿³ºº¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤ÎȽÃǤϺ½Å¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢È½ÃǤθí¤ê¤ÎÄøÅÙ¤¬Â礤¤¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ºÛÎ̸¢¤òÍôÍѤ·¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸øÀµ¤ÊºÛȽ¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¸¢Íø¤ò¿¯³²¤·¤¿¤È¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£
¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤ÎȽÎ㽸¤Ë¤Ï¤³¤ÎÌäÂê¤òÏÀ¤¸¤¿È½Î㤬¤¿¤¯¤µ¤ó¤¢¤ë¡£1979ǯ¤Î¥«¥ó¥µ¥¹½£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÎã¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¥±¡¼¥¹¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Î¸øȽ¤Ç¸¡»¡´±¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤Î°äÂΤμ̿¿14Ëç¤òÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Î°ìËç¤Ï²ò˶¼Ì¿¿¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡Ö³Ü¤«¤é¸Ô´Ö¤Ë¤«¤±¤ÆÀڤ곫¤«¤ì¡¢Â¡Êª¤òÈ´¤¼è¤é¤ì¤¿¿©Æù²Ã¹©¾ì¤Îµí¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë²£¤¿¤¨¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¶»¤ÎÈé¤Î°ìÉô¤Ï°äÂΤδé¤òʤ¤¤¡¢¶»Éô¤ÈÊ¢Éô¤Î¡´ï¤¬Çø¤±½Ð¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡£¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¤ÏÈï³²¼Ô¤Î»à°ø¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¼Â¼ÁŪ¤ËÁè¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤ª¤é¤º¡¢À¯Éܦ¤ÎÀìÌç²È¾Ú¿Í¤¬»à°ø¤Ï¿Ïʪ¤Î»É¤·½ý¤Ë¤è¤ë½Ð·ì»à¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤ÈÌÀ¸À¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£³Î¤«¤Ë¤¤¤¯¤Ä¤«¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤Ï¶§´ï¤¬ÂÎÆâ¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿³ÑÅ٤俼¤µ¤òÇ濳¤¬È½ÃǤ¹¤ë½õ¤±¤Ë¤Ï¤Ê¤ë¤¬¡¢Æ±¤¸ÅÀ¤ò½Å¤Í¤ÆΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë²ò˶¼Ì¿¿¤ò²¿Ëç¤â¸«¤ëɬÍ×À¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤³¤¦½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¡¢ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡Ö¤³¤Î¾Úµò¤ÎÍ£°ì¤Î²Äǽ¤ÊÌÜŪ¤Ï¡¢Ç濳°÷¤Î¿´¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡×¤È·ëÏÀ¤·¡¢ÍºáȽ·è¤òÇË´þ¤·¤Æº¹¤·Ìᤷ¤¿¡£State v. Boyd, 532 P.2d 1064 (Kan. 1975), at1068.
¶¯Å𻦿ͤθ½¾ì¤Ë²£¤¿¤ï¤ëÈï³²¼Ô¤Î¼Ì¿¿¡½¡½¡ÖÈï³²¼Ô¤ÎÇ˲õ¤µ¤ì¤¿´é¡¢Æ¬Éô¤Î½ý¡¢·ìº¯¡¢¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢Àã¤Î¾å¤ÎƬ¤Î¼þ°Ï¤Ë»¶¤é¤Ð¤ëÆùÊÒ¤ÈǾ¤Î°ìÉô¡×¡½¡½¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡¢ÁÊÄɦ¤Ï¡¢½Æ¤ÇƬÉô¤ò·â¤¿¤ì¤¿¤È¤Èï³²¼Ô¤ÎƬÉô¤¬ÃÏÌ̤˶ᤤ°ÌÃ֤ˤ¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¡¢¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¶¯Å𤬽ª¤ï¤Ã¤¿¸å¤ËÈï³²¼Ô¤ò»¦³²¤¹¤ë¤À¤±¤ÎÌÜŪ¤Ç»¦¿Í¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¤³¤È¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤ËɬÍפǤ¢¤ë¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢¥Ú¥ó¥·¥ë¥Ù¥Ë¥¢½£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤³¤Î¼çÄ¥¤òÂऱ¤¿¡£
¡Ö¼Ì¿¿¤¬´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¤â¤Î(inflammatory)¤È¤ß¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ÎËܼÁŪ¤Ê¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¹âÅ٤Τâ¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤ì¤ò¼èÄ´¤Ù¤ëɬÍ×À¤¬¡¢Ç濳¤ÎÀº¿À¤È¾ð½ï¤ò¤«¤Í𤹲ÄǽÀ¤òÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ë¾å²ó¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤Î¤«¤É¤¦¤«¤òÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎÌ(balancing test)¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¡Ä¡Ä³Î¤«¤Ë¡¢¥Ú¥ó¥·¥ë¥Ù¥Ë¥¢½£·Ù»¡¤Î¥Þ¥³¥â¥ó¥º·º»ö¤Ï¸øȽ¤Ç¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ò¸«¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤¬·â¤¿¤ì¤¿¤È¤¡¢¤½¤ÎƬÉô¤ÏÃÏÌ̤˶ᤤ¤È¤³¤í¤ÇÃÏÌ̤ÈÊ¿¹Ô¤Î¾õÂÖ¤À¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦°Õ¸«¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢·º»ö¤Ï¤½¤¦¾Ú¸À¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ò¸«¤ëɬÍפϤʤ«¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤Ê¤¼¤Ê¤é¡¢Èà¤Ï»ö·ï¸å¤Ë¸½¾ì¤Ç»àÂΤȤ½¤Î¾õÂÖ¤ò´Ñ»¡¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤«¤é¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¼ÂºÝ¤Î¤È¤³¤í¡¢¥Þ¥³¥â¥ó¥º·º»ö¤Ï¡¢¤ï¤¶¤ï¤¶¼Ì¿¿¤ò¸«¤Ê¤¯¤Æ¤â¼ÂºÝ¤Ë¸«¤¿¤³¤È¤ò½Ò¤Ù¡¢¼«¤é¤Î´Ñ»¡¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¤¤Æ°Õ¸«¤ò¸À¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡×Commonwealth v. Rogers, 401 A.2d 329 (Pa. 1979), at 330.
È¿ÂФˡ¢¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤Î¿È¸µ¤ä»à°ø¤òÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ë¤·¤¿¤ê¡¢¤µ¤é¤Ë¤ÏÈȹÔÂÖÍͤäÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°Õ¿Þ¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤò¤â¤Á¡¢¤½¤Î²ÁÃͤ¬Ç濳¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ÆÍýÀŪ¤ÊȽÃǤò˸¤²¤ë´í¸±À¤è¤ê¤âÂ礤¤¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¡£See, e.g., State v. Needs, 591 P.2d 130 (Idaho 1979); State v. Watts, 441 N.W. 2d 395 (Iowa 1989).
Èï³²¼Ô¤ÎÀ¸Á°¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢Æ±Íͤξڵò²ÁÃͤȥꥹ¥¯¤ÎÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¡£Èï³²¼Ô¤Î¿È¸µ¤ä¿ÈĹ¤Ê¤É¤Î¿ÈÂÎŪÆÃħ¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤ¬¤¢¤ë¾ì¹ç¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤¬¡¢Ç濳¤Î´¶¾ð¤ËÁʤ¨¤ë¤À¤±¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢µöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£See, e.g., Ricci v. State, P.2d 79 (Nev. 1975); State v. Finch, 975 P.2d 967 (Wash. 1999).
À±Åç»ö·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç
ˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤¬¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤âÂÅÅö¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ÏÀè¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤¿Ä̤ê¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¿Í¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë»àÂΤμ̿¿¤Ï¤ä¤Ï¤ê¡¢ÆüËܿͤδ¶¾ð¤ò¤â¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¤À¤í¤¦¡£¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤ÎºÛȽ´±¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤Èæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤òÆüËܤκÛȽ´±¤â¤ä¤é¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
À±Åç»ö·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¤É¤¦¤Ê¤ë¤À¤í¤¦¤«¡£¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤Ï»¦¿Í¤È»àÂλ²õ°ä´þ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏÁÊ°ø¤òÁ´¤¯Áè¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£À±Åçµ®ÆÁ»á¤ÏÅì¾ëÎÜÍþ¹á¤µ¤ó¤ò»¦¤·¤Æ¤½¤Î»àÂΤò¥Ð¥é¥Ð¥é¤ËÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤ó¤Ç¼Î¤Æ¤¿¤³¤È¤òÁè¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£Èï³²¼Ô¤Î¿È¸µ¤âÁèÅÀ¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤ÎÆùÊÒ¤ä¹üÊҤμ̿¿¤äÈà½÷¤ÎÀ¸Á°¤Î¥¹¥Ê¥Ã¥×¼Ì¿¿¤Ï¡¢ÁÊ°ø¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï¤Û¤È¤ó¤É²ÁÃͤ¬¤Ê¤¤¡£
ÁÊ°ø¤ò΢ÉÕ¤±¤ëµÒ´ÑŪ¤Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¹ü¤äÆùÊҤʤɤÎʪŪ¾Úµò¤¬É¬ÍפÀ¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤òȯ¸«¤·¤¿Áܺº´±¤Î¶¡½Ò¤ä¤½¤ì¤é¤ÎDNA´ÕÄê¤ò¤·¤¿ÀìÌç²È¤Î°Õ¸«¤¬¤¢¤ì¤Ð½½Ê¬¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤à¤·¤í¤½¤ì¤é¤ÎÊý¤¬¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¹â¤¤¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¤³¤ì¤é¤Ï¤¹¤Ç¤Ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¼è¤êÄ´¤Ù¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
¤½¤ì¤Ç¤Ï¡¢¤³¤ì¤é¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ÏÎÌ·º»ö¾ð¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤò»ý¤Ä¤À¤í¤¦¤«¡£¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¤ÏÎÌ·º¡½¡½»à·º¤Ë¤¹¤Ù¤¤«¤É¤¦¤«¡½¡½¤¬¤Þ¤µ¤ËÁèÅÀ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤À¤«¤é¡¢ÎÜÍþ¹á¤µ¤ó¤ÎÆùÊÒ¤ä¹üÊÒ¤äÀ¸Á°¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤¬Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë»à·º¤òÁªÂò¤µ¤»¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤò»ý¤Ä¤Ê¤é¤Ð¡¢¤½¤ì¤òºÎÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤âµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤À¤í¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤ì¤é¤Î¾Úµò¤¬»à·ºÁªÂò¤Î¤¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤò»ý¤Ä¤³¤È¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤¨¤Ê¤¤¡£
ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¸¡»¡Â¦¤Ï»à·º¤òÀµÅö²½¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Î¡ÖÈȹÔÂÖÍͤλĵԤµ¡×¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤È¤·¤Æ¤³¤ì¤é¤Î¾Úµò¤¬É¬ÍפÀ¤È¸À¤¦¤Î¤«¤â¤·¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢»à·º¤ÎŬÍÑ´ð½à¤ò¼¨¤·¤¿±Ê»³»ö·ïºÇ¹âºÛȽ·è¤¬´ð½à¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ·Ç¤²¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡Ö»¦³²¤Î¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤Î¼¹Ù¹À¡¦»ÄµÔÀ¡×¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢»àÂΤνèÍýÊýË¡¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÏÌäÂê¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡ÊºÇ2¾®È½¾¼58¡¦7¡¦8·º½¸37¡¾6¡¾609¡Ë¡£¹ü¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤Ë¤·¤íÆùÊҤμ̿¿¤Ë¤·¤í¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤Ï¤¹¤Ù¤Æ»àÂλ²õ¤ÎÂÖÍͤò¼¨¤¹¤â¤Î¤Ë¤¹¤®¤Ê¤¤¡£À±Åç»á¤ÏÎÜÍþ¹á¤µ¤ó¤Î¼ó¤ËÊñÃú¤ò»É¤·¤Æ»¦³²¤·¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢À¸¤¤Æ¤¤¤ëÈà½÷¤òÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤ó¤Ç»¦¤·¤¿¤ï¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£
ºÇ¹âºÛ¤Ï¡ÖÈȹԸå¤Î¾ð¾õ¡×¤ò»à·ºÅ¬ÍÑ´ð½à¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æµó¤²¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢»àÂλ²õ¤ÎÊýË¡¤Ï¤³¤ì¤Ë´Þ¤á¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£¤Ê¤¼¤Ê¤é¡¢»àÂλ²õºá¤Ï»¦¿Í¤È¤ÏÊ̤ÎÈȺá¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊýË¡¤Ç»àÂΤò½ýÉÕ¤±¤Æ¤âĨÌò3ǯ¤òĶ¤¨¤ëÎÌ·º¤ò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£Ë¡Î§¤Ï¤½¤ì¤òµö¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡Ê·ºË¡190¾ò¡Ë¡£¤È¤¦¤Æ¤¤»à·º¤òÀµÅö²½¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£
Èï³²¼Ô¤ÎÀ¸Á°¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤Ï¡¢»¦¿Í¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¼º¤ï¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤¬²¿¤À¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤«¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤À¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢»¦¿Íºá¤ÎÎÌ·º¤òÀµÅö²½¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ï¿Í¤ÎÌ¿¤òÃ¥¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¿Í¤¬¶ñÂÎŪ¤Ë¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿ÍÀ¸¤òÊâ¤ó¤Ç¤¤¤¿¤Î¤«¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Ëº¹¤¬½Ð¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïº£Æü¤Î¼Ò²ñ¤Ç¤ÏÀµÅö²½¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£²È²¤ä»Å»ö¤Ë·Ã¤Þ¤ì¹¬Ê¡¤Ê¿ÍÀ¸¤òÁ÷¤Ã¤¿¿Í¤ò»¦¤·¤¿¾ì¹ç¤È¡¢°Å¤¯À¨»´¤ÊÀ¸³è¤ò½Å¤Í¤Æ¤¤¿¿Í¤ò»¦¤·¤¿¾ì¹ç¤È¤Ç¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Ëº¹¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤ÆÎɤ¤¤È¤¤¤¦Íý¶þ¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£
Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëÈï³²¼Ô¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ÎÍøÍѤϤ¤¤º¤ì¤â¡¢Áʾ٤ÎÁèÅÀ¤òÍýÀŪ¤Ë²ò·è¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤ì¤é¤Ï»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Î´¶¾ð¤ËÁʤ¨¤ë¤À¤±¤Î°ÕÌ£¤·¤«¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¡ÖˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¡×¤¬Å¬ÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤Ê¤é¤Ð¡¢¤³¤ÎºÛȽ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤ÎÆùÊÒ¤ä¹üÊÒ¤½¤·¤ÆÀ¸Á°¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤òÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
ËÁƬÄĽҤäÊÛÏÀ¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¼Ì¿¿¤ÎÍøÍÑ
²¾¤Ë¼Ì¿¿¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤¿¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤òËÁƬÄĽҤäºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Ç¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë»È¤Ã¤Æ¤âÎɤ¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£Ë¡Î§Åª´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ÆºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤¿¼Ì¿¿¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤â¡¢ºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Ç¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤òËÜÍè¤ÎÌÜŪ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë»È¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¤¿¤á¤ËÍѤ¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢¤½¤Î¼ê³¤Ï°ãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤â¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤Ë¤Ï¤¤¤¯¤Ä¤«¤ÎÀèÎ㤬¤¢¤ë¡£¶¯Åð»ö·ï¤ÎºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Ç¸¡»¡´±¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤Î»àÂΡÊÈï³²¼Ô¤Ï»ö·ï¤Î¸å¤Ë¾»¦ÂΤÇȯ¸«¤µ¤ì¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï»¦¿Í¤Ç¤Ïµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£¡Ë¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ò¼¨¤·¤Æ¡Ö¥¸¥ç¥ó¡¦¥¦¥£¥ê¥¢¥à¥º[Èï³²¼Ô]¤Ï¤â¤Ï¤ä¤³¤ÎÀ¤¤Ë¤Ï¤¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Èà¤Ï¤Þ¤µ¤Ë¿ÍÀ¸¤Î²Ö¤Î»þÂå¤òÃ¥¤ï¤ì¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡×¤È½Ò¤Ù¤¿¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡¢¥¤¥ó¥Ç¥£¥¢¥Ê½£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ì¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸øÀµ¤ÊºÛȽ¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¸¢Íø¤òÃ¥¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤·¤ÆͺáȽ·è¤òÇË´þ¤·¤¿¡£
¡Ö¤³¤ì¤Ï»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¾åÁʿͤˤè¤ë¶¯Åð»ö·ï¤ÎÀ®Èݤ¬Ìä¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡Ä¡Ä¥¦¥£¥ê¥¢¥à¥º¤Î»àÂΤμ̿¿¤ò¼¨¤·¤Æ¡¢Èà¤Î»à¤ÎÀÕǤ¤¬¾åÁʿͤˤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¶¯Ä´¤¹¤ë¸¡»¡´±¤ÎÇ®¶¸Åª¤ÊºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Ï¡¢¾åÁʿͤ¬¸øÀµ¤ÊºÛȽ¤ò¼õ¤±¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤È¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ë¿®¤¸¤µ¤»¤ë¾õ¶·¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡×Adler v. State, N.E.2d 171 (Ind. 1967), at 173.
À±Åç»ö·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤¬Íºá̵ºá¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤Ï¤¹¤Ç¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢ËÁƬÄĽҤÇÈï³²¼Ô¤ÎÆùÊÒ¤ä¹ü¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ò¼¨¤·¤Æ¡Ö¤³¤ì¤Ï¡Ä¡ÄÁܺ÷¤Ç¸«¤Ä¤«¤Ã¤¿ÆùÊҤΰìÉô¤Ç¤¹¡£¿¿¤óÃæ¤Î¤¯¤Ü¤ó¤À½ê¤Ï¤ª¤Ø¤½¤Ç¤¹¡£¤Ø¤½¤Î¾å¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Åì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤¬À¸Á°³«¤±¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¥Ô¥¢¥¹¤Î·ê¤È°ìÃפ·¤Þ¤¹¡£¡Ä¡Ä²¼¤Ë±Ç¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¥á¥¸¥ã¡¼¤«¤é¤âʬ¤«¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¤¹¤Ù¤Æ£µ¥»¥ó¥Á³ÑÄøÅÙ¤ËÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤Þ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤³¤ì¤Ï¡¢»Ø¤Î°ìÉô¤Ç¤¹¡×¤Ê¤É¤È½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡ÊMSN»º·Ð¥Ë¥å¡¼¥¹1·î13Æühttp://www.iza.ne.jp/news/newsarticle/event/trial/212005/¡Ë¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤ÏºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤ÎÃæ¤Ç¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤Î°äÂΤ¬ÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤Þ¤ì¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¤³¤È¤µ¤é¤Ë¶¯Ä´¤·¤¿¡£
¡Ö[À±ÅçÈï¹ð¤Ï]Åì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤Î¼ê¤«¤éÆù¤ò¤½¤®¼è¤ê¡¢¤Þ¤ÊÈĤξå¤ÇÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤ß¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¤½¤ÎÍâÈդˤϡ¢Åì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤ÎƹÂΤ«¤éÊ¢¤ä¶»¤ÎÆù¤ò¤½¤®¼è¤ê¡¢Â¡´ï¤ò¤Þ¤ÊÈĤξå¤ÇÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤ß¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¤µ¤é¤ËÍâÈÕ¡Ä¡¢¼ª¤ò¤½¤®¡¢Æ¬³¸¹ü¡Ê¤º¤¬¤¤¤³¤Ä¡Ë¤ò¤Î¤³¤®¤ê¤ÇÀÚ¤ê¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¹ü¤Ï¥´¥ßÂÞ¤ËÆþ¤ì¤Æ±£¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢Éå¤é¤»¤Æ¶¯Îõ¤ÊÉ彤¬È¯À¸¤·¤¿¤¿¤á¡¢ÈȹԤ¬È¯³Ð¤·¤Ê¤¤¤è¤¦¤ËÆé¤Ç¤æ¤Ç¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£À±ÅçÈï¹ð¤ÏÅì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤Î°äÂΤò¡¢¼«¸Ê¤ÎÀ¸³è¤ÈÂÎÌ̤ò¼é¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¼Ù°¤Ê¡Èʪ¡É¤È¤·¤Æ̵»Ä¤Ë°·¤¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¡×¡Ö£±¥«·î°Ê¾å¤â±ø¿å¤Î¿åή¤ËÂѤ¨¤¿¹üÊҤϡ¢Ç¦ÂѶ¯¤«¤Ã¤¿Åì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤Î²ù¤·¤µ¡¢ÌµÇ°¤µ¤òÁʤ¨¤«¤±¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤«¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ç¤¹¡£¡×MSN»º·Ð¥Ë¥å¡¼¥¹2009ǯ1·î26Æü¡¢http://sankei.jp.msn.com/affairs/trial/090126/trl0901261449015-n1.htm
¤³¤ÎºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Î°Õ¿Þ¤Ï¡¢»à·ºÁªÂò¤Î´ð½à¤Ë¾È¤é¤·¤ÆËÜ·ï¤Ç¤Ï»à·º¤òÁªÂò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¹çÍýŪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òÏÀ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Ædz¤¨À¹¤ëÅܤê¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯È½ÃǤòµá¤á¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊÛÏÀ¤Ï¸øÀµ¤ÊºÛȽ¤ÎÂжˤˤ¢¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
·ëÏÀ
¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç¤Î·º»öºÛȽ¤Ï¡¢¡ÖºÛȽ´±¤Ï¥×¥í¥Õ¥§¥Ã¥·¥ç¥Ê¥ë¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢´¶¾ð¤Ëή¤µ¤ì¤ºÍýÀŪ¤ËºÛȽ¤ò¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦Á°Äó¤Ç¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£¤³¤ÎÁ°Äó¤¬Àµ¤·¤¤¤Î¤«¤ÏÂ礤¤Ëµ¿Ì䤬¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤ÎȽÃǤò¤¹¤ë¤Î¤¬Åö¤ÎºÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢¡Ö¤³¤Î¾Úµò¤ÏºÛȽ´±¡Ê¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¼«Ê¬¼«¿È¡Ë¤ÎÍýÀ¤ò¶¸¤ï¤»¤ë¡×¤Ê¤É¤È¤¤¤¦¥¹¥È¥¤¥Ã¥¯¤Ê¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ÎŬÍѤò´üÂÔ¤¹¤Ù¤¯¤â¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢ºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Ç¤Ï¤³¤Î¥Õ¥£¥¯¥·¥ç¥ó¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ë¡£É¾µÄ¼¼¤ÎÃæ¤ÇÀµµÁ¤ÈÍýÀ¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯É¾µÄ¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Ë¡Äî¤ËÄó½Ð¤µ¤ì¤ë¾Úµò¤ÎÁªÊ̤¬É¬ÍפǤ¢¤ë¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢ºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤¬À®¸ù¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Ë¡Î§²È¤¬¾ÚµòË¡¤Î¸·³Ê¤ÊŬÍѤ˰դòÍѤ¤¤ë¤³¤È¤¬ÉԲķç¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
°Ê¾å
´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë
ºÛȽ¤ÇÄó½Ð¤µ¤ì¤ë¾Úµò¤ÏʶÁè¤Î²ò·è¤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£ºÛȽ¤ÇÁè¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë»ö¼Â¤Î²òÌÀ¤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ½é¤á¤Æ¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î»ñ³Ê¤¬¤¢¤ë¡£¤¿¤È¤¨¤Ð¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤ò»¦¤·¤¿¤Î¤«¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Î¹Ô°Ù¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤ÏË´¤¯¤Ê¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤«¡¢ÈȹԤϷײèŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤«¡¢¾×ưŪ¤Ê¤â¤Î¤«¡£»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤ÎÁ°¤ËÄó½Ð¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬µö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡¢¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê»ö¼Â¤Î¸ÈݤÎǧÄê¤ËÌòΩ¤Ä¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢Áʾ٤ε¢·ë¤Ë±Æ¶Á¤òÍ¿¤¨¤ë»ö¼Â¤Î³¸Á³À¤ò¹â¤á¤¿¤êÄã¤á¤¿¤ê¤¹¤ë·¹¸þ¤ò»ý¤Ä¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï»È¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê·¹¸þ¤Î¤³¤È¤òˡΧ²È¤Ï¡Ö´ØÏ¢À¡×(¡Èrelevance¡É)¡¢¤¢¤ë¤¤¤Ï¼¡¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤ë¡ÖˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¡×¤È¶èÊ̤¹¤ë°ÕÌ£¤Ç¡¢¡Ö¼«Á³Åª´ØÏ¢À¡×(¡Ènatural relevance¡É)¤È¸Æ¤ó¤Ç¤¤¤ë¡£
»ö¼Â¤Î¸ÈݤÎȽÃǤË¿¾¯¤Ê¤ê¤È¤â±Æ¶Á¤òµÚ¤Ü¤¹¤â¤Î¡½¡½¼«Á³Åª´ØÏ¢À¤Î¤¢¤ë¾Úµò¡½¡½¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤ò¸«Ê¹¤¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆµÑ¤Ã¤Æ»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤ò¿¿Á꤫¤é±ó¤¶¤±¤ë´í¸±À¤Î¤¢¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤¬Â¸ºß¤¹¤ë¡£¤¿¤È¤¨¤Ð¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÎÁ°²Ê¤ä°É¾¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ê¾Úµò¤Ï¡¢¤¤¤Þµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ëÈȺá¤Î¾ÚÌÀ¤Ë¤È¤Ã¤Æ¿¾¯¤Î°ÕÌ£¤ò»ý¤Ä¤«¤â¤·¤ì¤Ê¤¤¤¬¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤¬ÆÃÄê¤ÎÈȺá¤òÈȤ·¤¿¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î°ÕÌ£¤Ï¾®¤µ¤¤¡£¤½¤ÎȾÌÌ¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤ËÂФ¹¤ëͽÃǤäÊ諤ò¤â¤¿¤é¤·¡¢¤µ¤é¤ËºÛȽ¤ÎÁèÅÀ¤òº®Í𤵤»¤ë¤³¤È¤Ë¤â¤Ê¤ê¤«¤Í¤Ê¤¤¡£¤À¤«¤éÁ°²Ê¤ä°É¾¤Ïµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ëÈȺá¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï»È¤¨¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£°ìÈÌŪ¤Ë¡¢Áʾ٤ε¢·ë¤Ë±Æ¶Á¤òÍ¿¤¨¤ë»ö¼Â¤ÎǧÄê¤ËÌòΩ¤ÄÄøÅ١ʾڵò²ÁÃ͡ˤȤ½¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¤â¤¿¤é¤µ¤ì¤ëͽÃÇ¡¦Êи«¡¢ÁèÅÀ¤Îº®Íð¡¢½ÅÊ£¡¦»þ´Ö¤Î̵Â̤Ȥ¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤ÊÊÀ³²¤ÎÄøÅÙ¤òÈæ³Ó¤·¤Æ¡¢¸å¼Ô¤ÎÊÀ³²¤¬Á°¼Ô¤Î²ÁÃͤè¤ê¤â¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ë½Å¤¤¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤òºÛȽ¤Ç»È¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤³¤Î²ÁÃͤÈÊÀ³²¤ÎÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤ηë²Ì¤òˡΧ²È¤Ï¡ÖˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¡×(¡Èlegal relevance¡É)¤È¸À¤¤¡¢Ë¡Î§Åª´ØÏ¢À¤¬¡Ö¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¤«¡Ö¤Ê¤¤¡×¤È¤«¸À¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¾Úµò¤ÎºÎÈݤò·è¤á¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤Ç¤Ï¡¢Ï¢Ë®¤Ç¤â½£¤Ç¤â¡¢¤³¤Î¼«Á³Åª´ØÏ¢À¤ÈˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤¬À©ÄêË¡¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤ÆÄê¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡ÊÎ㤨¤Ð¡¢Ï¢Ë®¾Úµòµ¬Â§401¡¢403¡Ë¡£ÆüËܤˤϴØÏ¢À¤Î°ìÈ̸¶Íý¤òÄê¤á¤¿¾òʸ¤Ï¸ºß¤·¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤¢¤ë»ñÎÁ¤¬¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÛȽ¤ÇÍøÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡Ö´ØÏ¢À¡×¤¬É¬ÍפǤ¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¹Í¤¨¤ÏÀΤ«¤é¼Â̳¤Çǧ¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¤ª¤ê¡¢Á°²Ê¤ä°À³Ê¤ÏÈȺáǧÄê¤Î¾Úµò¤Ë¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤Î¤ÏÂ翳±¡°ÊÍè¤ÎȽÎã¤Ç¤â¤¢¤ë¡ÊÂçȽ¾¼2¡¦9¡¦3¿·Ê¹2750¡Ý9¡¢Ï²λ³ÃÏ·èÊ¿13¡¦10¡¦10Ƚ¥¿1122¡Ý132¡Ë¡£¤À¤«¤é¡ÖˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¥ë¡¼¥ë¤Ï¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ç¤â°ìÈÌŪ¤Ë¾µÇ§¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¡£Áʾٴط¸¿Í¤¬¡Ö»ö·ï¤Ë´Ø·¸¤Î¤Ê¤¤»ö¹à¡×¤ä¡Ö½ÅÊ£¡×¤¹¤ë»ö¹à¤ÎÄĽҤò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤òÀ©¸Â¤·¡¢Åö»ö¼Ô¤¬ËÁƬÄĽҤǡÖÊи«Ëô¤ÏͽÃǤòÀ¸¤¼¤·¤á¤ë¶ó¤Î¤¢¤ë»ö¹à¡×¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¶Ø»ß¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ëˡΧ¤Î¾òʸ¡Ê·º»öÁʾÙË¡295¾ò¡¢296¾ò¡Ë¤Ë´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ÎÀ©ÄêË¡¾å¤Îº¬µò¤òǧ¤á¤ë¹Í¤¨¤â¤¢¤ë¡£
´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¾Úµò
¤µ¤Æ¡¢¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤Î·º»öºÛȽ¤Ç¤Ï¡¢Ë¡Î§Åª´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¡½¡½¾Úµò²ÁÃͤÈÊÀ³²¤ÎÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎÌ¡½¡½¤¬Å¬ÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤Ù¤Åµ·¿Åª¤Ê¾ìÌ̤ΰì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢¡Ö´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¾Úµò¡×(inflammatory evidence)¤ÎÌäÂ꤬¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤Ð¤·¤ÐÌäÂê¤È¤Ê¤ë¤Î¤¬¡¢»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëÈï³²¼Ô¤ÎÉåÇÔ¤·¤¿¤ê¹ó¤¯Â»½ý¤·¤¿»àÂΤμ̿¿¤ä²ò˶¼Ì¿¿¡¢¤½¤·¤Æ¤½¤ì¤ÈÂÐÈ椵¤»¤é¤ì¤ëÀ¸Á°¤ÎÈï³²¼Ô¤Î·ò¹¯Åª¤Ê¼Ì¿¿¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
Ç濳°÷¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¼Ì¿¿¤À¤È¤¤¤¦¤À¤±¤Ç¤ÏÇÓ½ü¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£ºÛȽ´±¤Ï¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤¬Ç濳¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ÆÍýÀŪ¤ÊȽÃǤò˸¤²¤ë´í¸±À¤ÎÅٹ礤¤È¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¤Î¤¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Î²ÁÃͤòÈæ³Ó¸¡Æ¤¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¾Úµò²ÁÃͤè¤ê¤â´í¸±À¤ÎÊý¤¬¼Â¼ÁŪ¤Ë¾å²ó¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Ï¤½¤Î¾Úµò¤òºÎÍѤ»¤ºÇ濳¤Ë¸«¤»¤Ê¤¤¡½¡½¾ÚµòÇÓ½ü¤¹¤ë¡½¡½¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î´í¸±À¤È²ÁÃͤÎÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤ϺÛȽ´±¤ÎºÛÎÌŪ¤ÊȽÃǤȤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢¾åÁÊ¿³¤Î¿³ºº¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤ÎȽÃǤϺ½Å¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢È½ÃǤθí¤ê¤ÎÄøÅÙ¤¬Â礤¤¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ºÛÎ̸¢¤òÍôÍѤ·¤ÆÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸øÀµ¤ÊºÛȽ¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¸¢Íø¤ò¿¯³²¤·¤¿¤È¤µ¤ì¤ë¡£
¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤ÎȽÎ㽸¤Ë¤Ï¤³¤ÎÌäÂê¤òÏÀ¤¸¤¿È½Î㤬¤¿¤¯¤µ¤ó¤¢¤ë¡£1979ǯ¤Î¥«¥ó¥µ¥¹½£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤ÎȽÎã¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¥±¡¼¥¹¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Î¸øȽ¤Ç¸¡»¡´±¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤Î°äÂΤμ̿¿14Ëç¤òÄó½Ð¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢¤½¤Î¤¦¤Á¤Î°ìËç¤Ï²ò˶¼Ì¿¿¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡Ö³Ü¤«¤é¸Ô´Ö¤Ë¤«¤±¤ÆÀڤ곫¤«¤ì¡¢Â¡Êª¤òÈ´¤¼è¤é¤ì¤¿¿©Æù²Ã¹©¾ì¤Îµí¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë²£¤¿¤¨¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¶»¤ÎÈé¤Î°ìÉô¤Ï°äÂΤδé¤òʤ¤¤¡¢¶»Éô¤ÈÊ¢Éô¤Î¡´ï¤¬Çø¤±½Ð¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤¿¡£¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¤ÏÈï³²¼Ô¤Î»à°ø¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤Ï¼Â¼ÁŪ¤ËÁè¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤ª¤é¤º¡¢À¯Éܦ¤ÎÀìÌç²È¾Ú¿Í¤¬»à°ø¤Ï¿Ïʪ¤Î»É¤·½ý¤Ë¤è¤ë½Ð·ì»à¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤ÈÌÀ¸À¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£³Î¤«¤Ë¤¤¤¯¤Ä¤«¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤Ï¶§´ï¤¬ÂÎÆâ¤Ë¿¯Æþ¤·¤¿³ÑÅ٤俼¤µ¤òÇ濳¤¬È½ÃǤ¹¤ë½õ¤±¤Ë¤Ï¤Ê¤ë¤¬¡¢Æ±¤¸ÅÀ¤ò½Å¤Í¤ÆΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë²ò˶¼Ì¿¿¤ò²¿Ëç¤â¸«¤ëɬÍ×À¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤³¤¦½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¡¢ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡Ö¤³¤Î¾Úµò¤ÎÍ£°ì¤Î²Äǽ¤ÊÌÜŪ¤Ï¡¢Ç濳°÷¤Î¿´¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡×¤È·ëÏÀ¤·¡¢ÍºáȽ·è¤òÇË´þ¤·¤Æº¹¤·Ìᤷ¤¿¡£State v. Boyd, 532 P.2d 1064 (Kan. 1975), at1068.
¶¯Å𻦿ͤθ½¾ì¤Ë²£¤¿¤ï¤ëÈï³²¼Ô¤Î¼Ì¿¿¡½¡½¡ÖÈï³²¼Ô¤ÎÇ˲õ¤µ¤ì¤¿´é¡¢Æ¬Éô¤Î½ý¡¢·ìº¯¡¢¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢Àã¤Î¾å¤ÎƬ¤Î¼þ°Ï¤Ë»¶¤é¤Ð¤ëÆùÊÒ¤ÈǾ¤Î°ìÉô¡×¡½¡½¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡¢ÁÊÄɦ¤Ï¡¢½Æ¤ÇƬÉô¤ò·â¤¿¤ì¤¿¤È¤Èï³²¼Ô¤ÎƬÉô¤¬ÃÏÌ̤˶ᤤ°ÌÃ֤ˤ¢¤Ã¤¿¤³¤È¡¢¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¶¯Å𤬽ª¤ï¤Ã¤¿¸å¤ËÈï³²¼Ô¤ò»¦³²¤¹¤ë¤À¤±¤ÎÌÜŪ¤Ç»¦¿Í¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤¿¤³¤È¤òΩ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤ËɬÍפǤ¢¤ë¤È¼çÄ¥¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢¥Ú¥ó¥·¥ë¥Ù¥Ë¥¢½£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¤³¤Î¼çÄ¥¤òÂऱ¤¿¡£
¡Ö¼Ì¿¿¤¬´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¤â¤Î(inflammatory)¤È¤ß¤Ê¤µ¤ì¤ë¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ÎËܼÁŪ¤Ê¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¹âÅ٤Τâ¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤½¤ì¤ò¼èÄ´¤Ù¤ëɬÍ×À¤¬¡¢Ç濳¤ÎÀº¿À¤È¾ð½ï¤ò¤«¤Í𤹲ÄǽÀ¤òÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ë¾å²ó¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤Î¤«¤É¤¦¤«¤òÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎÌ(balancing test)¤·¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£¡Ä¡Ä³Î¤«¤Ë¡¢¥Ú¥ó¥·¥ë¥Ù¥Ë¥¢½£·Ù»¡¤Î¥Þ¥³¥â¥ó¥º·º»ö¤Ï¸øȽ¤Ç¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ò¸«¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤¬·â¤¿¤ì¤¿¤È¤¡¢¤½¤ÎƬÉô¤ÏÃÏÌ̤˶ᤤ¤È¤³¤í¤ÇÃÏÌ̤ÈÊ¿¹Ô¤Î¾õÂÖ¤À¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦°Õ¸«¤ò½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢·º»ö¤Ï¤½¤¦¾Ú¸À¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ò¸«¤ëɬÍפϤʤ«¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤Ê¤¼¤Ê¤é¡¢Èà¤Ï»ö·ï¸å¤Ë¸½¾ì¤Ç»àÂΤȤ½¤Î¾õÂÖ¤ò´Ñ»¡¤·¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤«¤é¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¼ÂºÝ¤Î¤È¤³¤í¡¢¥Þ¥³¥â¥ó¥º·º»ö¤Ï¡¢¤ï¤¶¤ï¤¶¼Ì¿¿¤ò¸«¤Ê¤¯¤Æ¤â¼ÂºÝ¤Ë¸«¤¿¤³¤È¤ò½Ò¤Ù¡¢¼«¤é¤Î´Ñ»¡¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¤¤Æ°Õ¸«¤ò¸À¤¦¤³¤È¤¬¤Ç¤¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡×Commonwealth v. Rogers, 401 A.2d 329 (Pa. 1979), at 330.
È¿ÂФˡ¢¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤Î¿È¸µ¤ä»à°ø¤òÌÀ¤é¤«¤Ë¤·¤¿¤ê¡¢¤µ¤é¤Ë¤ÏÈȹÔÂÖÍͤäÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î°Õ¿Þ¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤò¤â¤Á¡¢¤½¤Î²ÁÃͤ¬Ç濳¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ÆÍýÀŪ¤ÊȽÃǤò˸¤²¤ë´í¸±À¤è¤ê¤âÂ礤¤¤È¤¤Ë¤Ï¡¢¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¡£See, e.g., State v. Needs, 591 P.2d 130 (Idaho 1979); State v. Watts, 441 N.W. 2d 395 (Iowa 1989).
Èï³²¼Ô¤ÎÀ¸Á°¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤â¡¢Æ±Íͤξڵò²ÁÃͤȥꥹ¥¯¤ÎÈæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¡£Èï³²¼Ô¤Î¿È¸µ¤ä¿ÈĹ¤Ê¤É¤Î¿ÈÂÎŪÆÃħ¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤ¬¤¢¤ë¾ì¹ç¤ÏµöÍƤµ¤ì¤ë¤¬¡¢Ç濳¤Î´¶¾ð¤ËÁʤ¨¤ë¤À¤±¤Î¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢µöÍƤµ¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£See, e.g., Ricci v. State, P.2d 79 (Nev. 1975); State v. Finch, 975 P.2d 967 (Wash. 1999).
À±Åç»ö·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç
ˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¤¬¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤âÂÅÅö¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤ÏÀè¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤¿Ä̤ê¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¡¢¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¿Í¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë»àÂΤμ̿¿¤Ï¤ä¤Ï¤ê¡¢ÆüËܿͤδ¶¾ð¤ò¤â¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¤À¤í¤¦¡£¤½¤¦¤¹¤ë¤È¡¢¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤ÎºÛȽ´±¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤Èæ³Ó¹ÍÎ̤òÆüËܤκÛȽ´±¤â¤ä¤é¤Ê¤±¤ì¤Ð¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
À±Åç»ö·ï¤Î¾ì¹ç¤É¤¦¤Ê¤ë¤À¤í¤¦¤«¡£¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤ÎÁÊ°ø¤Ï»¦¿Í¤È»àÂλ²õ°ä´þ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£Èï¹ð¿Í¤ÏÁÊ°ø¤òÁ´¤¯Áè¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£À±Åçµ®ÆÁ»á¤ÏÅì¾ëÎÜÍþ¹á¤µ¤ó¤ò»¦¤·¤Æ¤½¤Î»àÂΤò¥Ð¥é¥Ð¥é¤ËÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤ó¤Ç¼Î¤Æ¤¿¤³¤È¤òÁè¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£Èï³²¼Ô¤Î¿È¸µ¤âÁèÅÀ¤Ë¤Ê¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤¿¤¬¤Ã¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤ÎÆùÊÒ¤ä¹üÊҤμ̿¿¤äÈà½÷¤ÎÀ¸Á°¤Î¥¹¥Ê¥Ã¥×¼Ì¿¿¤Ï¡¢ÁÊ°ø¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤Ï¤Û¤È¤ó¤É²ÁÃͤ¬¤Ê¤¤¡£
ÁÊ°ø¤ò΢ÉÕ¤±¤ëµÒ´ÑŪ¤Ê¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¹ü¤äÆùÊҤʤɤÎʪŪ¾Úµò¤¬É¬ÍפÀ¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤òȯ¸«¤·¤¿Áܺº´±¤Î¶¡½Ò¤ä¤½¤ì¤é¤ÎDNA´ÕÄê¤ò¤·¤¿ÀìÌç²È¤Î°Õ¸«¤¬¤¢¤ì¤Ð½½Ê¬¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤à¤·¤í¤½¤ì¤é¤ÎÊý¤¬¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¹â¤¤¡£¤½¤·¤Æ¤³¤ì¤é¤Ï¤¹¤Ç¤Ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¼è¤êÄ´¤Ù¤é¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£
¤½¤ì¤Ç¤Ï¡¢¤³¤ì¤é¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ÏÎÌ·º»ö¾ð¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤò»ý¤Ä¤À¤í¤¦¤«¡£¤³¤Î»ö·ï¤Ç¤ÏÎÌ·º¡½¡½»à·º¤Ë¤¹¤Ù¤¤«¤É¤¦¤«¡½¡½¤¬¤Þ¤µ¤ËÁèÅÀ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤À¤«¤é¡¢ÎÜÍþ¹á¤µ¤ó¤ÎÆùÊÒ¤ä¹üÊÒ¤äÀ¸Á°¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤¬Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ë»à·º¤òÁªÂò¤µ¤»¤ë¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤò»ý¤Ä¤Ê¤é¤Ð¡¢¤½¤ì¤òºÎÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤âµö¤µ¤ì¤ë¤À¤í¤¦¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¤³¤ì¤é¤Î¾Úµò¤¬»à·ºÁªÂò¤Î¤¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ²ÁÃͤò»ý¤Ä¤³¤È¤Ï¤¢¤ê¤¨¤Ê¤¤¡£
ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¸¡»¡Â¦¤Ï»à·º¤òÀµÅö²½¤¹¤ë¤Û¤É¤Î¡ÖÈȹÔÂÖÍͤλĵԤµ¡×¤ò¾ÚÌÀ¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤È¤·¤Æ¤³¤ì¤é¤Î¾Úµò¤¬É¬ÍפÀ¤È¸À¤¦¤Î¤«¤â¤·¤ì¤Ê¤¤¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢»à·º¤ÎŬÍÑ´ð½à¤ò¼¨¤·¤¿±Ê»³»ö·ïºÇ¹âºÛȽ·è¤¬´ð½à¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æ·Ç¤²¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ï¡Ö»¦³²¤Î¼êÃÊÊýË¡¤Î¼¹Ù¹À¡¦»ÄµÔÀ¡×¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢»àÂΤνèÍýÊýË¡¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤ÏÌäÂê¤Ë¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡ÊºÇ2¾®È½¾¼58¡¦7¡¦8·º½¸37¡¾6¡¾609¡Ë¡£¹ü¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤Ë¤·¤íÆùÊҤμ̿¿¤Ë¤·¤í¡¢¤½¤ì¤é¤Ï¤¹¤Ù¤Æ»àÂλ²õ¤ÎÂÖÍͤò¼¨¤¹¤â¤Î¤Ë¤¹¤®¤Ê¤¤¡£À±Åç»á¤ÏÎÜÍþ¹á¤µ¤ó¤Î¼ó¤ËÊñÃú¤ò»É¤·¤Æ»¦³²¤·¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¡¢À¸¤¤Æ¤¤¤ëÈà½÷¤òÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤ó¤Ç»¦¤·¤¿¤ï¤±¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£
ºÇ¹âºÛ¤Ï¡ÖÈȹԸå¤Î¾ð¾õ¡×¤ò»à·ºÅ¬ÍÑ´ð½à¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤·¤Æµó¤²¤Æ¤¤¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢»àÂλ²õ¤ÎÊýË¡¤Ï¤³¤ì¤Ë´Þ¤á¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£¤Ê¤¼¤Ê¤é¡¢»àÂλ²õºá¤Ï»¦¿Í¤È¤ÏÊ̤ÎÈȺá¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊýË¡¤Ç»àÂΤò½ýÉÕ¤±¤Æ¤âĨÌò3ǯ¤òĶ¤¨¤ëÎÌ·º¤ò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£Ë¡Î§¤Ï¤½¤ì¤òµö¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡Ê·ºË¡190¾ò¡Ë¡£¤È¤¦¤Æ¤¤»à·º¤òÀµÅö²½¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ï¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£
Èï³²¼Ô¤ÎÀ¸Á°¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤Ï¡¢»¦¿Í¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¼º¤ï¤ì¤¿¤â¤Î¤¬²¿¤À¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤«¤ò¼¨¤¹¾Úµò¤À¤È¸À¤¨¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢»¦¿Íºá¤ÎÎÌ·º¤òÀµÅö²½¤¹¤ë¤Î¤Ï¿Í¤ÎÌ¿¤òÃ¥¤Ã¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦»ö¼Â¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤½¤Î¿Í¤¬¶ñÂÎŪ¤Ë¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ê¿ÍÀ¸¤òÊâ¤ó¤Ç¤¤¤¿¤Î¤«¤Ë¤è¤Ã¤Æ¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Ëº¹¤¬½Ð¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïº£Æü¤Î¼Ò²ñ¤Ç¤ÏÀµÅö²½¤Ç¤¤Ê¤¤¡£²È²¤ä»Å»ö¤Ë·Ã¤Þ¤ì¹¬Ê¡¤Ê¿ÍÀ¸¤òÁ÷¤Ã¤¿¿Í¤ò»¦¤·¤¿¾ì¹ç¤È¡¢°Å¤¯À¨»´¤ÊÀ¸³è¤ò½Å¤Í¤Æ¤¤¿¿Í¤ò»¦¤·¤¿¾ì¹ç¤È¤Ç¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Ëº¹¤¬¤¢¤Ã¤ÆÎɤ¤¤È¤¤¤¦Íý¶þ¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£
Íפ¹¤ë¤Ë¡¢ËÜ·ï¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ëÈï³²¼Ô¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ÎÍøÍѤϤ¤¤º¤ì¤â¡¢Áʾ٤ÎÁèÅÀ¤òÍýÀŪ¤Ë²ò·è¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Î¾Úµò¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¤½¤ì¤é¤Ï»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Î´¶¾ð¤ËÁʤ¨¤ë¤À¤±¤Î°ÕÌ£¤·¤«¤Ê¤¤¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤ï¤¬¹ñ¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¡ÖˡΧŪ´ØÏ¢À¤Î¥ë¡¼¥ë¡×¤¬Å¬ÍѤµ¤ì¤ë¤Ê¤é¤Ð¡¢¤³¤ÎºÛȽ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤ÎÆùÊÒ¤ä¹üÊÒ¤½¤·¤ÆÀ¸Á°¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤òÍøÍѤ¹¤ë¤³¤È¤Ïµö¤µ¤ì¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
ËÁƬÄĽҤäÊÛÏÀ¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¼Ì¿¿¤ÎÍøÍÑ
²¾¤Ë¼Ì¿¿¤Î¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤Æ¾Úµò¤È¤·¤ÆµöÍƤµ¤ì¤¿¤È¤·¤Æ¡¢¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤òËÁƬÄĽҤäºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Ç¤É¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë»È¤Ã¤Æ¤âÎɤ¤¤È¤¤¤¦¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ï¤Ê¤é¤Ê¤¤¡£Ë¡Î§Åª´ØÏ¢À¤¬Ç§¤á¤é¤ì¤ÆºÎÍѤµ¤ì¤¿¼Ì¿¿¤Ç¤¢¤Ã¤Æ¤â¡¢ºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Ç¤½¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤òËÜÍè¤ÎÌÜŪ¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë»È¤¦¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Æ¤ë¤¿¤á¤ËÍѤ¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ì¤Ð¡¢¤½¤Î¼ê³¤Ï°ãË¡¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
¤³¤ÎÅÀ¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¤â¥¢¥á¥ê¥«¤Ë¤Ï¤¤¤¯¤Ä¤«¤ÎÀèÎ㤬¤¢¤ë¡£¶¯Åð»ö·ï¤ÎºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Ç¸¡»¡´±¤¬Èï³²¼Ô¤Î»àÂΡÊÈï³²¼Ô¤Ï»ö·ï¤Î¸å¤Ë¾»¦ÂΤÇȯ¸«¤µ¤ì¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢Èï¹ð¿Í¤Ï»¦¿Í¤Ç¤Ïµ¯Áʤµ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¡£¡Ë¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ò¼¨¤·¤Æ¡Ö¥¸¥ç¥ó¡¦¥¦¥£¥ê¥¢¥à¥º[Èï³²¼Ô]¤Ï¤â¤Ï¤ä¤³¤ÎÀ¤¤Ë¤Ï¤¤¤Þ¤»¤ó¡£Èà¤Ï¤Þ¤µ¤Ë¿ÍÀ¸¤Î²Ö¤Î»þÂå¤òÃ¥¤ï¤ì¤¿¤Î¤Ç¤¹¡×¤È½Ò¤Ù¤¿¤³¤È¤Ë¤Ä¤¤¤Æ¡¢¥¤¥ó¥Ç¥£¥¢¥Ê½£ºÇ¹âºÛȽ½ê¤Ï¡¢¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤Æ¡¢¤³¤ì¤ÏÈï¹ð¿Í¤Î¸øÀµ¤ÊºÛȽ¤ò¼õ¤±¤ë¸¢Íø¤òÃ¥¤Ã¤¿¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤È¤·¤ÆͺáȽ·è¤òÇË´þ¤·¤¿¡£
¡Ö¤³¤ì¤Ï»¦¿Í»ö·ï¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¤¡£¾åÁʿͤˤè¤ë¶¯Åð»ö·ï¤ÎÀ®Èݤ¬Ìä¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡Ä¡Ä¥¦¥£¥ê¥¢¥à¥º¤Î»àÂΤμ̿¿¤ò¼¨¤·¤Æ¡¢Èà¤Î»à¤ÎÀÕǤ¤¬¾åÁʿͤˤ¢¤ë¤³¤È¤ò¶¯Ä´¤¹¤ë¸¡»¡´±¤ÎÇ®¶¸Åª¤ÊºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Ï¡¢¾åÁʿͤ¬¸øÀµ¤ÊºÛȽ¤ò¼õ¤±¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¤È¤ï¤ì¤ï¤ì¤Ë¿®¤¸¤µ¤»¤ë¾õ¶·¤Î°ì¤Ä¤È¤¤¤¦¤Ù¤¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¡×Adler v. State, N.E.2d 171 (Ind. 1967), at 173.
À±Åç»ö·ï¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤Æ¡¢Èï³²¼Ô¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤¬Íºá̵ºá¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¡¢ÎÌ·º¤Î¾Úµò¤È¤·¤Æ¤â¾Úµò²ÁÃͤ¬¤Ê¤¤¤³¤È¤Ï¤¹¤Ç¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡£¸¡»¡´±¤Ï¡¢ËÁƬÄĽҤÇÈï³²¼Ô¤ÎÆùÊÒ¤ä¹ü¤Î¼Ì¿¿¤ò¼¨¤·¤Æ¡Ö¤³¤ì¤Ï¡Ä¡ÄÁܺ÷¤Ç¸«¤Ä¤«¤Ã¤¿ÆùÊҤΰìÉô¤Ç¤¹¡£¿¿¤óÃæ¤Î¤¯¤Ü¤ó¤À½ê¤Ï¤ª¤Ø¤½¤Ç¤¹¡£¤Ø¤½¤Î¾å¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Åì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤¬À¸Á°³«¤±¤Æ¤¤¤¿¤È¤¤¤¦¥Ô¥¢¥¹¤Î·ê¤È°ìÃפ·¤Þ¤¹¡£¡Ä¡Ä²¼¤Ë±Ç¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤ë¥á¥¸¥ã¡¼¤«¤é¤âʬ¤«¤ë¤è¤¦¤Ë¡¢¤¹¤Ù¤Æ£µ¥»¥ó¥Á³ÑÄøÅÙ¤ËÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤Þ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£¤³¤ì¤Ï¡¢»Ø¤Î°ìÉô¤Ç¤¹¡×¤Ê¤É¤È½Ò¤Ù¤¿¡ÊMSN»º·Ð¥Ë¥å¡¼¥¹1·î13Æühttp://www.iza.ne.jp/news/newsarticle/event/trial/212005/¡Ë¡£¤Þ¤¿¡¢¸¡»¡´±¤ÏºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤ÎÃæ¤Ç¼¡¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ë½Ò¤Ù¤ÆÈï³²¼Ô¤Î°äÂΤ¬ÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤Þ¤ì¤¿¤³¤È¤ò¤³¤È¤µ¤é¤Ë¶¯Ä´¤·¤¿¡£
¡Ö[À±ÅçÈï¹ð¤Ï]Åì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤Î¼ê¤«¤éÆù¤ò¤½¤®¼è¤ê¡¢¤Þ¤ÊÈĤξå¤ÇÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤ß¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¤½¤ÎÍâÈդˤϡ¢Åì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤ÎƹÂΤ«¤éÊ¢¤ä¶»¤ÎÆù¤ò¤½¤®¼è¤ê¡¢Â¡´ï¤ò¤Þ¤ÊÈĤξå¤ÇÀÚ¤ê¹ï¤ß¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¤µ¤é¤ËÍâÈÕ¡Ä¡¢¼ª¤ò¤½¤®¡¢Æ¬³¸¹ü¡Ê¤º¤¬¤¤¤³¤Ä¡Ë¤ò¤Î¤³¤®¤ê¤ÇÀÚ¤ê¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¹ü¤Ï¥´¥ßÂÞ¤ËÆþ¤ì¤Æ±£¤·¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¤¬¡¢Éå¤é¤»¤Æ¶¯Îõ¤ÊÉ彤¬È¯À¸¤·¤¿¤¿¤á¡¢ÈȹԤ¬È¯³Ð¤·¤Ê¤¤¤è¤¦¤ËÆé¤Ç¤æ¤Ç¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£À±ÅçÈï¹ð¤ÏÅì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤Î°äÂΤò¡¢¼«¸Ê¤ÎÀ¸³è¤ÈÂÎÌ̤ò¼é¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¼Ù°¤Ê¡Èʪ¡É¤È¤·¤Æ̵»Ä¤Ë°·¤¤¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£¡×¡Ö£±¥«·î°Ê¾å¤â±ø¿å¤Î¿åή¤ËÂѤ¨¤¿¹üÊҤϡ¢Ç¦ÂѶ¯¤«¤Ã¤¿Åì¾ë¤µ¤ó¤Î²ù¤·¤µ¡¢ÌµÇ°¤µ¤òÁʤ¨¤«¤±¤Æ¤¤¤ë¤«¤Î¤è¤¦¤Ç¤¹¡£¡×MSN»º·Ð¥Ë¥å¡¼¥¹2009ǯ1·î26Æü¡¢http://sankei.jp.msn.com/affairs/trial/090126/trl0901261449015-n1.htm
¤³¤ÎºÇ½ªÊÛÏÀ¤Î°Õ¿Þ¤Ï¡¢»à·ºÁªÂò¤Î´ð½à¤Ë¾È¤é¤·¤ÆËÜ·ï¤Ç¤Ï»à·º¤òÁªÂò¤¹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¹çÍýŪ¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤³¤È¤òÏÀ¾Ú¤¹¤ë¤È¤¤¤¦¤è¤¦¤Ê¤â¤Î¤Ç¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¡¢»ö¼ÂǧÄê¼Ô¤Î´¶¾ð¤ò¤«¤¤¿¤Ædz¤¨À¹¤ëÅܤê¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯È½ÃǤòµá¤á¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£¤³¤Î¤è¤¦¤ÊÊÛÏÀ¤Ï¸øÀµ¤ÊºÛȽ¤ÎÂжˤˤ¢¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
·ëÏÀ
¤³¤ì¤Þ¤Ç¤Î·º»öºÛȽ¤Ï¡¢¡ÖºÛȽ´±¤Ï¥×¥í¥Õ¥§¥Ã¥·¥ç¥Ê¥ë¤Ç¤¢¤ê¡¢´¶¾ð¤Ëή¤µ¤ì¤ºÍýÀŪ¤ËºÛȽ¤ò¤¹¤ë¤â¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡×¤È¤¤¤¦Á°Äó¤Ç¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤¿¡£¤³¤ÎÁ°Äó¤¬Àµ¤·¤¤¤Î¤«¤ÏÂ礤¤Ëµ¿Ì䤬¤¢¤ë¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢¾Úµò¤ÎµöÍÆÀ¤ÎȽÃǤò¤¹¤ë¤Î¤¬Åö¤ÎºÛȽ´±¤Ç¤¢¤ë¤«¤é¡¢¡Ö¤³¤Î¾Úµò¤ÏºÛȽ´±¡Ê¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¼«Ê¬¼«¿È¡Ë¤ÎÍýÀ¤ò¶¸¤ï¤»¤ë¡×¤Ê¤É¤È¤¤¤¦¥¹¥È¥¤¥Ã¥¯¤Ê¥ë¡¼¥ë¤ÎŬÍѤò´üÂÔ¤¹¤Ù¤¯¤â¤Ê¤«¤Ã¤¿¡£¤·¤«¤·¡¢ºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Ç¤Ï¤³¤Î¥Õ¥£¥¯¥·¥ç¥ó¤Ï¤Ê¤¯¤Ê¤ë¡£É¾µÄ¼¼¤ÎÃæ¤ÇÀµµÁ¤ÈÍýÀ¤Ë´ð¤Å¤¯É¾µÄ¤¬¹Ô¤ï¤ì¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Ë¡Äî¤ËÄó½Ð¤µ¤ì¤ë¾Úµò¤ÎÁªÊ̤¬É¬ÍפǤ¢¤ë¡£¤¹¤Ê¤ï¤Á¡¢ºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤¬À®¸ù¤¹¤ë¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢Ë¡Î§²È¤¬¾ÚµòË¡¤Î¸·³Ê¤ÊŬÍѤ˰դòÍѤ¤¤ë¤³¤È¤¬ÉԲķç¤Ê¤Î¤Ç¤¢¤ë¡£
°Ê¾å
2008ǯ11·î18Æü
¤Þ¤¿ËܤÎÀëÅÁ¡£
¹âÌîδÊÔÃø¡Ø¥±¡¼¥¹¥Ö¥Ã¥¯·º»ö¾ÚµòË¡¡Ù¡Ê¸½Âå¿Íʸ¼Ò¡Ë¡£
¥í¡¼¥¹¥¯¡¼¥ë¤Î¼ø¶È¤Ç»È¤ï¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤òǰƬ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤¿¶µºà¤Ç¤¹¤¬¡¢·º»öÊÛ¸î¤ò¤ä¤ëÊÛ¸î»Î¤ËÆɤó¤Ç¤â¤é¤¤¤¿¤¤¤È»×¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
ÆüËܤÎË¡Äî¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¾ÚµòË¡¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Î¸úΨ¤È¤¤¤¦×ó°ÕŪ¤ÊÍ×ÁǤ¬¾ÚµòË¡¤Î´ðËܸ¶Â§¤è¤ê¤âÍ¥À褵¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£ºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Ç¤Ï¤³¤Î°ÊÀ¤ò¤Ê¤ó¤È¤«¼è¤ê½ü¤¯É¬Íפ¬¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£
¤½¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ÊÛ¸î»Î¤¬¼ÂÁ©¤ÎÃæ¤Ç¾ÚµòË¡¤ÎµÄÏÀ¤òÀâÆÀŪ¤ËŸ³«¤Ç¤¤ëɬÍפ¬¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£
Ëܽñ¤Ç»ä¤Ï¡¢ÂåɽŪ¤ÊÆüËܤÎȽÎã¤òÌÖÍ夹¤ë¤È¤È¤â¤Ë¡¢Ë¡Äî¤Ç¤ÎµÄÏÀ¤ËÌò¤ËΩ¤Ä¤È»×¤¦Æâ³°¤ÎȽÎã¤äË¡Îᡢʸ¸¥¤ò¤ò¼ýÏ¿¤·¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£
¥±¡¼¥¹¥Ö¥Ã¥¯·º»ö¾ÚµòË¡
¹âÌîδÊÔÃø¡Ø¥±¡¼¥¹¥Ö¥Ã¥¯·º»ö¾ÚµòË¡¡Ù¡Ê¸½Âå¿Íʸ¼Ò¡Ë¡£
¥í¡¼¥¹¥¯¡¼¥ë¤Î¼ø¶È¤Ç»È¤ï¤ì¤ë¤³¤È¤òǰƬ¤Ë¤ª¤¤¤¿¶µºà¤Ç¤¹¤¬¡¢·º»öÊÛ¸î¤ò¤ä¤ëÊÛ¸î»Î¤ËÆɤó¤Ç¤â¤é¤¤¤¿¤¤¤È»×¤Ã¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£
ÆüËܤÎË¡Äî¤Ë¤ª¤±¤ë¾ÚµòË¡¤Ï¡¢ºÛȽ´±¤Î¸úΨ¤È¤¤¤¦×ó°ÕŪ¤ÊÍ×ÁǤ¬¾ÚµòË¡¤Î´ðËܸ¶Â§¤è¤ê¤âÍ¥À褵¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Þ¤¹¡£ºÛȽ°÷ºÛȽ¤Ç¤Ï¤³¤Î°ÊÀ¤ò¤Ê¤ó¤È¤«¼è¤ê½ü¤¯É¬Íפ¬¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£
¤½¤Î¤¿¤á¤Ë¤Ï¡¢ÊÛ¸î»Î¤¬¼ÂÁ©¤ÎÃæ¤Ç¾ÚµòË¡¤ÎµÄÏÀ¤òÀâÆÀŪ¤ËŸ³«¤Ç¤¤ëɬÍפ¬¤¢¤ê¤Þ¤¹¡£
Ëܽñ¤Ç»ä¤Ï¡¢ÂåɽŪ¤ÊÆüËܤÎȽÎã¤òÌÖÍ夹¤ë¤È¤È¤â¤Ë¡¢Ë¡Äî¤Ç¤ÎµÄÏÀ¤ËÌò¤ËΩ¤Ä¤È»×¤¦Æâ³°¤ÎȽÎã¤äË¡Îᡢʸ¸¥¤ò¤ò¼ýÏ¿¤·¤Þ¤·¤¿¡£
¥±¡¼¥¹¥Ö¥Ã¥¯·º»ö¾ÚµòË¡